Family lose three dogs to Parvovirus
Passengers caught up in the Ruby Princess cruise ship outbreak could be on the hook for a hefty legal bill after rejecting an early $15 million settlement offer from the cruise line.
In October 2023, the Federal Court found Carnival was negligent in its duty of care and misled passengers about safety on board before the ill-fated March 2020 voyage.
The ship departed Sydney only to return with 663 positive cases amongst the 2641 passengers, which included 1679 Australians. The voyage led to 28 deaths.
Just prior to a trial which began in October 2022, Carnival offered to settle the case for $15 million.
This was rejected by the passengers, who returned with a counter-offer of $69 million.
The larger sum was rejected by Carnival and the trial began, leading to Justice Angus Stewart’s landmark October 2023 judgment.
In his findings against Carnival, the judge ordered the company to pay lead plaintiff Susan Karpik $4423 plus interest for her out-of-pocket medical expenses.
Karpik had originally sought over $360,000 for damages to injuries, distress and disappointment.
On Wednesday, Justice Stewart ordered Carnival to pay Karpik and her legal team at Shine Lawyers their costs of running the case up until the $15 million settlement offer was made on October 5, 2022.
However, he refrained from deciding who should pay the costs past that date until the total amount of compensation owed to passengers eligible for the class action was determined.
Judges have the ability to order a successful plaintiff to pay the legal costs of a defeated party if the amount they receive through court is less than that offered in a rejected settlement.
Karpik argued it was reasonable to reject Carnival’s settlement offer because the deduction of between $5.85 million and $6.75 million in legal costs would have left passengers with only a “relatively modest amount”.
However, Justice Stewart said it was currently impossible to determine how much Carnival would have to pay.
There was no way to assess how many passengers were eligible for compensation and what the size of their claims were, he said.
Karpik’s individual claim revolved around the illness of her husband Henry, who had to be placed in an induced four-week coma after contracting the virus, and his need for ongoing care.
The Ruby Princess departed from Sydney for New Zealand on a 13-day round trip, but returned 11 days later when Australia’s borders were shut in the early days of the pandemic.
The matter will next come before the court on April 12.
News Related
-
-
-
FILE PHOTO: A man walks in the Central Business District on a rainy day, in Beijing, China, July 12, 2023. REUTERS/Thomas Peter/File Photo By Joe Cash, Ellen Zhang and Kane Wu BEIJING/HONG KONG (Reuters) – U.S. furniture company head Jordan England thinks his firm’s Chinese suppliers are among the best ...
See Details:
Analysis-West's de-risking starts to bite China's prospects
-
Independent senators are trying a parliamentary tactic last successful 90 years ago to give first responders PTSD protections and end domestic violence discrimination in the workplace. Senators Jacqui Lambie and David Pocock took four elements of Labor’s larger workplace law reform bill and it passed the Senate against the government’s ...
See Details:
'Beyond a joke' Labor won't ensure PTSD protections: MP
-
-
-
-
Photograph: Rod McGuirk/AP The stateless Rohingyan refugee who successfully overturned the legality of indefinite immigration detention was accidentally named in documents published by the high court. The man was identified by his surname in a home affairs department email providing an internal update about the case, which was among documents ...
See Details:
Rohingyan refugee NZYQ accidentally named in documents published by high court
-
Photograph: Rod McGuirk/AP The stateless Rohingyan refugee who successfully overturned the legality of indefinite immigration detention was accidentally named in documents published by the high court. The man was identified by his surname in a home affairs department email providing an internal update about the case, which was among documents ...
See Details:
Colorado loses commitments of 2 more high school recruits
-
Photograph: Rod McGuirk/AP The stateless Rohingyan refugee who successfully overturned the legality of indefinite immigration detention was accidentally named in documents published by the high court. The man was identified by his surname in a home affairs department email providing an internal update about the case, which was among documents ...
See Details:
Queensland Health issues urgent patient safety alert over national bacteria outbreak
-
Photograph: Rod McGuirk/AP The stateless Rohingyan refugee who successfully overturned the legality of indefinite immigration detention was accidentally named in documents published by the high court. The man was identified by his surname in a home affairs department email providing an internal update about the case, which was among documents ...
See Details:
Townsville Community Pantry 'distressed' by fruit, vegetable waste at Aldi supermarket
-
Photograph: Rod McGuirk/AP The stateless Rohingyan refugee who successfully overturned the legality of indefinite immigration detention was accidentally named in documents published by the high court. The man was identified by his surname in a home affairs department email providing an internal update about the case, which was among documents ...
See Details:
What Is The Beaver Moon And What Does It Mean For You?
-
Photograph: Rod McGuirk/AP The stateless Rohingyan refugee who successfully overturned the legality of indefinite immigration detention was accidentally named in documents published by the high court. The man was identified by his surname in a home affairs department email providing an internal update about the case, which was among documents ...
See Details:
Labor senator Pat Dodson to resign from politics due to health issues
-
Photograph: Rod McGuirk/AP The stateless Rohingyan refugee who successfully overturned the legality of indefinite immigration detention was accidentally named in documents published by the high court. The man was identified by his surname in a home affairs department email providing an internal update about the case, which was among documents ...
See Details:
Hamas releases 11 more hostages, as Israel agrees to extend ceasefire
OTHER NEWS
Disrupt Burrup Hub group say police have issued move-on notices prohibiting access to the WA site. A group of climate activists and filmmakers say their phones have been seized during ...
Read more »
As individuals, we have unique experiences that affect our mental health and wellbeing, but what about the collective experiences that influence each generation? The mental health of Australians has been ...
Read more »
Syed Ghazaly wants to see the Geraldton abattoir reopen early next year to process 1,000 sheep a day. (ABC Mid West Wheatbelt: Chris Lewis) The new owners of a mothballed ...
Read more »
Carlton coach Michael Voss says he and his players understand there are heightened expectations on them, but insists the Blues are ready to develop individually and in their game plan. ...
Read more »
The Bulldogs’ off-season signing frenzy is set to continue with the club reportedly set to land Cronnor Tracey in a swap deal. The Sydney Morning Herald reports Tracey is expected ...
Read more »
Consumers and impacted businesses are being urged to have their say on the Optus outage, with the federal government laying out the terms of reference for its review into the ...
Read more »
It has been revealed a released immigration detainee is unable to be contacted by authorities. Border Force has referred the matter to the Federal Police as authorities are attempting to ...
Read more »