A study has found that dogs are unable to conceptualise a human's reputationCanines witnessed and experienced human handlers giving or withholding foodThey then showed no preference towards either the 'generous' or 'selfish' human

While they are known as man’s best friend, getting that friendship reciprocated will take a little more than a sneaky titbit from the dinner table.

This is because researchers have discovered that dogs cannot remember incidences of generosity, and so have no concept of a gift-giving reputation.

Animal behaviourists from the University of Veterinary Medicine Vienna in Austria conducted a study to see if canines would approach a generous handler over a selfish one.

They found that neither dogs nor wolves had a preference after they witnessed the handler giving out or withholding treats.

The study concludes that ‘reputation formation may be more difficult than expected for animals’, and questions whether it is even possible.

Giving dogs treats DOESN'T make them like you more: Study shows pooches don't remember generosity

Animal behaviourists from the University of Veterinary Medicine Vienna in Austria conducted a study to see if canines would approach a generous handler over a selfish one. They found that neither dogs nor wolves had a preference after they witnessed them handing out or withholding treats (stock image)

Giving dogs treats DOESN'T make them like you more: Study shows pooches don't remember generosity

Some studies say that dogs cooperate with humans because they can form an understanding of their reputations by observing them interacting with others. Dr Hoi-Lam Jim tested this ability and whether it evolved during domestication or was already present in their wolf ancestors. Pictured: Pack-living dogs with animal trainer at the Wolf Science Center

Among animals that live in groups, forming reputations of individuals can play an important role in cooperation.

Some studies say that dogs cooperate with humans because they can form an understanding of their reputations by observing them interacting with others.

Dr Hoi-Lam Jim tested this ability and whether it evolved during domestication or was already present in their wolf ancestors.

Her paper, published today in PLOS ONE, outlined the two-phase experiment that involved nine wolves and six dogs at the Wolf Science Center in Austria.

The first phase involved the animals observing an interaction between two humans and a dog, where the ‘generous’ human fed the dog and the ‘selfish’ human withheld food.

Afterwards, the test animal demonstrated whether they had formed reputations of the humans by choosing which of the two humans to approach.

The second phase tested whether each animal formed reputations after interacting directly with humans, who either fed them or withheld food.

Statistical analysis of the results suggested that the generous handler did not have a better reputation with either the dogs or the wolves.

The animals did not have a preference for them after either indirect observation or direct experience of their generosity with food.

Giving dogs treats DOESN'T make them like you more: Study shows pooches don't remember generosity

Experimental set up. The trainer and dog demonstrator would walk up to the partner, who would either say ‘here you go!’ and throw a piece of meat into the enclosure, or say ‘you can’t have it’, cross their arms and turn around with the food in their hand. After observing this a number of times, the test dog (subject) would be allowed to choose a preferred partner by walking over the dotted line to one of the crosses where they were stood from the blue circle


These findings do not support the idea that dogs and wolves are able to conceptualise humans’ reputations and act based upon them.

However, three dogs and two wolves did show some preference for the generous human after both witnessing them giving food to another animal and being fed themselves.

Wolves also paid more attention to the generous human when observing interactions with a dog.

The psychologists are calling for further research to be done to confirm their findings with a larger number of dogs or wolves.

An animal may be more likely to gauge and act according to a reputation while in a dangerous or stressful situations, or if they are particularly hungry.

The authors wrote: ‘In this study, there was only a small cost of not receiving a food reward if the animals chose the selfish partner.

‘Further, the trainer fed the subject every time he/she went back to the starting point for the next trial and the animals were not food-deprived before the test, thus they may not have been very motivated to choose the generous partner.’

Startling – Lyme Disease Diagnoses Have Skyrocketed 357% in Rural Areas

Video: Lawrence 'Moonman' Mooney 'not pursuing charges' after a late night pub scuffle that left him with bloody lip

'He tried to strangle me while driving': Kerry Katona says ex-husband George Kay would beat her EVERY DAY as she reveals hellish extent of his domestic abuse

As he picked up a jackhammer and removed my laundry tiles, all doubt left my heart

Chelsea player ratings vs Crystal Palace: Reece James the driving force but Wesley Fofana struggles again

Attendance Allowance: Pensioners could be missing out on DWP benefit worth £369 per month

Lawrence 'Moonman' Mooney 'not pursuing charges' after a late night pub scuffle that left him with bloody lip

Lewis Hamilton summoned to stewards for 'alleged breach of sporting code' in Singapore

Fern Britton puts on a brave face while leaving her hotel as she is seen for the first time since ex-husband Phil Vickery shared a kiss with her best friend Lorraine Stanton

Peyton Manning Could Reportedly Be Seeking Another Big Job

NFL World Reacts To Controversial Terry Bradshaw News

Supreme Court Could Overturn Gun Control Brought In After Vegas Shooting

Stoke City rally around Joe Bursik following tragic update

Jurgen Klopp refuses to blame fans for 'obvious feeling' after 'horrendous' moments in Liverpool draw with Brighton

Starts With A Bang Podcast #86 – Stars in the Universe

Video: 'We were HORRIBLE to watch': Jurgen Klopp admits Liverpool were 'all over the place' and 'not convincing' in their dismal draw against Brighton... as he claims his struggling side reminded him of when he first arrived at Anfield 

NEWS RELATED

Video: Shailene Woodley sizzles in a black gown with VERY daring leg split while Thylane Blondeau opts for a leggy mini dress as they lead the stars at the Monot show during PFW

Fury as vile eco-cretin, 21, pours bucket of FAECES on memorial to Captain Sir Tom Moore in a bizarre and sickening protest over private jets

Eco warrior pours bucket of human waste on memorial to beloved captainMaddie Budd, 21, a former medical student, carried out the shocking protestShe was trying to make a statement against the use of private jets in the UK Captain Sir Tom Moore raised over £30million for the NHS on his 100th birthday 

View more: Fury as vile eco-cretin, 21, pours bucket of FAECES on memorial to Captain Sir Tom Moore in a bizarre and sickening protest over private jets

Dapper Paul McCartney the day tipper... and 50 years on, he still looks fab in a double-breasted suit

It was a fab style when he wore it way back in 1971 – and Sir Paul McCartney rolled back the years last week as, looking dapper in a dark blue double-breasted ensemble, he went out to lunch. And just as he also did back in the 1970s, Macca sported ...

View more: Dapper Paul McCartney the day tipper... and 50 years on, he still looks fab in a double-breasted suit

EMILY PRESCOTT: Cara Delevingne sitting on a £42million fortune which includes Cara & Co and Hot Mess

As Britain’s highest-paid supermodel, Cara Delevingne’s wealth is as eye-popping as her colourful private life, with new accounts revealing she has £42 million in assets. And her career is clearly soaring across the pond as her accounts take in her two US subsidiary companies – Cara & Co (US) Inc ...

View more: EMILY PRESCOTT: Cara Delevingne sitting on a £42million fortune which includes Cara & Co and Hot Mess

Jordan Barrett looks sleek in a three-piece suit as he poses with model pal Georgia May Jagger at Paris Fashion Week

He strutted the Boss catwalk at Milan Fashion Week last Thursday. But Jordan Barrett swapped the runway for the red carpet on Saturday as he attended the exclusive Business of Fashion 500 gala at Paris Fashion Week. Dressed in a three-piece suit, the Australian model, 25, smouldered as he posed ...

View more: Jordan Barrett looks sleek in a three-piece suit as he poses with model pal Georgia May Jagger at Paris Fashion Week

Video: Graham Potter admits Chelsea were LUCKY Thiago Silva wasn't sent off against Crystal Palace before the Brazilian set up their equaliser... as he hails the Blues' for their 'character and spirit' to earn a late win

Why Australia's most expensive suburb is being accused of hypocrisy as locals whinge about a plan to turn sprawling mansion into an event venue

Plans to open heritage listed mansion to events sparked outrage among locals Swifts mansion in Sydney's eastern suburbs could host events on 41 days of yearLocals concerned unwanted drunks will run amok in ritzy Darling Point suburbs

View more: Why Australia's most expensive suburb is being accused of hypocrisy as locals whinge about a plan to turn sprawling mansion into an event venue

Nicola Peltz sports a cream mini and towering boots as she and husband Brooklyn Beckham step out after attending Victoria's PFW show following family feud

Nicola Peltz looked incredible as she stepped out hand-in-hand with husband Brooklyn Beckham in Paris on Saturday evening. The couple are in the French capital after attending Spice Girl Victoria’s first PFW show, and squashing any rumoured family feud in the process. The socialite, 27, put on a very leggy ...

View more: Nicola Peltz sports a cream mini and towering boots as she and husband Brooklyn Beckham step out after attending Victoria's PFW show following family feud

Liz Truss to face wretched week at Tory Party conference after mini-budget turmoil

Video: Bridgerton bombshells Simone Ashley and Phoebe Dynevor turn up the heat at George and Amal Clooney's starry inaugural Albie Awards

Pout of control! Lauren Sanchez puckers up as she dines with Jeff Bezos during Miami vacation - days after Amazon CEO's ex-wife Mackenzie Scott filed for divorce from second husband

Kylie Jenner flaunts her jaw-dropping figure in a sheer lace bodysuit with cleavage-baring cut out at the BoF Gala dinner during PFW

10 Classic Performance Cars Perfect For A Mid-Life Crisis

Woman who started petition calling for Holly Willoughby and Phillip Schofield to be sacked over 'queue jump' says 'it's destroying me'

Political leaders and actors among those set to take part in pro-unity group Ireland’s Future Irish unity rally in Dublin's 3Arena

Jamie Redknapp makes 'quality' Diego Costa admission after Bruno Lage decision

EXCLUSIVE: Boy George signs for I'm a Celebrity... Get Me Out of Here! and secures the biggest pay cheque EVER as he is offered almost $1m to appear

Video: Man City boss Pep Guardiola insists there will be 'zero problems' after he leaves the club... as the Spaniard's future at the Etihad remains unclear with his contract set to expire at the end of the season

No sympathy as Nottingham Forest boss delivers Brendan Rodgers verdict

West Bromwich: Red wall town that turned blue split on Liz Truss ahead of Conservative conference

OTHER NEWS

Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network