Federal judge orders Justice Department to put forward proposed redactions on Mar-a-Lago affidavit

Documents related to the search warrant for former President Donald Trump's Mar-a-Lago estate in Palm Beach, Fla. AP

West Palm Beach, Fla.: A federal judge on Thursday ordered the Justice Department to put forward proposed redactions as he committed to making public at least part of the affidavit supporting the search warrant for former President Donald Trump’s estate in Florida.

US Magistrate Judge Bruce Reinhart said that under the law, it is the government’s burden to show why a redacted version should not be released and prosecutors’ arguments Thursday failed to persuade him. He gave them a week to submit a copy of the affidavit proposing the information it wants to keep secret after the FBI seized classified and top secret information during a search at Trump’s Mar-a-Lago estate last week.

The hearing was convened after several news organizations, including The Associated Press, sought to unseal additional records tied to last week’s search, including the affidavit. It is likely to contain key details about the Justice Department’s investigation examining whether Trump retained and mishandled classified and sensitive government records.

The Justice Department has adamantly opposed making any portion of the affidavit public, arguing that doing so would compromise its ongoing investigation, would expose the identities of witnesses and could prevent others from coming forward and cooperating with the government.

The attorneys for the news organizations, however, argued that the unprecedented nature of the Justice Department’s investigation warrants public disclosure.

“You can’t trust what you can’t see,” said Chuck Tobin, a lawyer representing the AP and several other news outlets.

In addition to ordering the redactions, the judge agreed to make public other documents, including the warrant’s cover sheet, the Justice Department’s motion to seal the documents and the judge’s order requiring them to be sealed.

Those documents showed the FBI was specifically investigating the “willful retention of national defense information,” the concealment or removal of government records and obstruction of a federal investigation.

Jay Bratt, a top Justice Department national security prosecutor, had argued that the affidavit should remain hidden from the public. Unsealing it, he said, would provide a “road map” of the investigation — which is in its “early stages” — and expose the next steps to be taken by federal agents and prosecutors.

He argued it was in the public interest for the investigation, including interviews of witnesses, to go forward unhindered.

As the hearing kicked off, a small caravan of vehicles with Trump flags drove past the federal courthouse in West Palm Beach, Florida. An attorney for Trump, Christina Bobb, was in the courthouse Thursday but said she was only there to observe the court proceeding.

Bratt argued in court that even a redacted version of the document could reveal investigative steps or create the ability for sleuths or those being eyed in the investigation to identify witnesses in the case. He also contended that the Justice Department had already gone to rare lengths to bring transparency, including making a request for the court to unseal the warrant and property receipt, which were made public last week.

“There is heightened interest,” he conceded. “This is likely an unprecedented situation.”

Trump, in a Truth Social post last week, called for the release of the unredacted affidavit in the interest of transparency.

Reinhart gave the government until next Thursday to submit its version with the proposed redactions along with written arguments for each, going line by line. He said he would then review the proposal and make his own proposed redactions and then may meet with government lawyers to give them a final argument for why specific information should be withheld.

Justice Department attorneys have argued in court filings that the investigation into Trump’s handling of “highly classified material” is ongoing and that the document contains sensitive information about witnesses.

A recent filing by Bratt and Juan Antonio Gonzalez, the US attorney in Miami, says making the affidavit public would “cause significant and irreparable damage to this ongoing criminal investigation.”

“If disclosed, the affidavit would serve as a roadmap to the government’s ongoing investigation, providing specific details about its direction and likely course, in a manner that is highly likely to compromise future investigative steps,” they wrote.

FBI agents searched Trump’s Mar-a-Lago estate on 8 August, 2022, removing 11 sets of classified documents, with some not only marked top secret but also “sensitive compartmented information,” according to a receipt of what was taken that was released Friday. That is a special category meant to protect the nation’s most important secrets that if revealed publicly could cause “exceptionally grave” damage to US interests. The court records did not provide specific details about information the documents might contain.

NEWS RELATED

Jimmy Vesey gets chance to prove himself with Rangers’ top line

Jimmy Vesey is just the latest player to get a look on the Rangers’ top line next to Chris Kreider and Mika Zibanejad, which has given the 29-year-old even more of an opportunity to showcase himself in the final days of his professional tryout contract. “We put him everywhere,” coach ...

View more: Jimmy Vesey gets chance to prove himself with Rangers’ top line

Calgary city council approves ‘missing middle’ zoning with minor changes

After two days of hearing from the public and hours of debate, Calgary city council has approved changes to local zoning rules, including the creation of a new zoning category for higher-density developments. Council voted 9-6 in favour of the changes with Coun. Sean Chu, Sonya Sharp, Andre Chabot, Terry ...

View more: Calgary city council approves ‘missing middle’ zoning with minor changes

Norman Reedus reveals how his daughter Nova, 3, helped him propose to Diane Kruger: 'Everybody's crying'

The Walking Dead action star Norman Reedus told the story about how he proposed to his babymama – Cannes best actress winner Diane Kruger – after a motorcycle trip to Savannah, GA in August 2021. The Florida-born 53-year-old said on Jimmy Kimmel Live! on Tuesday: ‘Well, I had the ring ...

View more: Norman Reedus reveals how his daughter Nova, 3, helped him propose to Diane Kruger: 'Everybody's crying'

South African man who brought 34kg of rhino horns worth $1.2m into S'pore charged

SINGAPORE – A South African man who brought more than 34kg of rhinoceros horns worth $1.2 million into Singapore without a valid export permit was charged in court on Thursday. This is the largest seizure of rhinoceros horns in Singapore. Gumede Sthembiso Joel, 32, and the 34.25kg of African ...

View more: South African man who brought 34kg of rhino horns worth $1.2m into S'pore charged

Myanmar hands 10-year prison sentence to Japanese journalist

Myanmar hands 10-year prison sentence to Japanese journalist A court in military-ruled Myanmar has sentenced a Japanese journalist to prison after he filmed an anti-government protest in July FILE – An image of Toru Kubota, a Japanese journalist detained in Myanmar while covering a protest, is displayed at the Japan ...

View more: Myanmar hands 10-year prison sentence to Japanese journalist

Cool Cats secures strategic investment from Animoca Brands

Cool Cats Group LLC, the web3 company behind the iconic blue-chip non-fungible token (NFT) collection Cool Cats, announced Wednesday that it has received a strategic investment from Animoca Brands, the Hong Kong-based company advancing digital property rights for gaming and the open metaverse. The partnership will drive Cool Cats’ ...

View more: Cool Cats secures strategic investment from Animoca Brands

DynaLIFE says routine urinalysis testing to return to normal in Alberta on Thursday

Urinalysis testing for Albertans at DynaLIFE facilities will return to normal on Thursday, according to a spokesperson for the health-care company. Last month, DynaLIFE and Alberta Precision Laboratories sent a memo to doctors, nurses and lab staff saying constrained supply levels of urinalysis reagent used across Canada was impacting community ...

View more: DynaLIFE says routine urinalysis testing to return to normal in Alberta on Thursday

Pregnant homeless Florida mom shot while sleeping in car with 3 children

A pregnant Florida mom was shot in the head while sleeping in a car next to her children. Tampa Police Department A pregnant homeless mother was shot in the head Wednesday morning as she and her three children slept inside the family’s rental car in Florida, police said. The ...

View more: Pregnant homeless Florida mom shot while sleeping in car with 3 children

Keanu Reeves suits up while sporting a salt-and-pepper beard as he signs memorabilia for fans outside Jimmy Kimmel Live taping in Hollywood

At least 66 US clinics have halted abortions, institute says

Vegan-friendly mac and 'cheese' and chili perfect for cozy fall cooking

The Conners Season 5 Episode 3 Revealed Some Surprising Parallels Between Darlene And Roseanne

Texas trooper under investigation for Uvalde massacre response now a cop for school district

Silicon Island

The Scorpion Renaissance Is Upon Us

Scrubs producer Eric Weinberg charged with 18 counts of sexual assault

Lucky shopper wins Isuzu D-Max X-Terrain after spending just RM300

Willson Contreras ‘Nostalgic' as Cubs Career Reaches Likely End

Does 'The Rings Of Power' rule them all?

Diplomat says Myanmar court gives 10-year prison sentence to Japanese journalist who filmed anti-government protest

OTHER NEWS

Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network