Court: Cop who shot Castile wrongly denied teaching license

Court: Cop who shot Castile wrongly denied teaching license

The Minnesota Court of Appeals says a state board must reconsider its rejection of a substitute teaching license for the former police officer who shot and killed Philando Castile in 2016

Jeronimo Yanez applied to be a substitute teacher in 2020, but his application was denied based on “immoral character or conduct.” The appeals court ruled that this reason was unconstitutionally vague and the Minnesota Professional Educator Licensing and Standards Board must reconsider — focusing narrowly on whether Yanez’s conduct makes him unfit to teach.

The appeals court said that upon reconsideration, the board must identify factors it is using to determine whether Yanez’s conduct “violated moral standards for the teaching profession.” The board must also avoid characterizing policing practices — such as a pretextual reason for a traffic stop — as immoral.

“The board’s decision must focus exclusively on Yanez’s conduct and his fitness to be a teacher, not fitness to be a police officer,” the appeals court ruled.

Messages left with Yanez’s attorney and with the licensing board were not immediately returned Monday.

Yanez, a former St. Anthony police officer, shot Castile during a traffic stop after Castile, who was Black, said he had a gun. Authorities later discovered that Castile, a 32-year-old elementary school cafeteria worker, had a permit for the firearm.

The case got widespread attention after Castile’s girlfriend, who was in the car with her young daughter, began livestreaming the shooting’s aftermath on Facebook.

Yanez was charged with manslaughter but was acquitted by a jury. The shooting and Yanez’s subsequent acquittal led to massive public outcry and protests in Minnesota and beyond.

Yanez left the police department after his trial. In February 2020, he applied for a substitute teaching license, according to the appeals court ruling. At the time of his application, he was teaching Spanish part-time at a parochial school. The school's principal supported his license application.

During the application process, the board’s disciplinary committee investigated Yanez’s case and recommended that his application be denied.

He appealed to an administrative-law judge, who also recommended that his application be denied after a hearing in which St. Paul Public Schools Superintendent Joseph Gothard testified that Yanez’s actions were hurtful and offensive to the community. An expert who testified for Yanez said the traffic stop was lawful and that he agreed the deadly use of force was reasonable.

The administrative-law judge found Yanez prejudged Castile as a robbery suspect because of his “wide set nose” — initiating a pretextual traffic stop that indicated “racial bias, microaggressions, and negativity bias that are detrimental to students, especially students of color.”

The administrative-law judge also found that Yanez failed to establish that his use of deadly force was reasonable and necessary. The board ultimately denied Yanez's application.

Yanez argued on appeal that denying his application due to “immoral character or conduct” was unconstitutionally vague. The appeals court agreed, saying that other jurisdictions have found that immorality means different things to different people, and that the conduct in question must be directly related to a teacher’s ability to teach.

The appeals court said that the phrase is nebulous and “vulnerable to the caprice of ever-changing public opinion and the potential for arbitrary, biased enforcement” but that it could survive constitutional scrutiny if narrowed to “relate to professional morals in the occupation of teaching.”

Castile’s mother, Valerie Castile, said Monday that she didn’t know Yanez was trying to obtain a substitute teaching license, and that she doesn’t think he belongs in the classroom.

She said children – particularly students of color — might have trouble focusing on what Yanez is teaching and could worry that they were in danger. She said parents would also need to be notified if he was in a classroom.

“The community knows about what he did and I don’t think the kids would be comfortable even having him there,” she said. “We have to think about our children’s comfort levels. … We have to think about those children and the trauma they suffered because of what he did.”

Related TopicsPolice Shootings

I flew to Turkey for a new set of teeth – trolls say I’m a Katie Price wannabe with piano tiles but I don’t care

Lateness matters, your honors: Judges must not violate court rules related to their campaigns

My car insurance costs me £150 a year extra due to ‘unfair’ rules – five ways to avoid the ‘poverty premium’

How to save a Google Doc on your computer or smartphone

When it comes to dating, earning less than $30,000 is a deal breaker, a new survey shows

I’m a savvy shopper… the M&S bargains I swear by – it’s so much cheaper than you think

Love Island fans convinced Casa Amor is about to happen as Maya Jama reveals she’s heading back to the villa

I feel sorry for lost puppy Tommy Fury, he’s trying to figure out life and treated like runt of family, says Jake Paul

Jake Paul sticks by claim Molly-Mae has given birth and claims Tommy Fury will mentally struggle to fight him

Manifestantes “desactivan” gases lacrimógenos en Perú

Officers brought homeless man to remote spot and beat him, prosecutors say

McDonald's Finally Breaks Its Twitter Silence With A Simple Post

Shoppers share their mega TK Maxx sales hauls as they nab yellow sticker bargains like 70p boots & £1.70 designer jeans

I’m a fashion expert and these styles of winter coats are making you look tacky – it’s bad news for quilted coat lovers

Dancing On Ice fans baffled as they spot something very different about Keith Lemon – did you notice?

The Princess of Wales writes an open letter ahead of a new campaign launch

NEWS RELATED

Kelly Cheng, Sara Hughes, beach volleyball’s new sensation, win World Tour Finals

Kelly Cheng, Sara Hughes, beach volleyball’s new sensation, win World Tour Finals In just a few months since reuniting, Kelly Cheng and Sara Hughes have become not just the best women’s beach volleyball team in the U.S., but also, arguably, the world. Cheng and Hughes, former partners who got back together for ...

View more: Kelly Cheng, Sara Hughes, beach volleyball’s new sensation, win World Tour Finals

Brie Larson has an existential crisis by questioning the fragile nature of time itself

Brie Larson has an existential crisis by questioning the fragile nature of time itself Time is a fickle and cruel mistress, and it waits for nobody, not even an Academy Award-winning star like Brie Larson. The Marvel Cinematic Universe stalwart appears to be having something of an existential crisis ...

View more: Brie Larson has an existential crisis by questioning the fragile nature of time itself

Steven Spielberg Cast Alden Ehrenreich After Seeing a Bat Mitzvah Video He Made

Alden Ehrenreich broke through to the big time in 2018, landing the leading role in Solo: A Star Wars Story. Many critics and fans appreciated Ehrenreich’s heartfelt performance. And over the past several years, the talented young star has continuously opted for roles that challenge him creatively. Ehrenreich’s own story ...

View more: Steven Spielberg Cast Alden Ehrenreich After Seeing a Bat Mitzvah Video He Made

Parents go wild for Primark’s new kids’ bedroom line, including cute duvet sets, cushions and storage solutions

IT'S becoming more well known for its Home section, with people travelling from far and wide to get their hands on cheap, cute items for their houses. And now Primark has proved that it's also one to be reckoned with in the kids' home section too. Primark has some ...

View more: Parents go wild for Primark’s new kids’ bedroom line, including cute duvet sets, cushions and storage solutions

Man arrested in deadly point-blank shooting in Queens

Man arrested in deadly point-blank shooting in Queens FAR ROCKAWAY, Queens (PIX11) — Police arrested a man on murder charges on Sunday, months after he allegedly fatally shot a man at close range in Queens. Jovan Springer, a 29-year-old Brooklyn resident, was charged with murder and criminal possession of ...

View more: Man arrested in deadly point-blank shooting in Queens

Richard Madeley slammed on Good Morning Britain after he’s forced to apologise twice over Sam Smith blunder

RICHARD Madeley apologised twice today on Good Morning Britain after misgendering pop star Sam Smith and a guest on the show. Sam was assigned male at birth but the 30-year-old singer announced they were non-binary in 2019 and asked people to use they/them pronouns when addressing him. Richard Madeley ...

View more: Richard Madeley slammed on Good Morning Britain after he’s forced to apologise twice over Sam Smith blunder

Robotaxis have a passenger problem that no one thought of

Robotaxis have a passenger problem that no one thought of An issue with self-driving cars has come t0 light that apparently no one previously considered: dozing passengers. Officials in San Francisco, where Alphabet’s Waymo company and GM-backed Cruise are currently operating robotaxi services as part of ongoing trials, highlighted ...

View more: Robotaxis have a passenger problem that no one thought of

All Good: WNBA Has Reported No Positive Coronavirus Tests

Seven players had tested positive for COVID-19 in the days leading up to arriving in Bradenton, but there have been none in the bubble since

View more: All Good: WNBA Has Reported No Positive Coronavirus Tests

Most Adani Shares Continue Bloodbath as Asia's Richest Man Loses $28 Billion in a Month

As Blinken visits, Palestinians say Israeli troops kill a man in the West Bank

Parliament to debate two separate motions on public housing affordability during Feb 6 sitting

Kate Ferdinand shows off growing baby bump after revealing she’s pregnant with second baby

The Masked Singer’s Joel Dommett signs up for new ‘high octane’ ITV game show

Coroner investigating after multiple people found dead inside an Upstate home

Actress Annie Wersching passes away from cancer at 45

Receptionist who thought she ‘might die’ at almost 18 stone aged 40 ‘gobsmacked’ after losing 42% of her body weight

Urban League holds vigil in memory of Tyre Nichols

Loose Women legend Kaye Adams gets her first tattoo to mark turning 60

World Bank: Myanmar economy to grow 3%, dragged by conflict

Hard-up households handed extra time to apply for £300 free cash direct to bank account – can you get it?

OTHER NEWS