Call for harder line on how we judge conservation
Credit: CC0 Public Domain

James Cook University scientists say a more direct approach should be taken to conservation planning—with greater focus on the real impact of conservation actions and less attention paid to targets or actions that misrepresent progress.

Dr. Patrick Smallhorn-West is a Research Fellow at JCU’s ARC Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies. In a recent article he said that conservation only functions by changing human actions, so if conservationists make choices that avoid interfering with human damage to nature, they are also necessarily limiting their impact.

“For example, marine protected areas can incur costs to fishers, and national parks can incur lost opportunities for agriculture, mining, logging, or grazing,” said Dr. Smallhorn-West.

“Controlling these activities therefore carries political and societal costs. But fishing, agriculture, and mining are also some of the key activities affecting nature.”

He said much of conservation planning and research focuses on minimizing the costs incurred by fishing, logging, and mining.

“But this widespread emphasis on minimizing costs has resulted in the paradoxical development of conservation goals with little actual impact for nature,” said Dr. Smallhorn-West.

He said one example of this was the 2004 rezoning of the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park, which increased highly protected areas from 4.6 percent to 33.3 percent of the Park, but still only reduced the extent of business-as-usual trawling by less than 5 percent and areas trawled more than once by less than 1 percent.

This same pattern followed the 2018 design of Australia’s National system of Marine Protected Areas, where high protection was greatest in deep water (>500 m), and had negligible overlap with pelagic longlining areas (0.4%) or trawling grounds (0.1%), and only limited fishing by 1 percent and petroleum extraction by 4.5 percent.

He said the results aren’t limited to Australia—globally, the largest 10 marine protected areas, collectively making up 53 percent of the world’s coverage and whose main purpose is to limit fishing, are almost all situated in remote areas that already have low levels of fishing.

Dr. Smallhorn-West said if these vast conservation networks fail to change any present-day actions, then the question needs to be asked about what exactly they are meant to achieve.

“We understand that nature conservation is only one of society’s values, and hence needs to be balanced with other things we hold dear. But if we accept that preserving nature through reduced resource consumption is a goal of conservation, then we must also accept that minimizing costs will also minimize impact.

He said there should be a change in the language of conservation to focus explicitly on the differences conservation actions make, with more value assigned to their practical impact.

“The value we attribute to a conservation action should be correlated to the extent to which it changes human actions—after all, if human impacts were not causing harm to nature, then nature conservation would not be necessary,” said Dr. Smallhorn-West.

“Put another way, the predominant question should be ‘how much does/will this intervention change what people are doing’? This would extend the idea through society that conservation is about giving something up, while balancing these societal values with others such as reducing poverty and inequalities.”

He said organizations, governments, and other bodies promoting examples of easy conservation wins with minimal disruption of present-day actions should be viewed with caution.

“The only chance these projects have of achieving impact is by their potential effects of future human actions, which is problematic in three ways: first, it lets business as usual continue in areas needing protection; second, it passes the responsibility for change onto future generations; and third, there is always the possibility of conservation programs being canceled in the future. We need to act now.

“Making the language used to communicate conservation progress, targets, and planning more honest and more explicitly focused on the differences our actions make will help to realign our efforts with the effective preservation of nature,” said Dr. Smallhorn-West.

More information: Patrick F. Smallhorn‐West et al, Why does conservation minimize opportunity costs?, Conservation Science and Practice (2022). DOI: 10.1111/csp2.12808

Provided by James Cook University

Citation: Call for harder line on how we judge conservation (2022, November 24) retrieved 24 November 2022 from https://phys.org/news/2022-11-harder-line.html This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

NEWS RELATED

Nest Rolls Out a Slew of New Holiday Ringtones for Your Doorbell

Google It’s that time of the year again. The minute Thanksgiving is over, the Christmas tree and lights start going up. Throughout the year, Google releases new Nest doorbell tones that are fun and festive, and for the 2022 holiday, we’re getting five new Nest doorbell ringtones. More importantly, ...

View more: Nest Rolls Out a Slew of New Holiday Ringtones for Your Doorbell

6 of the biggest new Netflix releases coming next week

I hope you’ve cleared out your streaming watchlist, because Netflix is teeing up a slew of new releases over the next several days that will dominate viewership on the platform over the coming week. As we do each weekend, we’ll walk through a curated selection of some of the biggest ...

View more: 6 of the biggest new Netflix releases coming next week

7 Ways to Fix iPhone Calendar Search Not Working

Want to check out the dates of your past or upcoming meeting or travel plans? Or when was your last or next doctor’s appointment? Well, you can search for the appointment and event in your Calendar app. But what if the iPhone Calendar search feature is not working? Well, this ...

View more: 7 Ways to Fix iPhone Calendar Search Not Working

This Wanted Man Finally Gets Arrested After Commenting on Sheriff's Facebook Post

This could be the easiest police manhunt in history. This fugitive from Georgia essentially helped local law enforcement to arrest him after he commented on the Rockdale County Sheriff’s Office’s Facebook page. How About Me? When this sheriff’s office posted a “Most Wanted List” for November, something unexpected happened in ...

View more: This Wanted Man Finally Gets Arrested After Commenting on Sheriff's Facebook Post

Samsung's next-gen OLED screens might support multi-fingerprint sensing

Samsung could usher in the next era of fingerprint sensing technology on OLED displays. The South Korean company is reportedly working on OLED displays with multi-fingerprint sensing technology. Dubbed OLED 2.0, these screens are capable of scanning multiple fingerprints at the same time. This would eliminate the need for ...

View more: Samsung's next-gen OLED screens might support multi-fingerprint sensing

Amazon Basics Office Products and Electronics Are Now Discounted up to 38%

Stock up and save on batteries, surge protectors, memory cards and more with this limited-time deal.

View more: Amazon Basics Office Products and Electronics Are Now Discounted up to 38%

SIM swapper gets 18-months for involvement in $22 million crypto heist

Florida man Nicholas Truglia was sentenced to 18 months in prison on Thursday for his involvement in a fraud scheme that led to the theft of millions from cryptocurrency investor Michael Terpin. The funds were stolen following a January 2018 SIM swap attack that allowed Truglia’s co-conspirators to hijack ...

View more: SIM swapper gets 18-months for involvement in $22 million crypto heist

How to Use the Same WhatsApp Account on Two Phones Officially

WhatsApp is one of the most widely-used instant messaging apps despite lacking several features. For example, Telegram lets you use the same account on multiple devices but unfortunately, the same wasn’t possible on WhatsApp — until now. You can now use the same WhatsApp account on two phones officially! The ...

View more: How to Use the Same WhatsApp Account on Two Phones Officially

Scientists Discover That Binge-Eating Sweet Treats Is Influenced by Gut Microbiome

Bayesian search: A simple rule to find stuff you’ve lost

What We’re Playing: ‘Star Trek Timelines’ Free-to-Play in the Final Frontier

Funko Pop spoils the design of a major MCU Phase 5 villain

Hackers use new, fake crypto app to breach networks, steal cryptocurrency

How to Create and Join Amazon Prime Video Watch Party

Advanced “Lab on a Chip” – Scientists Have Created a Powerful, Ultra-Tiny Spectrometer

Possible that Twitter gave preference to leftists during Brazil election: Elon Musk

Northrop Grumman Unveils US Air Force's B-21 Stealth Nuclear Strategic Bomber

Archaeologists Uncover 1,900-Year-Old Snacks Underneath Rome's Ancient Colosseum

Motorola Edge 30 Fusion Launches In The US With The Most Unique Color Ever

How giant-faced owls snag voles hidden in snow

OTHER NEWS

Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network