Campaign signs influence how we vote more than you might realize

Campaign signs are posted outside a polling location on the first day of early voting on July 15 in Nashville, Tenn. Jonathan Mattise/AP hide caption

toggle caption Jonathan Mattise/AP

With election season in full swing, seemingly every neighborhood and busy intersection is sprouting dozens of multicolored signs touting candidates for offices ranging from register of wills to U.S. Senate.

Often, these signs proclaim a candidate’s name, but not much else. You might have wondered, how effective can they be as a campaign tool, especially in an age of radio, television and social media? Are they even a smart placeto put campaign resources, particularly in local races, where funds are tight?

It turns out political scientists have tried to answer these questions.

A 2015 study led by Donald Green, a political science professor at Columbia University, found that political signs can in fact make a difference — “somewhere between 1 and 2 percentage points on average,” Green says. “Hardly earth shattering, but not nothing, either.” In races that are especially close, they might just be the deciding factor.

The “Ben Griffin” experiment

What’s primarily at stake when it comes to signs is name recognition — especially for many local races that don’t generate a lot of attention, according to Cindy Kam, a professor at Vanderbilt University who leads the Research on Individuals, Politics & Society Lab.

Kam co-authored a study in 2011 in which yard signs for a fictitious county council candidate — “Ben Griffin” — were planted on lawns on a well-trafficked street near a school. A survey was mailed out a few days later by the school’s Parent Teacher Association asking respondents to list their choices for the county’s at-large council seats. Five real candidates were listed along with the fictitious Ben Griffin and another made-up name.

Incredibly, nearly a quarter of respondents listed the fictional Ben Griffin among their top three picks.

Campaign signs influence how we vote more than you might realize

Neighbors display political yard signs in front of their homes in Grosse Pointe, Mich., in October 2020. Kimberly P. Mitchell/USA Today Network/Reuters hide caption

toggle caption Kimberly P. Mitchell/USA Today Network/Reuters

Kam concludes that in races where little information is available, “having some sense of name recognition, having seen a name, having seen multiple signs that convey a sense of viability [and] electability can be useful.”

But Matt Compton, a senior vice president at Blue State, which helps to support progressive causes and campaigns, says his experience is that political signage can make a significant difference in higher-profile races as well.

Case in point: the 2008 presidential primaries, when both Republicans and Democrats had roughly 10 candidates each vying for their party’s nomination.

“[It] was pretty crowded,” says Compton, who previously worked in the White House’s Office of Digital Strategy under then-President Barack Obama. “So, just finding a way to stand out and to be recognizable in a really crowded marketplace like that is an effective use of campaign time and dollars.”

The simpler the message, the better

Keeping things simple seems to be key in increasing name recognition and there’s evidence that a cluttered message can do more harm than good.

Brandon Lenoir, who studies political communication and campaigns at High Point University and worked with Green on the 2015 study, says they found that signs without partisan cues actually got the message across better than ones that identified a candidate’s party affiliation.

“It seems that just putting your name out there and what you’re running for is more effective than actually trying to make a plea for being a progressive or a conservative or a Republican or a Democrat,” he says.

Campaign signs influence how we vote more than you might realize

Mark Mumford, clerk of the Circuit Court for Kent County, Md., walks through a mass of political placards as he arrives to check on voter turnout in Maryland’s early voting at the Kent County Public Library in Chestertown on Oct. 25, 2018. Jim Watson/AFP via Getty Images hide caption

toggle caption Jim Watson/AFP via Getty Images

More generally, that simplicity is something Christopher Nicholas, a veteran Republican political consultant, says he tries to impress on clients.

“The mistake people make is they want to cram it with too much information. I remind them that people are driving by these signs, not walking by the signs,” Nicholas says.

Party affiliation, however, can be transmitted in more subtle ways, says Kenneth Worles Jr., president of Three(i) Creative Communications, which works with Democratic and progressive candidates.

Voters, he says, have begun to internalize the blue and red party colors that have become popular identifiers in recent years. “If a Republican is running in a Democratic city, I guarantee you that Republican is going to have a little more blue” in their sign, he says.

Signs can also motivate volunteers

Nicholas says campaign signs serve another important purpose: to help motivate staff and volunteers.

He recalls a campaign he worked on in the 1980s to reelect a Republican congressional candidate in Indiana. Otherwise loyal campaign volunteers complained that in the previous election, the candidate “didn’t even have a yard sign,” he says.

“People see these signs as part and parcel of what a campaign needs to be doing,” Nicholas says. “Without them, things feel a little naked.”

How vital, then, are signs to political campaigns? Vanderbilt’s Kam thinks they could be more important than ever, given the current media landscape. Local news she argues, “is almost a dying breed” and political coverage has become “massively nationalized.”

“I would say in some of these races, we do not have tons of information,” she says. If candidates are wanting to get name recognition, “political signs that people see in their day-to-day lives” might be the best way to do it.

NEWS RELATED

Biden wants to bump Iowa, make South Carolina the first primary state

Biden cited a need for more diversity in the nominating process. Michael Brochstein/Sipa USA President Biden has proposed a radical shakeup of the Democratic presidential nominating process that would make South Carolina the first primary state, bumping Iowa from the top spot. The plan was announced by Democratic Party ...

View more: Biden wants to bump Iowa, make South Carolina the first primary state

Scattered easing of Covid-19 curbs across China after week of unrest

BEIJING – Some communities in Chinese cities where Covid-19 is still spreading are easing off on testing requirements and quarantine rules in a marked shift in virus policies after widespread protests across the country. China is set to announce an easing of its Covid-19 quarantine rules in the coming days ...

View more: Scattered easing of Covid-19 curbs across China after week of unrest

Grand jury indicts former San Antonio police officer accused of shooting unarmed teen

Grand jury indicts former San Antonio police officer accused of shooting unarmed teen Ex-SAPD cop James Brennand faces attempted murder, aggravated assault charges. A grand jury has indicted former San Antonio Police officer James Brennand on two counts of aggravated assault and one count of attempted murder after he allegedly ...

View more: Grand jury indicts former San Antonio police officer accused of shooting unarmed teen

Surgeon General Vivek Murthy advises on flu, RSV and COVID-19

Surgeon General Vivek Murthy advises on flu, RSV and COVID-19 “We can't let up our guard,” he told ABC News. Health officials are warning of a “triple threat” of flu, RSV and COVID-19 across the country and hospitals are continuing to see a surge in pediatric RSV cases. U.S. Surgeon ...

View more: Surgeon General Vivek Murthy advises on flu, RSV and COVID-19

What World Cup Games Are Happening Today? Match Schedule for Dec. 2

Here’s the four-game slate to watch for on Friday as the final groups of nations fight to advance to the round of 16

View more: What World Cup Games Are Happening Today? Match Schedule for Dec. 2

Signing Jacob deGom chance for Steve Cohen the owner to satisfy Steve Cohen the fan

Wednesday marked a fairly significant 10-year anniversary for the Mets, which flew, quite understandably, under the radar. For it was on Nov. 30, 2012, that David Wright signed a seven-year, $122 million contract that all but guaranteed he would remain a Met for life, which he did. We’ll mention the ...

View more: Signing Jacob deGom chance for Steve Cohen the owner to satisfy Steve Cohen the fan

10 Los Angeles middle schoolers likely OD’d on weed edibles in class: officials

Fire officials are spotted putting a student in an ambulance after ten middle school students overdosed on edibles on Dec. 1, 2022. ABC7News.com Ten Los Angeles middle schoolers likely overdosed on what authorities believe were cannabis edibles during class Thursday morning, officials said. The students, all between the ages ...

View more: 10 Los Angeles middle schoolers likely OD’d on weed edibles in class: officials

Bills capture first AFC victory of season in ‘TNF’ win over Patriots

FOXBOROUGH, Mass. — Josh Allen threw two touchdown passes and the Buffalo Bills beat the New England Patriots 24-10 on Thursday night for their first AFC East victory of the season. Devin Singletary had a 1-yard touchdown run to help the Bills (9-3) win their third straight and take a ...

View more: Bills capture first AFC victory of season in ‘TNF’ win over Patriots

Jennifer Siebel Newsom accused of lying on the stand about Harvey Weinstein rape

Citigroup trying to get accidental $500M Revlon loan payment back

UN: Iraq Christians were victims of Islamic State war crimes

The Dark History Of Carrie

WATCH: Campers Rescue Man Who Spent Weeks Lost in California Forest

Knicks’ RJ Barrett finally showing signs of ending another shooting slump

Ducks’ skid grows to four with loss to Stars

Man Rescued by Campers After Being Lost in California Forest for Weeks

CRÍTICAS. Will Smith heroico, David Harbour agresivo y más estrenos en salas de cine

City committee looks to silence train whistles at southwest Calgary rail crossing

E. Jean Carroll has request for DC Court of Appeals in new Trump defamation lawsuit

‘Green Book' Actor Found Dead on NYC Sidewalk With No Signs of Injuries

OTHER NEWS

Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network