Climate change is making the weather more severe. Why don't most forecasts mention it?

Some mountain trails in the city of Phoenix are open before sunrise and after sunset to encourage hikers to avoid the heat of the midday. A large body of scientific research shows that climate change is making heat waves more severe. Communicating about that climate connection while a heat wave is still underway can affect peoples’ attitudes about climate change more broadly. Ryan Kellman/NPR hide caption

toggle caption Ryan Kellman/NPR

At global climate talks that just wrapped up, one of the few areas of agreement was about the worldwide toll of climate-driven weather disasters.

Leaders from Pakistan and Kenya, Senegal and the Bahamas connected the dots between a hotter Earth and devastating floods, storms, heat waves and droughts. And in a speech at the conference, President Joe Biden said more severe hurricanes and wildfires are wreaking havoc in the United States.

That connection between extreme weather and climate change has never been clearer, thanks to an area of science known as extreme-event attribution. It allows scientists to describe exactly how much worse a specific flood, heat wave, hurricane or drought is because of human-caused global warming.

But that science is largely missing from public weather forecasts that millions of people in the U.S. rely on. As severe weather gets more common, scientists and forecasters are contending with a sneakily difficult question: How do we work together to explain the role of climate change?

It’s mostly the scientists who do the talking

Years of research have shown how climate change intensifies rain storms, heat waves and hurricanes.

But when a disaster is unfolding, the official weather forecasts from the federal government don’t include information about how climate change is making the disaster more severe or more likely, even when the connection is well-established by previous studies. The forecasts that most people get on their phones or through television broadcasts are based on official government information.

If they did include climate context, weather forecasts for hurricanes might mention how sea level rise or warmer ocean temperatures could make the storm more severe than storms in the past.

Similarly, official updates on drought conditions might mention how global warming contributes to longer, more severe droughts. Or heat wave warnings from the National Weather Service could include information about the strong, well-established connection between a hotter Earth and dangerously hot days.

Instead, information about that connection comes from researchers, often weeks or months after the disaster happens.


But scientists may not always be the best messengers. Research has found that television meteorologists can be some of the most authoritative voices for lots of people on the connection between climate change and weather.

And federal forecasters, such as those at the National Hurricane Center, could also be effective messengers for climate information, says Michael Wehner, a climate scientist at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory who studies extreme weather. “Confidence in these statements would be considerably higher,” he argues, if they were coming as part of forecasts and warnings that people already trust and turn to when a storm is bearing down.

But including climate context in real-time weather warnings is easier said than done, says Sarah Kapnick, the chief scientist at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA). Kapnick has a background as a research scientist, and has worked on extreme-event attribution studies.

“When an extreme event is happening, NOAA’s National Weather Service has a singular focus on protecting lives and property,” she explains. Forecasters do their best to answer questions about the role of climate change in whatever disaster is unfolding, she says. But “they don’t necessarily know all the science about climate change, and they’re not active in doing that type of analysis,” explains Kapnick.

Instead, NOAA scientists separately put out information about how climate change affects hurricanes, floods, heat waves and other severe weather. “One of the difficulties, when an event is happening, is trying to combine those two into one,” Kapnick says.

NOAA is currently reviewing how it communicates with the public about climate change, she says, in part because of a flood of interest from the public and from local officials who are grappling with more severe weather.

Climate change is making the weather more severe. Why don't most forecasts mention it?

Hurricane Ian cause wide spread flooding when it dumped rain across Florida in September. A preliminary analysis found that Ian dumped at least 10% more rain because of climate change. Joe Burbank/Orlando Sentinal/Tribune News Service via Getty hide caption

toggle caption Joe Burbank/Orlando Sentinal/Tribune News Service via Getty

Hurricane Ian led to some confusing climate change communication

The gap between scientists and forecasters was on full display when Hurricane Ian hit Florida in September. The storm gathered strength over abnormally hot water in the Gulf of Mexico – water made hotter by human-caused global warming.

A large body of research shows that warmer oceans can make hurricanes worse by causing storms to dump more rain. Sea level rise in Florida makes storm surge more destructive. And research also suggests that climate change may make it more likely for storms to rapidly intensify, which also happened to Ian. Such storms are dangerous because they get extremely destructive right before hitting land, giving people little time to evacuate.

But forecasts and statements from the National Hurricane Center didn’t mention how climate change was likely to make Hurricane Ian more severe.

The day before the storm made landfall in Florida, the acting director of the hurricane center, Jamie Rhome, appeared on CNN and was asked how climate change might be affecting the storm’s intensification. He responded, “We can come back and talk about climate change at a later time. I want to focus on the here and now.”

Pressed by CNN’s Don Lemon, Rhome responded, “I don’t think you can link climate change to any one event. On the whole, on the cumulative, climate change may be making storms worse. But to link it to any one event, I would caution against that.”

“That statement was wrong,” says Wehner. “It is entirely appropriate for me to say climate change made this event more intense.”

Indeed, a preliminary analysis by Wehner and other climate scientists in the days after Ian made landfall estimated that climate change caused the storm to drop at least 10% more rain than it would have without global warming.

Asked about Rhome’s comments, Rick Spinrad, administrator of NOAA , which oversees the National Hurricane Center, said it is clear that climate change is affecting hurricanes and tropical storms.

“You look at what happened with Hurricane Harvey, Hurricane Ian,” he said in a recent interview with NPR, about two months after Hurricane Ian. “These storms are dumping feet of rain. We’ve not tended to see that before. So when you talk about attribution, I think it’s unequivocal that we can attribute to climate change the changes in the dynamics of these storms.”

But, Spinrad says, the research “isn’t robust enough yet” for weather forecasters to say exactly how much worse a given weather disaster will be, in real-time. Nor should that necessarily be the primary goal. Instead, he says his agency is focused on giving people information about what to expect in the future. For example, as heat waves get more intense, NOAA hopes to use extreme-event attribution science to beef up its ability to warn people.

How we communicate about climate change affects public support for climate policies

Humans are habitually focused on the present. Your leaky roof demands more attention than the threat of a future climate-driven flood.

That’s why the time during and immediately after a weather disaster is so important. People who experience a severe heat wave or hurricane, and who understand that it is connected to climate change, are more likely to take action to protect themselves from future disasters, and to support climate policies, according to research by Gabrielle Wong-Parodi of Stanford University.

That includes more support for electric vehicles and policies to cut greenhouse gas emissions, as well as an interest in doing things like flood-proofing your home.

It’s unclear how long those attitudes last after a climate-driven disaster. Figuring that out is an active area of research. “There appears to be this window of time within which you might want to help people better understand what those risks are, and make links to climate change,” Wong-Parodi explains.

“I think that’s really important as we move forward, because it has implications for how we may want to communicate to the public about these types of events,” says Wong-Parodi.


England forward Marcus Rashford can become a world-beater admits Man United teammate Harry Maguire

Harry Maguire has praised England’s Marcus Rashford for the way he has roared back to form and says his talented Manchester United team-mate has the potential to become one of the world’s best.

View more: England forward Marcus Rashford can become a world-beater admits Man United teammate Harry Maguire

BBC cancels Christmas Day ‘Top of the Pops’ after nearly 60 years

1 of 4 The iconic Christmas Day show –which debuted its first Christmas special on Dec. 24 in 1964 — was canceled due to financial problems. BBC “Top of the Pops” featured the Rolling Stones as its first band. Mirrorpix via Getty Images The Spice Girls appear on “Top ...

View more: BBC cancels Christmas Day ‘Top of the Pops’ after nearly 60 years

Prosecutor says evidence shows Trump ‘explicitly’ OK’d tax fraud

NEW YORK —  In the end, it wasn’t a last-minute smoking gun but a prosecutor insisting that evidence shows Donald Trump was aware of a scheme that his Trump Organization’s executives hatched to avoid paying personal income taxes on millions of dollars’ worth of company-paid perks. After telling jurors Thursday that ...

View more: Prosecutor says evidence shows Trump ‘explicitly’ OK’d tax fraud

USMNT Disappointed in Loss to Netherlands, Sets Sights on Hosting in 2026

Head coach Gregg Berhalter and a quartet of players spoke on their team's World Cup run following elimination to the Dutch on Saturday

View more: USMNT Disappointed in Loss to Netherlands, Sets Sights on Hosting in 2026

33-year-old N.B. driver dead after fatal crash south of Sussex

A man in his 30s died in a single-vehicle crash about 10 kilometres south of Sussex. Just before 10:30 p.m. on Dec. 1, police were called to a crash on Route 111 in Jeffries Corner. Just one car was involved in the crash, said police said in a release. The ...

View more: 33-year-old N.B. driver dead after fatal crash south of Sussex

Ticketmaster Sued By Taylor Swift Fans Over Ticketing Debacle

Jamie McCarthy/Getty Images for MTV No Taylor? No peace! A gaggle of Taylor Swift fans are suing Ticketmaster over its botched November 15 ticket sale for her Eras Tour. The fans collective are suing the company for “fraud, price-fixing, and antitrust violations,” accusing it of “intentional deception” that allowed scalpers ...

View more: Ticketmaster Sued By Taylor Swift Fans Over Ticketing Debacle

George Takei Strikes Back At ‘Star Trek’ Castmate William Shatner’s Criticism

George Takei has responded to the barbed comments made about him by former Star Trek costar William Shatner. During an appearance on Friday’s The Graham Norton Show in the UK, Takei, age 85, said the moment would be “The very last time I talk about him” in response to ...

View more: George Takei Strikes Back At ‘Star Trek’ Castmate William Shatner’s Criticism

Edward Berger, Daniel Brühl & Felix Kammerer Talk Responsibility Of Making A German-Language ‘All Quiet On The Western Front’ – Contenders International

Netflix Director Edward Berger said that what intrigued him most about the prospect of adapting Erich Maria Remarque’s world-renowned bestselling book All Quiet on the Western Front into a film was the chance to tell the story in his native German language. While the film has been made for ...

View more: Edward Berger, Daniel Brühl & Felix Kammerer Talk Responsibility Of Making A German-Language ‘All Quiet On The Western Front’ – Contenders International

Orioles reach deal with Kyle Gibson, sources say

Orioles reach 1-year deal with Kyle Gibson, sources say

These stories offer a glimpse into trauma, loss experienced in Houston area in 2022

‘Is This a Joke?': Man Traveling With 2 Daughters Says He Was Accused of Human Trafficking

San Diego ambulance provider offering $50,000 signing bonuses to combat paramedic staffing crisis

20 of the most majestic mountain peaks in the world

Teen girls struck in South Vancouver pedestrian collision, police say

Police warn about suspects looking through mailboxes

Activision Blizzard sees second successful union drive

3 holiday romance novels that will get you hot this winter

‘Spam figgy pudding’ sells out ahead of the holidays

England Seeks Win Over Senegal in 2022 World Cup Round of 16: Here's How to Watch


Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network