Appeals court denied Musk's bid to scrap the settlement in April

Angelo Zino says Twitter has the ‘upper hand’ amid Musk takeover

CFRA Research senior equity analyst Angelo Zino discusses the Elon Musk-Twitter deal and the performance of tech stocks amid a volatile market.

Lawyers for Elon Musk say the government is unlawfully muzzling the billionaire with a 2018 settlement that requires his tweets about Tesla to be pre-approved by the company's lawyers before being sent out.

Musk's lawyers filed a legal brief Wednesday with the federal appeals court in Manhattan arguing against a lower court's decision to uphold the deal with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Attorney Alex Spiro contends the SEC has used the pre-approval provision as a “government-imposed muzzle” on Musk's speech before it is even made on a broad range of topics.

“Since the judgment was entered, the SEC has maintained constant investigations into Mr. Musk’s speech, employing nebulous interpretations of the consent decree seemingly designed to curb and chill his future speech, all regarding speech entirely unrelated to the 2018 tweet for which the SEC initiated this action,” Spiro wrote.

Spiro adds the SEC has threatened to hold the CEO of Tesla in contempt of court for such speech despite the luxury electric vehicle maker's compliance with the settlement. The brief calls on the Second Circuit Court of Appeals to strike or modify the pre-approval provision.

ELON MUSK'S TWITTER DEPOSITION RESCHEDULED TO OCT. 6, 7

The settlement with the SEC was reached to resolve securities fraud charges related to a now infamous tweet in which Musk claimed he had “funding secured” to take Tesla private at $420 per share. The agency filed a lawsuit against Musk claiming he made “false and misleading” statements about Tesla’s privatization plans and that he “knew or was reckless in not knowing” that his statements were false and/or misleading.

Ticker Security Last Change Change %
TSLA TESLA INC. 287.81 +4.87 +1.72%

During the TED2022 conference in April, Musk maintained that funding to take Tesla private “was indeed secured” at the time and that he was “forced to concede to the SEC unlawfully” in order to save Tesla.

“At the time, Tesla was in a precarious financial situation, and I was told by the banks that if I did not agree to settle with the SEC that the banks would cease providing working capital, and Tesla would go bankrupt immediately. So that's like having a gun to your child's head,” Musk explained. “So I was forced to concede to the SEC unlawfully. Those bastards. And now it makes it look like I lied when I did not, in fact, lie. I was forced to admit that I lied to save Tesla's life, and that's the only reason.”

Elon Musk claims SEC settlement's tweet pre-approval requirement unlawfully muzzles his free speech
Elon Musk claims SEC settlement's tweet pre-approval requirement unlawfully muzzles his free speech
Image 1 of 2

Elon Musk speaks at SESSION 11 at TED2022: A New Era. April 10-14, 2022, Vancouver, BC, Canada.

In addition to the pre-approval requirement, Tesla and Musk each paid $20 million in fines. Tesla was also required to add two new independent board directors and Musk was stripped of his chairman title. Under the terms of the settlement, Musk and Tesla neither admitted nor denied wrongdoing.

In April, U.S. District Judge Lewis Liman in New York rejected Musk’s bid to throw out the settlement and denied a motion to nullify a subpoena of Musk seeking information about possible violations of the settlement.

Liman called Musk and Tesla's claims of harassment “meritless” and argued that Musk's claim of economic duress is “wholly unpersuasive,” citing the fact that he was already a multi-billionaire in 2018.

“Musk cannot now seek to retract the agreement he knowingly and willingly entered by simply bemoaning that he felt like he had to agree to it at the time but now — once the specter of the litigation is a distant memory and his company has become, in his estimation, all but invincible — wishes that he had not,” Liman wrote at the time.

Elon Musk claims SEC settlement's tweet pre-approval requirement unlawfully muzzles his free speech

The headquarters of the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is seen in Washington, DC, Jan. 28, 2021. (SAUL LOEB/AFP via Getty Images / Getty Images)

The SEC, which did not immediately return FOX Business' request for comment on Wednesday's filing, is currently investigating whether Musk violated the settlement with tweets last November asking Twitter followers if he should sell 10% of his Tesla stock.

The Associated Press contributed to this report

NEWS RELATED

'He never should have run for this seat'

When Herschel Walker entered the U.S. Senate race with the backing of his longtime friend Donald Trump, Georgia Republicans were not naive about the challenges ahead. The retired football star had no prior political experience. He had a messy personal life, only some of which he had publicly acknowledged. But ...

View more: 'He never should have run for this seat'

Musk proves Hunter Biden censorship came from collusion among Biden campaign, law enforcement and Twitter

Over the December 3 weekend, new Twitter CEO Elon Musk gave a slew of documents to writer Matt Taibbi regarding internal discussions at the company on how to handle the New York Post story on Hunter Biden’s laptop during the 2016 election. The Post story had broken on October 14, ...

View more: Musk proves Hunter Biden censorship came from collusion among Biden campaign, law enforcement and Twitter

China's Xi to Visit Riyadh as Saudi Arabia Seeks to Expand International Reach

Xi’s followed an invitation from Saudi Arabia’s King Salman, and will be attended by other Arab heads of state.e China-Gulf Cooperation Council Summit in Riyadh, according to the Chinese foreign ministry. The visit, which will span three days, followed an invitation from Saudi Arabia’s King Salman. Chinese President Xi ...

View more: China's Xi to Visit Riyadh as Saudi Arabia Seeks to Expand International Reach

Polygamous Leader in Arizona Had Over 20 Wives, Many of Them Minors,

The document filed Friday provides new insight about what investigators have found in a case that first became public in August.

View more: Polygamous Leader in Arizona Had Over 20 Wives, Many of Them Minors,

China Rolls Back Strict Anti-COVID-19 Measures on Travel and Production After Mass Protests

The announcement follows recent street protests in several cities over the strict “zero-COVID” policy now entering its fourth year.

View more: China Rolls Back Strict Anti-COVID-19 Measures on Travel and Production After Mass Protests

Teen at Sen. Ted Cruz’s home hospitalized after ‘self-inflicted cutting’ emergency call

A 14-year-old girl reportedly suffered self-inflicted stab wounds on the arms. WADE VANDERVORT/AFP via Getty Images Police and emergency personnel responded to the Houston home of Sen. Ted Cruz Tuesday night after receiving a call of a teenage girl injured with “self-inflicted” cuts, according to local reports. A 14-year-old ...

View more: Teen at Sen. Ted Cruz’s home hospitalized after ‘self-inflicted cutting’ emergency call

‘No lack of wildness’ - a car-free break on the John Muir Way, Scotland

Pioneering conservationist John Muir was born in Dunbar on the east coast of Scotland in 1838, and his birthplace is now a museum. He moved to the US when he was 11 and went on to create the Sierra Club organisation, which still protects Yosemite and other national parks. ...

View more: ‘No lack of wildness’ - a car-free break on the John Muir Way, Scotland

Notice a Change on I-76? PennDOT Says Crashes, Travel Time Are Down. This Is Why

Notice a Change on I-76? PennDOT Says Crashes, Travel Time Are Down. This Is Why Drivers traveling the Schuylkill Expressway (Interstate 76) through Montgomery County, Pennsylvania, may notice their commute is getting better, and PennDOT claims for a lot of people, it should be. The Pennsylvania Department of Transportation ...

View more: Notice a Change on I-76? PennDOT Says Crashes, Travel Time Are Down. This Is Why

Infinix Malaysia to throw 12.12 year-end sale on Shopee and Lazada soon

FBI: Polygamous leader had 20 wives, many of them minors

‘Who should get my mother’s diamonds?’ My late sister left them to her son’s wife. I pleaded with my nephew, but he won’t budge. What options do I have?

20 arrested over suspected illegal gambling activities, more than $118,000 seized

Tesla Model 3 launched in Thailand – from ~RM221k, up to 614 km range

US Jews fear collision with expected Israeli government

Report: 25 people detained in far-right raids across Germany

Portugal coach Fernando Santos admits Cristiano Ronaldo's role in the squad needs to be redefined

Calvin and Hobbes: Bill Watterson Reveals Comic That Upset Readers most

Andrew Luck opens up about abrupt Colts retirement, biggest regret

Shania Twain Confesses She Had to Flatten Her Chest as a Child to Avoid Stepfather’s Alleged Sexual Abuse

Mitch McConnell Says Trump Would Have 'A Very Hard Time' Becoming President Again

OTHER NEWS

Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network