Fetterman wins Senate dress-code battle — and beclowns the institution

opinion, casual, clothing, john fetterman, senate, suits, fetterman wins senate dress-code battle — and beclowns the institution

Sen. John Fetterman sporting his signature hoodie while speaking with Joe Biden. AP

John Fetterman’s Senate legacy is now set — he’s the guy who made it possible to dress like a slob.

What the Missouri Compromise was to Henry Clay, what the Second Reply to Hayne was to Daniel Webster, what the Civil Rights Act of 1957 was to Lyndon Johnson, Carhartt sweatshirts and baggy shorts will be to John Fetterman.

The Pennsylvania senator is the poster boy — if self-indulgent sloppiness is your thing — for his chamber dropping a dress code that required senators to dress in business attire when appearing on the Senate floor.

Fetterman briefly complied with the rule by making the sacrifice of putting on a suit and tie after he was first elected.

Then he reverted to his standard uniform that makes it look like he just showed after sitting on his couch, surrounded by empty pizza boxes, watching football games all weekend.

There’s business casual, then there’s Fetterman’s garb.

It wouldn’t be acceptable at many fraternity events around the country.

Philadelphia Eagles fans dress more carefully on game days.

If he showed at almost any service or working-class job in America dressed this way, his supervisor would give him a stern talking to and insist that he have more respect for himself, his colleagues and his customers.

But as it happens, he’s only a United States senator, so he can wear whatever he damn pleases.

When the history of the decline of American institutions is written, the jettisoning of the Senate dress code may not be more than a footnote, yet it will deserve mention.

It has long been remarked that it matters how we dress. Mark Twain is sometimes said to have written (in what’s actually a paraphrase), “Clothes make the man. Naked people have little or no influence on society.”

It turns out that slovenly people do, however.

The business suit as we know it had its origins in the court of British King Charles II.

Then the 19th-century British trendsetter Beau Brummell made an important contribution by simplifying the outfit.

After various twists and turns, by the mid-20th century in the United States, the modern suit had arrived.

As an article in The Atlantic notes, “It appeared on everyone from cab drivers to business executives, and made all appear polished and professional.”

The unraveling began several decades ago with the advent of Causal Friday, which eventually spread into Casual Everyday.

The Senate giving way to this ethos after a couple of centuries of a higher standard is a sign of the times.

We no longer reliably produce people willing to conform themselves to the norms and expectations of their institutions; personal brands are considered more important.

And the leaders of institutions tend to lack the courage to insist on rules that may no longer be fashionable, even if they still serve an important function.

It’s not that John Fetterman is going to be a better or worse senator depending on how he dresses — he’ll be a party-line vote regardless.

But his dress speaks to how he regards his position.

This would be obvious in other contexts. If someone shows up at a funeral or a wedding in jeans and a T-shirt, it is taken, understandably, as sign of disrespect, as an unwillingness to make the basic effort to acknowledge the solemnity of the occasion.

A session of the Senate isn’t as fraught and meaningful as a wedding or a funeral, but it should be considered an event of some consequence.

The history of the body stretches back to the beginning of the republic, and it is invested with considerable power.

Dressing appropriately acknowledges this; dressing as if it’s a bowling alley disregards it.

Would we take a judge as seriously without his or her robes? Or an officer of the law without his or her uniform?

Fetterman has won this battle but at the price of beclowning himself and his institution — not that he cares.

Twitter: @RichLowry

News Related


New York’s very serious City Council never fails to take up our most pressing issues… right?

The New York City Council has advanced a bill that would remove historical figures like Christopher Columbus and George Washington from city property. Paul Martinka When the New York City ... Read more »

Earth to Matt Gaetz: Narcissistic nihilism only helps the left

Rep. Matt Gaetz keeps threatening to force a vote of confidence in Speaker Kevin McCarthy. REUTERS Rep. Matt Gaetz is now winning praise from The New York Times’ Michelle Cottle ... Read more »

Biden and the autoworkers union: a roundabout of inflationary hypocrisy

We shouldn’t be too surprised 13,000 United Auto Workers went on strike last week and thousands more may soon join them on the picket lines. Although strikes are still rare ... Read more »

The UN’s ‘harmony with nature’ goal is full of fantasy, waste and wasted opportunities

The UN’s Secretary-General Antonio Guterres demands a “tripling” of global development aid — “at least $500 billion for the rest of decade” — to ignite progress on the UN Sustainable ... Read more »

Soviet-style grocery stores won’t save Chicago from pro-crime pols

Chicago mayor Brandon Johnson is really showing his socialist cred. He’s announced a plan to possibly open city-owned grocery stores in so-called food deserts in Chicago, following the closures of ... Read more »

Joe Biden’s Trumpy treatment of Garland proves he’s just like Donald

President Biden appears to be in a row with US Attorney General Merrick Garland. REUTERS President Joe Biden is looking remarkably Trumpian when it comes to handling the US attorney ... Read more »

Browns’ Nick Chubb exits ‘Monday Night Football’ with ghastly knee injury

Nick Chubb was carted off the field in Pittsburgh on Monday after the Browns running back suffered what appeared to be a knee injury. On a first-and-goal at 8-yard line, ... Read more »

The troubling rush to judge Russell Brand guilty or not — with a stunning lack of skeptics

Columnist Brendan O’Neill questions the fast judgement over allegations levied at Russell Brand. Getty Images/ Carl Court So, this Russell Brand thing. Is it an open-and-shut case of rape? Or ... Read more »

Like other ‘antiracist’ activists, Ibram X. Kendi proves he’s only in it for himself

Dr. Ibram X. Kendi speaks onstage during Netflix’s “Stamped From The Beginning” world premiere during the Toronto International Film Festival at TIFF Bell Lightbox. The real measure of an individual’s ... Read more »

With politics now ‘The Jerry Springer Show,’ what’s a voter to do?

Columnist Daniel McCarthy believes American political scandals can confuse voters who to vote for. Shutterstock “The Jerry Springer Show” has been off the air for years, but you’d never know ... Read more »

Now the WHO demands answers from China on COVID? It’s too late

The World Health Organization’s initial 2021 “investigation” called the leak theory “extremely unlikely” — but the agency eventually disowned it. Shutterstock Now the World Health Organization steps up pressure on ... Read more »

Day-care drug nightmare: Letters to the Editor — Sept. 19, 2023

The Issue: A toddler who died and three who are in the hospital after exposure to fentanyl at day care. As a former pre-school owner and educational director, not to ... Read more »

Dems’ Oliver Anthony problem, DNC icing out RFK, Jr. and other commentary

Robert Kennedy Jr. is hinting at a third-party run for president because the Democratic National Committee’ is “rigging” the primaries against him to benefit Biden. Fox News Liberal: Dems’ Oliver ... Read more »

Biden protects the bloated bureaucracy over those they serve

Columnist Betsey McCaughey shames Biden for protecting bureaucracy instead of democracy.  REUTERS/Jonathan Ernst The Biden administration is setting a booby trap in case a Republican wins the presidency in 2024. ... Read more »

President Pinocchio Joe is a truly terrible liar

President Biden has repeatedly fabricated details about his own life to the media. Photo by Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images “No man,” said Abraham Lincoln, “has a good enough memory to be ... Read more »

Worst-dressed Sen. John Fetterman strikes blow for slobs everywhere

Chalk up another victory for the Senate’s #1 blue-collar cosplayer, Pennsylvania’s John Fetterman. Looks like the shambling lawmaker — after months of taking flak for his high-school-stoner, hoodie-and-gym-shorts outfits — ... Read more »

Rams’ shocking last-second field goal in loss to 49ers delivers brutal bad beat

The move left many fans shaking their heads, because the Rams still lost by seven points. FOX / NFL The Rams kicked a field goal to beat the clock but ... Read more »

Giants embarrassed by rival Cowboys in nightmare season-opening loss

The best thing about the way the Giants opened up their 2023 season was that the abuse they took and the sacks they allowed and the embarrassment they should feel ... Read more »

Marines were ordered to pick up human feces before they were allowed to leave Kabul: ‘Degrading and ridiculous’

Soldiers and Marines assist with security at an Evacuation Control Checkpoint during an evacuation at Hamid Karzai International Airport, Aug. 19, 2021 in Kabul, Afghanistan. U.S. Central Command Public Affairs ... Read more »

White House’s crude ploy vs. fuel prices to boost Biden for 2024

The price of gas is tied to the price of crude oil, and Goldman Sachs last week predicted the price of Brent crude oil will surpass $107 by December next ... Read more »

America doesn’t trust itself: Faith in US institutions and each other takes dangerous drop

Gerard Baker breaks down the downfall in public faith, how the lack of confidence in leadership happened and how to restore trust. AP/Patrick Semansky Congress, the presidency, the FBI, the ... Read more »

Biden’s broadband boondoggle, a telling walk-off and other commentary

President Biden’s “internet for all” promise didn’t include that the costs would pass on to the taxpayer, according to Reason’s J.J. Tuccille. AFP via Getty Images Libertarian: Biden’s Broadband Boondoggle ... Read more »

For 9/11 families, it’s 22 years without answers, justice or accountability

Families who lost their loved ones from 9/11 want justice and answers for the horrific event. REUTERS/Andrew Kelly For 22 years, my family and I — and most of all ... Read more »

Burning Man’s privileged twits leave behind a trashed Nevada campsite

Burning Man organizers must spend weeks scrubbing the site in Nevada’s Black Rock Desert. Getty Images/ Julie Jammot The heavy rains that shut down this year’s Burning Man festival have ... Read more »

The rowdy US Open encapsulates everything that’s wrong with New York City

The rowdy fans at Flushing Meadows during this year’s US Open is everything that’s wrong with NYC, according to columnist Nicole Gelinas. AFP via Getty Images/ Angela Weiss What could ... Read more »

How 9/11 helped open the door to NYC’s churches

The ban on worship services in public schools hampered new churches from starting and the expansion of existing churches needing a temporary home as they found larger meeting spaces. Getty ... Read more »

Adams’ truth on migrant crisis: Letters to the Editor — Sept. 11, 2023

NYC Mayor Eric Adams has warned about how grave the migrant situation in the city is. G.N. Miller/New York Post The Issue: Mayor Adams’ comment that the migrant crisis will ... Read more »

As 9/11 becomes history, ‘Never forget’ takes on new meaning

The 22nd anniversary of the September 11 attacks brings realization that upcoming adults look at the tragedy just as a moment in history. REUTERS/Andrew Ke Twenty-two years now: For all ... Read more »

A new settlement cuffs cops and guarantees more protests will become riots

Once again, the city has agreed to a bad court settlement that will make New York harder to govern. This one puts new cuffs on cops: The NYPD must stop ... Read more »

NY Democrats claim they’re working ‘behind the scenes’ on migrant crisis — fat chance

New Yorkers want Mayor Eric Adams to do more to manage the influx of migrants impacting communities. Matthew McDermott Is Mayor Adams, sorely burdened by inconvenient truths, telling a fib? ... Read more »
Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự