Elephant tourism vicious circle: why Bali’s Sumatran elephants, suffering a horrific ‘lockdown’, need visitors to survive

magazines, post magazine, asia travel, animals, indonesia, tourism, travel news and advice, elephant tourism vicious circle: why bali’s sumatran elephants, suffering a horrific ‘lockdown’, need visitors to survive

Among the countless things that Covid-19 has shone a spotlight on is the complex, often harmful, relationship that humans have with nature. Back when lockdowns were a novelty, we marvelled at viral videos showing animals reclaiming streets and waterways, ignoring the fact that the pathogen behind the pandemic was probably a direct result of our exploitation of the natural environment, not to mention our unnatural intimacy with wild creatures.

Few fauna manifest this paradox quite like Bali’s captive Sumatran elephants. As the name suggests, this critically endangered species is not indigenous to the Indonesian resort island – instead hailing from Borneo and Sumatra – but many have been moved to Bali as part of a government-run conservation programme “that entrusts privately-owned zoos and safari parks in Indonesia with the care of critically endangered Sumatran elephants”, according to an October 7 Al Jazeera article about the plight of 14 pachyderms at one such park.

The Bali Elephant Camp (BEC) “left more than a dozen elephants to starve, and staff without pay after plummeting ticket sales forced it to close when Covid-19 spread around the world and borders were closed,” the report said.

A subspecies of the Asian elephant, the Sumatran’s conservation status was upgraded by the International Union for Conservation of Nature in 2011 from endangered to critically endangered because the population had declined by at least 80 per cent in three elephant generations, or 75 years. There are estimated to be between 2,400 and 2,800 Sumatran elephants left in the world, about 200 of which remain in the wild.

You cannot imagine a skinny elephant until you see one. They are big animals and you’re not meant to see their bones

Femke Den Haas, vet who visited BEC in May

Global conservation body WWF reports that this decline “is largely due to habitat loss and as a result of human-elephant conflict”, adding that “Sumatra has experienced one of the highest rates of deforestation within the Asian elephant’s range, which has resulted in local extinctions of elephants in many areas”. Much of the 473,000 sq km island’s remaining forest cover includes areas that are simply too small to support viable elephant populations.

According to the Al Jazeera article, the elephants at BEC were “sourced from breeding centres established 30 years ago in Sumatra that were supposed to help stabilise the population. In exchange for giving the animals a home, accredited businesses were permitted to sell elephant-tourism services that were wildly profitable before the pandemic.” BEC was reportedly charging US$230 for a half-hour elephant ride for two people.

“Many industries in Bali have collapsed as a result of the Covid-19 pandemic. But the impact on small companies like Bali Elephant Camp has been especially severe,” Agus Budi Santosa, director of the Konservasi Sumber Daya Alam Bali (BKSDA), the government body that oversees the well-being of rehomed Sumatran elephants, told Al Jazeera. “[When tourism stopped] they were no longer able to cover operational costs, especially the cost of feeding elephants.”

Femke Den Haas, a vet who visited BEC in May with BKSDA, took pictures of the undernourished animals. “You cannot imagine a skinny elephant until you see one,” she told Al Jazeera. “They are big animals and you’re not meant to see their bones. But that’s what they were – just skin and bones.”

BEC declined to answer questions from Al Jazeera. However, the broad­caster reported that all 14 elephants had been removed from the camp, with three going to “an unidentified zoo on the neighbouring island of Java” and the remaining 11 moving to Tasta Wildlife Park, in central Bali. As at BEC, Tasta will engage the animals in tourism activities, offering visitors the chance to ride the elephants – for a fee, naturally.

As far as major animal conservation organisations are concerned, any such interactions with animals are not only unethical, but exploitative and can constitute abuse. The only way to ethically interact with elephants is to observe them from a distance. Worse still, in a 2018 report that investigated 26 wildlife tourism venues in Bali, World Animal Protection found that not one met “even the basic needs of animals”.

“Travellers should stay away from any irresponsible entertainment activities involving wild animals,” urges the report. “If you can ride, hug, swim or have a selfie with a wild animal, please don’t and don’t visit venues offering these activities.”

Except, now we’ve seen what happens when visitors stay away. These animals, which live in captivity because human activities have destroyed their natural habitats to the extent that their populations can no longer be supported in the wild, and which have been placed in tourism attractions as part of efforts to “rehabilitate” their populations, now depend on tourism to survive, even if that doesn’t offer them any quality of life.

The “lockdown” Sumatran elephants have had to endure because of humans is far worse than anything Covid-19 has inconvenienced people with.

magazines, post magazine, asia travel, animals, indonesia, tourism, travel news and advice, elephant tourism vicious circle: why bali’s sumatran elephants, suffering a horrific ‘lockdown’, need visitors to survive

India is among several Asian countries currently gearing up to welcome foreign tourists again. Photo: Anadolu Agency via Getty Images

Asian destinations prepare to reopen to international tourism

Thailand announced on October 11 that it plans to no longer require visitors from at least 10 low-risk nations to quarantine beginning next month if they are fully vaccinated for Covid-19 and the Indonesian island of Bali is among other Asian destinations that are preparing to reopen to international tourism, alongside India and Vietnam.

On October 7, the Indian government announced that it would start granting tourist visas again from October 15, after an 18-month hiatus. In a statement, the Ministry of Home Affairs said: “After considering various inputs, the MHA has decided to begin granting fresh Tourist Visas for foreigners coming to India through chartered flights with effect from October 15.” Those travelling on commercial flights would be able to enter the country from November 15.

Entry requirements and quarantine rules currently differ depending on the state, although arrivals in New Delhi do not have to quarantine as long as they can provide a negative PCR test result taken within 72 hours of boarding their flight.

magazines, post magazine, asia travel, animals, indonesia, tourism, travel news and advice, elephant tourism vicious circle: why bali’s sumatran elephants, suffering a horrific ‘lockdown’, need visitors to survive

Hoi An is one of Vietnam’s “key tourist destinations” that is set reopen to vaccinated visitors from countries deemed a low Covid-19 risk. Photo: Getty Images

As for Bali, coordinating minister for maritime affairs and investment, Luhut Pandjaitan, announced on October 4 that the island’s airport would open to international flights on October 14. “We are open to several countries, including South Korea, China, Japan, United Arab Emirates and New Zealand,” Pandjaitan told the Associated Press.

Arrivals will be subject to five days’ quarantine at their own expense and the partial reopening will serve as a “trial” for Bali’s ability to once again welcome all, tourism minister Sandiaga Uno told reporters, although he did not offer a timeline for that full return.

Vietnam’s reopening will also be staggered, with Reuters reporting that the Southeast Asian nation is planning “to reopen key tourist destinations to vaccinated visitors from countries deemed a low Covid-19 risk” from December “ahead of a full resumption targeted for June next year”.

Those key destinations include Ha Long Bay, Hoi An, Da Lat and Nha Trang, although it is not yet clear which countries will be considered low risk.

News Related


Travel memories crystallised in architect’s journaling – his sketches record the experience of a place in a way no photograph can

In more ways than one, we’re grounded. Eagerly awaiting the restrictions of a global pandemic to lift, Hongkongers are clamouring at airport gates, passport in hand, desperate to see the ... Read more »

How to survive world’s longest coronavirus quarantine without losing your mind

Do not take Hong Kong’s three-week hotel quarantine, the world’s longest, lightly – you’ve got to go in with a plan. I approached it much like I planned trips to ... Read more »

Amazing mazes you'll want to get lost in

1/29 SLIDES © aMAZEme/Facebook These attractions are a cut above A source of fun and sometimes frustration, mazes have been entertaining and confusing people for centuries. From beautiful historic labyrinths in ... Read more »

What subway travel used to look like

1/34 SLIDES © Arkivi/Getty Images Going underground The world’s subway systems are much more than just a way to get from A to B. They’re impressive feats of engineering, sometimes with ... Read more »

Delta announced 3 new routes to Panama in its latest network expansion

© Thomas Pallini/Insider Touring Delta Air Lines’ new terminal at LaGuardia Airport. Thomas Pallini/Insider Delta Air Lines is launching three new routes and one additional frequency to Panama City, Panama ... Read more »

Ancient Egyptians left these treasures behind

1/31 SLIDES © Unai Huizi Photography/Shutterstock Egypt’s ancient wonders Home to spectacular desert landscapes, the planet’s longest river and millennia-old monuments found nowhere else, Egypt is quite unlike any other country ... Read more »

Earth's unspoiled spots you might never see

1/31 SLIDES © trabantos/Shutterstock A world away… The world might feel like a smaller place today, but there are still some remarkably remote and pristine places. From the sand dunes of ... Read more »

Eerie sunken shipwrecks caught on camera

1/28 SLIDES © Jellyman Photography/Shutterstock Ghosts of the sea Modern underwater photography can capture beautiful but eerie images of sunken vessels, transporting us to places we might not otherwise see. Many ... Read more »

A global airline is no longer requiring passengers to wear face masks on some flights

© Provided by Business Insider A SAS Scandinavian Airlines’ Airbus A350-900 XWB. Thomas Pallini/Insider Scandinavian Airlines will no longer require face masks on flights within Scandinavia. Flights outside of Sweden, ... Read more »

Tremendous tunnels around the world

1/31 SLIDES © robert paul van beets/Shutterstock Tunnel vision Since the dawn of time humankind has had the urge to tunnel and burrow, whether for safety, storage, irrigation or to extract ... Read more »

Which countries are only letting in double vaccinated travellers?

With lockdown restrictions lifted throughout most of the UK, and the resumption of international travel on 17 May, British travel fans are tentatively considering the prospect of foreign trips. While ... Read more »

US travel reopening: How can I get cheap flights to America?

Following the announcement by the White House that the US will reopen to fully vaccinated tourists from 8 November, there’s been a flurry of bookings for trips across the pond. ... Read more »

Are ‘nature positive’ trips the next step in ethical tourism?

Sri Lanka’s Udawalawe national park is less visited than more crowded Yala (Getty Images/iStockphoto) “We’re loving nature to death.” That’s the problem with the state of travel at the moment, ... Read more »

BA to hire thousands of staff amid signs of recovery for the travel industry

British Airways is planning to rehire thousands of staff following the lay-offs caused by the pandemic, according to the union Unite. Unite says the airline is looking to rehire about ... Read more »

Explore Titanic’s secrets at these amazing museums

1/27 SLIDES © Radharc Images/Alamy Stock Photo Must-see Titanic museums and monuments It’s almost 110 years since RMS Titanic went down, yet we continue to be fascinated by the Ship of ... Read more »

You can now ride in a luxury train carriage designed by Wes Anderson

Film director Wes Anderson – famous for his distinctive aesthetic and eye for retro-modern interiors – has designed a luxury train carriage in the UK. The director of The Grand ... Read more »

Kingston University complex wins prestigious architecture award: 9 more buildings around the world we’d love to learn in

If you studied in a concrete 1960s comprehensive block, you’ll definitely get pangs of jealousy at the sight of Kingston University London – Town House. The building, described as a ... Read more »

The New Zealand city of Christchurch is firing its official wizard after keeping the necromancer on its payroll for more than 20 years

© Phil Noble/Reuters The Wizard of New Zealand, Ian Brackenbury Channell, will be taken off the city’s payroll come December. Phil Noble/Reuters Ian Brackenbury Channell, better known as the Wizard ... Read more »

When do PCR tests for travel switch to lateral flow?

The continuation of mandatory PCR Covid tests for travel has been a bone of contention for both travellers and the travel sector throughout 2021. Despite the successful vaccine rollout, any ... Read more »

You can’t keep a good airline down. Or Alitalia

Simon Calder, also known as The Man Who Pays His Way, has been writing about travel for The Independent since 1994. In his weekly opinion column, he explores a key ... Read more »

Lateral flow tests to replace PCRs for vaccinated travellers in time for half-term

Fully vaccinated travellers arriving in England will be able to take cheaper and quicker lateral flow tests from 24 October instead of the PCR tests currently required. The rule change ... Read more »

NHS Covid app crash: What’s the problem and will it affect my travels?

The NHS website and app were both down for part of Wednesday afternoon, with users unable to access their digital NHS Covid Passes. The UK’s proof of vaccination certificates can ... Read more »

Offa’s Dyke Path at 50: an ancient earthwork still shrouded in mystery

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: PA Images/Alamy We come up a steep hillside, stepping past twisted trees laden with lichen and scarlet berries, all dripping with rain. A mob ... Read more »

The incredible stories of the world's last surviving nomads

1/31 SLIDES © MonoRidz/Shutterstock Last of the nomads It’s almost impossible to imagine life without the comfort of our beds, the convenience of 24-hour superstores and the thrill of a luxury ... Read more »

British Airways confirms A380 plans as part of winter expansion

British Airways has revealed more details of its winter plans – including returning its Airbus A380 aircraft to the skies. The airline has confirmed speculation that the “SuperJumbo” will resume ... Read more »

Inside the 100-year-old abandoned house where time has stood still

1/23 SLIDES © Lisbeth Christensen One family’s 100-year history in a windswept island home Nestled on the rugged tip of an island in northern Norway, two degrees above the Arctic Circle, ... Read more »

The world's ugliest houses you just won't believe

1/33 SLIDES © @UglyBelgianHouses / Instagram Aesthetically challenging residences around the globe They say that beauty is in the eye of the beholder and never has that phrase been truer than ... Read more »

Edinburgh Festival to tackle climate change by asking visitors not to fly

Edinburgh Festival organisers have announced they will be encouraging visitors not to fly and to attend events online rather than in person. The new action plan, drawn up in response ... Read more »

Airline association boss Willie Walsh slams ongoing PCR testing ‘rip-off’

The director general of the global airline body Iata has slammed the UK government’s continuing rules around PCR tests for travel, calling them a “state-sponsored rip-off”. Speaking at an Aviation ... Read more »

What is split ticketing and how can it save me money on train tickets?

Dividing a rail journey into separate segments can save a fortune on train tickets. As ticket-splitting becomes mainstream, will anyone ever pay full price ever again for rail travel? What ... Read more »

Bali reopens to tourists from 19 countries - but no flights are running

Bali officially reopened to international visitors today, allowing fully vaccinated travellers from 19 countries to enter – but with no international flights operating into its airport. In a statement on ... Read more »

There is ‘overwhelming’ demand for new Hong Kong magazine aimed at the city’s migrant community and domestic workers

The co-founders of Pangyao – a lifestyle magazine launched this month to showcase Hong Kong’s migrant community – have hit a snag. They can’t keep up with demand. “The response ... Read more »

This is your state's top place to camp

1/51 SLIDES © Under Canvas/Facebook Sites to behold Camping has stepped up a gear in recent years. While there have always been incredible spots to pitch a tent around the US, ... Read more »

Why finding America's 'greatest lost treasure' landed this man in jail

1/27 SLIDES © TNS/SIPA USA/PA Images The greatest lost treasure in US history and the incredible story behind it In February 2018 a spectacular array of gold ingots, coins, and more ... Read more »

Climate crisis: the worst floods in history

1/37 SLIDES © Sean Rayford/Getty Images The devastating effects of Mother Nature While water can be stunningly beautiful, it can also be extremely dangerous, as proven by the most extreme weather events ... Read more »

A pilot using TikTok to criticize the federal vaccine mandate is going viral among conservatives

© @cellsaucenutrition/TikTok This screenshot is from a viral TikTok showing a pilot criticizing vaccine mandates. The video has been boosted by popular figures on the right. @cellsaucenutrition/TikTok A pilot spoke ... Read more »

Travel experts call on US to decide on date for UK opening soon: ‘The industry thrives on certainty’

Travel experts are slamming the Biden administration’s failure to set a date for reopening the US to land and air travel by vaccinated travellers. The White House announced the plans ... Read more »

Sanibel and Captiva Are a Beachy Shoulder Season Fall Getaway

© Provided by Southern Living Martina Birnbaum / EyeEm / Getty Images If you’re on the hunt for a vacation with all the fun and none of the crowds, set ... Read more »

Amazing animals that live in America's national parks

1/31 SLIDES © Tomas Kotouc/Shutterstock Havens for wildlife Covering an enormous 84 million acres of the US and its territories abroad, national parks are filled with plenty of wildlife. From sweet and fluffy ... Read more »

Pediatricians say trick-or-treating poses a low to moderate risk this year. These tips can help keep your kids safe.

© PeopleImages/Getty Images PeopleImages/Getty Images With COVID-19 cases down in most states, trick-or-treating is back on in many cities and towns. Pediatricians say there’s still a risk for COVID-19 transmission ... Read more »