Gas should not be factored into our climate commitments – it is not a sustainable carbon source

With coal now globally acknowledged as a sunset industry, the next frontier in the fight to save our climate will be in the oil and gas sectors.

gas should not be factored into our climate commitments – it is not a sustainable carbon source
© Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved

To avoid the worst impacts of climate change by limiting global warming to 1.5˚C, global greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions must peak now and then drastically decrease by mid-century. To achieve this, we must make a rapid shift away from fossil fuels. Yet, an emerging and problematic narrative is that natural gas might help us achieve the goal of net-zero carbon emissions by 2050.

In a recent interview with the Sunday Times (26 September 2021), Environment Minister Barbara Creecy described gas as “an important transition enabler” because its emissions are half those of coal. However, she also pointed out that infrastructure associated with gas might effectively be a stranded asset by mid-century (a mere 30 years’ hence).

Creecy’s remarks came in the same week that Sasol announced its revised target for emissions – a reduction of 30% by 2030 (up from a much-criticised earlier figure of 10%).

At first glance, Sasol’s announcement appears to be a major step forward for the energy and chemical company and some clever wording evoked the Paris Agreement without claiming that its revised emission reduction target is in line with the global agreement to limit GHG emissions.

Insufficient details from Sasol’s updated strategy make it hard to judge the relative contribution of these newly announced mitigation measures. But, in the words of CEO Fleetwood Grobler, the reduction target will be achieved through a “mix of energy and process efficiencies, investments in renewables and a shift to incremental natural gas as a transition feedstock for our southern African value chain”.

This “coal-to-gas” shift is a far cry from what is needed to achieve the objectives of the Paris Agreement, particularly in southern Africa where, according to the IPCC, we potentially face more extreme impacts with every fraction of a degree of global warming due to our geographic location.

To allow for a 50% probability of limiting warming to 1.5°C, oil and gas production must decline globally by 3% each year until 2050, with most regions needing to reach peak production now or during the next decade. By 2040, global gas use needs to be halved.

Because of this, any major investments in developing new gas fields in Mozambique and/or infrastructure for gas import via pipeline or LNG terminals, will make it impossible for South Africa to deliver an emission reduction trajectory in line with the objectives of the Paris Agreement. Alternatively, these investments will be subject to considerations of much shorter lifespans, making them likely to end up as the stranded assets the minister warned against.

For Sasol to achieve its net-zero target by 2050 while consuming large amounts of fossil gas would require a very large amount of carbon offsets in the form of removals or implementing large-scale carbon capture and storage at Secunda (currently the world’s largest single-site emitting plant) and Sasolburg.

Considering the relatively high cost of both these options, it would be interesting to compare them to the scenario where Sasol’s business model pivots to 100% emission-free or even emission-negative technology.

These options exist and would build on Sasol’s proprietary Fischer-Tropsch (FT) technology, which is indeed well suited to play a meaningful role in a low-carbon future. Sasol already has a key competitive advantage as a producer of green hydrogen and/or green hydrocarbons if a suitable source of green carbon can be introduced to its operations.

While it is true that at the point of combustion, gas causes lower emissions than coal per unit of energy produced, a fair comparison must account for the total climate impact of gas, including fugitive emissions of methane, the main component of natural gas. Fossil-based methane has a global warming potential 29.8 times that of CO2 over 100 years and it can escape into the atmosphere at many different points in the supply chain.

These emissions are not unavoidable, but they take place due to insufficient monitoring and lack of financial incentives to address the leaks and have routinely been underestimated by industry and governments. In the fracking fields of northeastern British Columbia, for example, these emissions have been found to be 1.6 to 2.2 times higher than federal estimates or between 3.6% and 5.4% of the lifetime production of conventional gas wells.

Specific to South Africa, a proposed 3,500km national gas pipeline would have to be flared every 187km to avoid methane leakage. If operated as historically, emissions from existing and proposed gas infrastructure would exceed the carbon budget associated with a temperature rise within a 1.5°C trajectory.

The climate science is clear. Oil and gas fields need to be subject to much shorter lifespans to make sure the world has a meaningful chance of limiting warming to 1.5°C, and any new investments into gas fields and any related infrastructure that facilitates gas use stands in the way of the common objective to avoid a worsening climate crisis.

Credible decarbonisation plans for Sasol must involve an accelerated phasing out of coal and ramping up the use of renewables and sustainable carbon sources (and let’s be clear: fossil gas does not fall into this category). Any path other than this would simply be a case of more hot air. OBP/DM

Tjaša Bole-Rentel is the Bioenergy Programme Manager at WWF South Africa.

News Related


Car dependence grows despite drop in commuting

Although the traditional five-day working week could be over, motorists say they are still reliant on their cars. © Provided by Motoring Research RAC Car dependency remains Before the COVID-19 ... Read more »

What's behind Mercedes' F1 straightline performance gains?

© Charles Coates / Motorsport Images Valtteri Bottas, Mercedes W12 Having shown excellent straightline speed in recent rounds, particularly at the Turkish Grand Prix, Mercedes came under fire from Red Bull team ... Read more »

Petrol prices closing in on record high, analysis shows

© PA 2.63237994.jpg Petrol prices are being artificially inflated to a near-record high, according to new analysis. Increases in the wholesale cost of diesel is being “loaded onto petrol”, the ... Read more »

Formula 1 United States Grand Prix qualifying – Start time, how to watch, channel

© Zak Mauger / Motorsport Images Mick Schumacher, Haas VF-21, Lando Norris, McLaren MCL35M Valtteri Bottas set the overall pace on Friday, leading his Mercedes teammate Lewis Hamilton with a ... Read more »

Gauteng police bust BMW driver speeding at 216km/h

© Provided by The South African Gauteng South African Police Service (SAPS) officers nabbed a BMW driver who was traveling at a speed of 216km/h in his M4 coupe on ... Read more »

The 15 coolest concept cars we've ever seen

1/16 SLIDES © Wikimedia Commons The 15 coolest concept cars we’ve ever seen While many cars never make it past the concept stage, some eventually wind up on the highway—or at ... Read more »

UK drivers told to shop around as petrol prices head to new highs

Motorists are being advised to shop around for fuel before filling up this weekend as the soaring cost of car ownership heaps fresh pain on squeezed household finances. © Provided ... Read more »

Life through a lens: What's been happening on Instagram this week...

1/11 SLIDES © Bang Showbiz How many likes did they get? It’s been a busy week on Instagram for the stars who have been sharing their every move and bit of ... Read more »

2021 Volvo XC90 petrol mild-hybrid to be launched in India soon

© Jay Shah 2021 Volvo XC90 petrol mild-hybrid to be launched in India soon – 2.0-litre diesel powertrain to be discarded  – Expected to be launched in the coming weeks ... Read more »

An introduction to CarWale Track Day 2021: The CarWale Podcast

© Aditya Nadkarni An introduction to CarWale Track Day 2021: The CarWale Podcast Sonam and Aditya are back to bring you Episode 22 of The CarWale Podcast. In the latest ... Read more »

Motor racing-Mercedes not ruling out another grid drop for Hamilton

© Reuters/MIKE BLAKE United States Grand Prix By Alan Baldwin (Reuters) -Mercedes would not rule out Formula One title contender Lewis Hamilton taking another engine penalty this season after team ... Read more »

Petrol prices nearing record high, AA analysis finds

Petrol prices are nearing a record high, the AA has said. © PA The Petrol Retailers Association warned on Wednesday that fuel price records are ‘almost certain to be eclipsed’ ... Read more »

Safety fears rise as e-scooter's with speeds of up to 72mph are sold

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Super-powered e-scooters which can travel at up to 72mph are being sold by UK firms despite a warning they do not meet trading ... Read more »

UPDATE 2-Motor racing-Verstappen calls Hamilton a 'stupid idiot' as F1 rivals clash

* Verstappen and Hamilton go wheel-to-wheel in practice * Red Bull’s Perez fastest in second practice * Bottas led the way in the morning * Finn will have a five-place ... Read more »

The cars that are cults

1/27 SLIDES © Autocar The best-selling cars aren’t always the most exciting ones. The average motorist doesn’t care about downforce, heritage, horsepower or off-road capacity. To most, a car is a ... Read more »

'Stupid idiot!': Max Verstappen blasts Lewis Hamilton - hours after claiming pair had buried hatchet

© GETTY IMAGES ‘Stupid idiot!’: Max Verstappen blasts Lewis Hamilton – hours after claiming pair had buried hatchet – GETTY IMAGES Max Verstappen labelled title rival Lewis Hamilton a “stupid ... Read more »

Mercedes mulling over more Hamilton engine changes

© PA Images Close-up of Lewis Hamilton’s Mercedes W12 car. Austin October 2021 Mercedes boss Toto Wolff has said the team are having ongoing discussions about making more engine changes ... Read more »

Motor racing-Bottas leads Mercedes one-two in first U.S. GP practice

Oct 22 (Reuters) – Valtteri Bottas led title-chasing team mate Lewis Hamilton in a dominant Mercedes one-two in first U.S. Grand Prix practice on Friday with Red Bull’s championship leader ... Read more »

Verstappen blasts 'stupid idiot' Hamilton in US Grand Prix practice

© Jim WATSON Starring role: Lewis Hamilton was second-fastest races during the first practice session at the Circuit of The Americas in Austin, a track where he has won five ... Read more »

FP2: Perez pips Norris as Red Bull close the deficit

© PA Images Sergio Perez runs in FP2 in Austin. USA October 2021. Sergio Perez topped FP2 in Austin as Red Bull clawed back their gap to Mercedes, with Lando ... Read more »

Renault cutting car production due to chip shortage

© Provided by This Is Money MailOnline logo Renault is cutting car production by 500,000 this year due to a crippling global semiconductor shortage.  The car maker’s finance chief Clotilde ... Read more »

Etisalat builds a modern network for Expo 2020

© Provided by Khaleej Times Etisalat builds a modern network for Expo 2020 Etisalat has built a dedicated modern network for Expo 2020 Dubai to meet its exclusive requirements and ... Read more »

‘Stupid idiot!’ Verstappen and Hamilton clash again in US Grand Prix practice

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Mark Thompson/Getty Images Angst in Austin is an unfamiliar emotion for Lewis Hamilton, but the Mercedes team principal, Toto Wolff, is worried that engine ... Read more »

GM now finishing and shipping pickups it had parked for lack of chips

DETROIT — General Motors is more than halfway through shipping newly-assembled pickups that it had parked due to a shortage of semiconductor chips, a top executive at the No. 1 ... Read more »

Highly Modified Custom Porsche 911 GT3 Tears Up The Streets

© Provided by Motorious Not bad for a power wheels! Porsche has made a name for itself over the 90 years that its been producing automobiles for being Germany’s premium ... Read more »

German solar car firm Sono Motors files for U.S. IPO

Solar cell panels are seen on the hood of German solar car company Sono Motors' prototype car “Sion” in Munich, Germany, August 1, 2018. Picture taken August 1, 2018. REUTERS/Andreas ... Read more »

8 Accessories to Get Your Car in the Halloween Spirit

1/9 SLIDES © Frienda In case the decreasing daylight and creepy neighborhood decorations didn’t give it away, Halloween is just around the corner. We all know decorating our home is a ... Read more »

Sainz: Drivers will have to adapt for 'most demanding F1 season'

Carlos Sainz says that drivers will have to adapt and be prepared for next year’s record 23-race schedule, and especially the run of flyaway races at the end of the ... Read more »

Air travelers rip rental car companies in 2021 J.D. Power satisfaction study

Air travelers seeking rental cars are faced with higher prices and lower-quality rentals thanks to the ongoing effects of the pandemic, J.D. Power said in its 2021 North America Rental ... Read more »

Cars for Cannonball Run: Window Shop with Car and Driver

After a week’s hiatus when nothing changed, Window Shopping is back for mid-October. The subject? The event that made Car and Driver a cultural touchstone. And secured the legend of ... Read more »

Mercedes "suffering with reliability" on F1 engines

© Mark Sutton / Motorsport Images Valtteri Bottas, Mercedes W12 Mercedes revealed on Friday in Austin that it had taken a third fresh engine for Bottas in four races, resigning ... Read more »

Mercedes dismisses Red Bull "noise" on F1 straightline device

© Zak Mauger / Motorsport Images Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes W12 Mercedes’ strong straightline speed has been the source of fresh intrigue as the world championship battle between the Brackley team ... Read more »

The BMW M2 CS may be sold out, but you can still win one here

Autoblog may receive a share from purchases made via links on this page. Pricing and availability are subject to change. No donation or payment necessary to enter or win this ... Read more »

White House says no new deadlines on reconciliation bill

U.S. President Joe Biden stops to talk to reporters as he departs with Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi after meeting with Democratic lawmakers at the U.S. Capitol to promote ... Read more »

Dogged by engine issues, Mercedes dominate opening practise in Texas

© Jim WATSON Starring role: Lewis Hamilton was second-fastest races during the first practice session at the Circuit of The Americas in Austin, a track where he has won five ... Read more »

FP1: Mercedes fire early warning shot to Red Bull

© PA Images Lewis Hamilton in practice for the USGP. Austin October 2021. Valtteri Bottas and Lewis Hamilton topped FP1 in Austin, and ended the session almost a full second ... Read more »

Daimler CEO hopes to stabilize supply chain this quarter

Ola Kaellenius, chairman of Daimler AG, attends the presentation of the new Mercedes-Benz S-Class at the Daimler production plant in Sindelfingen near Stuttgart, Germany, September 2, 2020. REUTERS/Ralph Orlowski/File Photo ... Read more »

London Mayor Sadiq Khan to continue with ultra-low emission zone plans

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo London Mayor Sadiq Khan has refused to allow an extension to Monday’s deadline for new controversial ultra-low emission zones across the capital as ... Read more »

2021 Ford Bronco 2-Door Badlands: Review

1/20 SLIDES © Mike Meredith, Automotive Content Experience What Is It? One of the most highly anticipated models in many years, the 2021 Ford Bronco is an all-new off-road-oriented vehicle that ... Read more »

F1 driver Daniel Ricciardo to wear Dale Earnhardt-themed helmet at US Grand Prix

© Provided by CBS Sports Although he’s a native of Western Australia, Formula 1 driver Daniel Ricciardo is right at home this week as the series makes its annual trip ... Read more »