André Pratte: A last word on Jean Charest's defeat

Jean Charest takes part in the Conservative Party of Canada English leadership debate on May 11, 2022.

A recent column of mine has angered many in Jean Charest’s leadership campaign organization, including within his family. In that column, I wrote that Charest’s crushing defeat against Pierre Poilievre was a “gloomy end” to his political life.

In her comment published on the Post’s website on September 26, former Charest Communications Director Michelle Coates Mather disagrees with the criticism of the campaign expressed by “Pratte and others in the pundit class”.

After reading Ms. Mather’s text and having heard a great deal from others close to Charest and his campaign, I read my column again to see whether I was as unfair to the candidate as they believe I was. 

Although I am sorry that I hurt so many people’s feelings, I stand by what I wrote. Perhaps I would have changed a word or two. “Gloomy” was too strong a qualifier, I should have written “sad.” The paragraph about Charest’s age could have been written differently. But overall, I believe the column was based on unchallengeable facts and was fair to the candidate and his organization.

Unlike Ms. Mather, I did not research “Jean Charest” on the web before agreeing to join his campaign. I have known Charest for 40 years. As a reporter and then editorial writer, I covered, admired, and defended him in the best and worst times of his career. I wrote an early biography, for which I interviewed over 100 of his colleagues, friends, and members of his family.

I volunteered for his campaign because I was convinced, as I still am, that he would have made the best prime minister for these troubled times in our country’s history.

True, I wasn’t “intimately involved with the campaign.” However, I was in regular contact with people who were, including the candidate himself and members of his family.

Even though in the end I played only a minuscule role, I paid a significant professional price for joining the campaign. I used whatever credibility I had left to convince people that Charest was the right person, and that this was the right time. I sold membership cards. It is just too easy to dismiss my opinion by pushing me in the corner of the “armchair quarterbacks.”

The Charest people’s main point is that he ran a great campaign, and therefore that there is nothing to be sad about. I agree that he did run a very good campaign and that even when his chances of winning went up in smoke, as I wrote, “the candidate, dogged as always, fought until the end.” But I disagree that the outcome is a happy end to his career. Good campaign or not, the results were simply catastrophic. Asserting that something went terribly wrong is not being disloyal, mean or ill-informed; it is stating the obvious.

Ms. Mather accuses me of “ageism,” This is surprising considering that I am one year older than Charest. My point regarding age was that, because of the generation gap, many Conservatives simply did not know Charest as we knew him. This point was made to me by very senior organizers within the campaign.

Anyway, the main argument of my op-ed was that had I known my country and the Conservative party better, I would have detected early on the strength of the pro-Poilievre movement. Having done so, I would have advised Charest not to run, for his and his family’s sake, because I consider myself his friend (although possibly that friendship is over now…). It is bizarre that a piece that was essentially self-critical was seen by his organizers as an attack on them.

Since Charest’s defeat, it appears that most of those organizers have decided to rally behind the new leader, as if this was some ordinary leadership race. It wasn’t. This is how Jean Charest put it last May: 

“The question we face is very serious. Will we in the Conservative party take the path of American-style politics, attack politics, politics where we pit one group against another, politics where we make slogans and every answer is a dodge?”

Many joined the Charest camp because we believed that Pierre Poilievre was a risk for Canadian democracy and the rule of law. And now we should cheer him as if nothing happened? As if Poilievre had not called our candidate all sorts of names, going so low as to refuse to shake his hand? Poilievre may rise to the occasion and become a good Leader of the Opposition and even Prime Minister. However, for now, I remain guarded.

As for Jean Charest, he certainly can be proud of his remarkable political achievements, including running a principled, dignified leadership campaign. My column only meant to highlight that he deserved for that career to end on a happier note.

André Pratte played a very minor role in Jean Charest’s Conservative leadership campaign.


Look: Big Ten Head Coach Urged To 'Clean House'

COLLEGE PARK, MD – OCTOBER 04: A view of the Big Ten logo on the field during the game between the Maryland Terrapins and the Ohio State Buckeyes at Byrd Stadium on October 4, 2014 in College Park, Maryland. (Photo by G Fiume/Maryland Terrapins/Getty Images) There were a handful ...

View more: Look: Big Ten Head Coach Urged To 'Clean House'

Former gov’t official: Filber blocked us from acting for the public interest

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu attends the weekly cabinet meeting at his office in Jerusalem. The public corruption trial of Prime Minister-designate Benjamin Netanyahu continued on Monday with the testimony of former Communications Ministry official Yair Hakak, who explained aspects of the prosecution’s regulatory side of the Bezeq-Walla media ...

View more: Former gov’t official: Filber blocked us from acting for the public interest

Laurentian University exits creditor protection following insolvency

Laurentian University, which filed for insolvency in February 2021, has exited the CCAA process meant to restructure its operations as it worked to overcome its financial problems. Laurentian University in Sudbury, Ont., has exited the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA) restructuring process that followed its insolvency in February 2021. ...

View more: Laurentian University exits creditor protection following insolvency

Kevin Spacey Signs First Movie After Winning $40 Million Sex Abuse Lawsuit

Kevin Spacey. Kevin Spacey has reportedly nabbed a new movie role amid the ongoing lawsuits surrounding him. According to Variety, Spacey will be starring in an upcoming British indie thriller, titled “Control”. Spacey will reportedly play a voice role in the upcoming project, with Variety comparing it to Kiefer ...

View more: Kevin Spacey Signs First Movie After Winning $40 Million Sex Abuse Lawsuit

Windsor woman accused of giving hundreds of fraudulent discounts

A store employee works at a cashier desk at a retail business in New Jersey on Nov. 25, 2022. A 61-year-old Windsor woman is facing charges after police investigated hundreds of illegal discounts being given at her workplace. Windsor Police Service said its Financial Crimes Unit began investigating on ...

View more: Windsor woman accused of giving hundreds of fraudulent discounts

College Football Starting Quarterback Transferring After Final Game

(Photo by David Madison/Getty Images) A college football starting quarterback has reportedly decided to transfer. Davis Brin, the starting quarterback at Tulsa, has reportedly entered the transfer portal. Tulsa’s starting quarterback threw for 2,138 yards and 17 touchdowns this season. He added two rushing touchdowns. On3 first reported the ...

View more: College Football Starting Quarterback Transferring After Final Game

Dog Loves Helping with the Laundry and Our Hearts Can't Take It

What an absolute angel! Dogs are wonderful for many reasons, and one of those reasons are that they are natural helpers and workers. Many different dogs were bred to perform specific jobs in the past, and in the present day, our pups are still happy to help out in ...

View more: Dog Loves Helping with the Laundry and Our Hearts Can't Take It

Former Vancouver Canucks staffer claims discrimination in claim against team

A former video analyst with the Vancouver Canucks has filed a human rights complaint claiming the organization discriminated against her when they fired her this fall. Rachel Doerrie, 25, claimed the team’s assistant manager, Émilie Castonguay, made discriminatory comments about her mental health before the team fired her for an “unreasonable and flimsy” ...

View more: Former Vancouver Canucks staffer claims discrimination in claim against team

Breakenridge: Calgary shouldn't let complex social issues sidetrack it from making transit safer now

Emirates Boeing 777 vs Airbus A380 Business Class: Which Cabin Is Best?

Kellyanne Conway appears before Jan. 6 committee as panel races to finish report

Cowboys Locked in NFC East Dogfight

Chicago Med Wedding! Get a First Look at April and Ethan's 'Classic and Yet Glamorous' Nuptials

Helena Bonham Carter Began Menopause as Her Children Hit Puberty: 'You're Both Basically Going Insane'

Patients wait months for Pap test results as labs juggle high demand, staff shortage

Tyler Hikoalok murder trial set to resume Tuesday as case turns to defence

New review reveals potential positives of virtual overdose monitoring systems

Businesses relieved as Trudeau's $2.3-billion Asia strategy leaves room to deal with China

Mississauga-Lakeshore byelection voters head to the polls Dec. 12

Alleged Chinese spy who worked for Hydro-Québec freed on bail ahead of trial


Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network