Kerry part-time firefighter not working when on standby for callouts, court finds

kerry part-time firefighter not working when on standby for callouts, court finds

Kerry part-time firefighter not working when on standby for callouts, court finds

A Labour Court finding that a part-time Kerry fireman cannot be considered to be working when he is on standby for callouts for a fire or other alert has been upheld by the High Court.

David Walsh, a retained firefighter since 2008 with Ballybunion Fire Station and who also runs a B&B in Ballybunion with his partner, had brought a Labour Court claim in which he submitted he was on call 168 hours a week, 52 weeks of the year, and had to turn up at the station within 10 minutes of a callout.

The Labour Court, in November 2022, found time spent on standby was not “working time” for the purpose of the Organisation of Working Time Act 1997 and the EU Working Time directive.

It said Mr Walsh was obliged to attend callouts averaging 1.7 hours a week, or 84 hours per annum.

He was not obliged to participate in all callouts but there was a 75% minimum attendance requirement, it said. The requirements placed on him did not “place him under major constraints and have a very significant impact on the management of his time”, it said.

He was able to pursue other activities for a significant portion of his standby periods, including running his own business.

Mr Walsh’s case then came before the High Court as an appeal on a point of law from a determination of the Labour Court. Kerry County Council, which operates the fire service, was the respondent and opposed Mr Walsh’s case.

Mr Walsh’s counsel, Conor Power SC, argued the Labour Court had looked at some factors, including that his client had to respond to an alert within 10 minutes and that he did not have to remain at any specific place during time spent on standby.

However, the Labour Court had erred in law in failing to take into account the overall impact of all the restrictions on him in determining that the time spent on standby was not working time, counsel argued.

Mairéad McKenna SC, for the council, said the High Court could only interfere with primary findings of fact made by the Labour Court if it was satisfied there was no evidence to support them.

In this case, nearly all the findings of fact made by the Labour Court had been agreed, or had not been seriously controverted, she said.

Therefore, there was no basis for the High Court to set aside any of the primary findings of fact made by the Labour Court, or the inferences drawn by it, she argued.

Mr Justice Anthony Barr dismissed the appeal.

He said the Labour Court had regard to relevant factors which could be deemed to be constraints on Mr Walsh’s ability to carry out activities while on call.

It was entitled to reach the conclusion that the constraints on him were not such as to “objectively and very significantly” affect him freely managing his time and pursuing his business and social interests during his periods on standby, he said.

He was satisfied there was no basis on which to set aside the decision of the Labour Court as having been reached through an error of law.

Would you like a lunchtime summary of content highlights on the Irish Examiner website? Delivered straight to your inbox at 1pm each day.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Paul Hosford: Helen McEntee's future depends on the streets of Dublin remaining peaceful

Paul Hosford: Helen McEntee’s future depends on the streets of Dublin remaining peaceful The issue of policing in Dublin has been thrown into sharp focus following the horrific stabbing of ... Read more »

Five hospitalised following 'serious' two vehicle road traffic collision

The collision occurred on Monday morning. (stock image) Five people have been hospitalised following a two vehicle road traffic collision on Monday. Gardaí are appealing for witnesses to the collision, ... Read more »

Challenge: Try to find the hidden cat in a very old building

Challenge: Try to find the hidden cat in a very old building (Photo: Reproduction/Reddit) Only people with advanced observation skills can identify the hidden cat in this very old building. ... Read more »

Man arrested following suspected cocaine seizure in Galway worth €56,000

A man has been arrested following a seizure of cocaine with a value of €56,000 in Galway on Sunday evening. Gardaí seized the drugs during a search at a residence ... Read more »

Parkinson's Disease Warning Signs: What To Look Out For

generic doctor image Overview A chronic and progressive movement disorder that initially causes tremor in one hand, stiffness or slowing of movement. Symptoms If you or someone you know is ... Read more »

Man caught with over €1M worth of cocaine in van has jail time doubled in appeal

A man who was caught with over €1 million in cocaine in a “sophisticated” operation where the drugs were hidden in a modified compartment in his van has had his ... Read more »

Fine Gael TD Fergus O'Dowd announces he will stand down after the next General Election

File image of Fine Gael TD Fergus O’Dowd. FINE GAEL TD Fergus O’Dowd has announced that he will stand down at the next General Election. O’Dowd started his political career ... Read more »
Top List in the World