Letters to the Editor: The Constitution is flawed, but it works. Changing it invites upheaval

To the editor: I agree with columnist Nicholas Goldberg that holding a constitutional convention would be the wrong way to fix the flawed Constitution, particularly in our chaotic times.

I would go a step further. We should not be changing the Constitution, even when better times arrive.

The essence of our Constitution (and law in general) is not its inherent goodness, but its ability to maintain the social order. Successful societies of the past prospered with the creation of written laws, some of which we today see as absurd or unfair.

One can argue with Goldberg about whether giving tiny states the same number of senators as California or Texas is wrong, but we should be careful about making that into a Constitutional project. The framers knew what they were doing by making changing the Constitution very hard.

Jack Kaczorowski, Los Angeles

..

To the editor: Goldberg wonders whether his fear that a new constitutional convention could endanger the separation of church and state is a worst-case fantasy. It’s not. His fear is justified.

He further points out that delegates to such a convention would very likely be appointed by state Legislatures, the majority of which favor right-wing policies. A constitutional convention could rewrite or discard any provision of the Constitution.

The framers in the 1780s were far more determined to protect the equal rights of conscience of everyone, whether believer or nonbeliever, than the religious right wingers who would probably make up a majority of the delegates to a present-day convention.

Secular Americans never want more rights than anyone else. We just don’t want fewer rights. Can our religious right counterparts provide the same assurance of supporting equal rights for all?

Edward Tabash, Los Angeles

The writer, an attorney, chairs the board of directors of the Center for Inquiry.

..

To the editor: Article V of the Constitution sets forth the mechanism of amending it and guarantees equal suffrage of the states that cannot be revoked without their permission. Thus, unfortunately, this undemocratic feature of the Senate effectively cannot be amended.

It’s also worth noting that it takes two-thirds of the House and Senate to propose an amendment, and three-fourths of the states to ratify it. Thus, eliminating the electoral college will not happen because there are more than enough small states to prevent ratification.

Lastly, the high bar to amend the Constitution would prevent the 2nd Amendment from ever being modified or eliminated. So sadly, there’s little to no chance of any of these reforms being enacted.

Gregory Palermo, Carpinteria

..

To the editor: I hate to disagree with Goldberg, but the changes he seeks to the Constitution would be a disaster.

First, abolishing the electoral college would let large states like New York and California effectively run the country, with no say from small states.

Second, if I don’t like the actions of the government and want to protest in the street, I should still be able to carry a gun without law enforcement taking it away.

Finally, tiny Wyoming should have the same representation in the U.S. Senate as California — two senators. It should have the same relevance as bigger states.

Jacquie Mahoney, Claremont

NEWS RELATED

How to Watch Brazil Vs. Switzerland in 2022 World Cup

Brazil and Switzerland are both coming off World Cup-opening wins

View more: How to Watch Brazil Vs. Switzerland in 2022 World Cup

Israel's Likud signs coalition deal with anti-LGBTQ radical

Israel's Likud signs coalition deal with anti-LGBTQ radical Former Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu has struck a coalition deal with a small ultranationalist faction leader known for homophobic rhetoric and disparaging remarks about non-Orthodox Jews, a sign of the incoming government's hardline makeup JERUSALEM — Former Israeli prime minister ...

View more: Israel's Likud signs coalition deal with anti-LGBTQ radical

Niece of supreme leader asks world to cut ties with Iran

Niece of supreme leader asks world to cut ties with Iran The niece of Iran's supreme leader is calling for people to pressure their governments to cut ties with Tehran BAGHDAD — The niece of Iranian Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khameni is calling on people to pressure their governments ...

View more: Niece of supreme leader asks world to cut ties with Iran

Apple production shortfalls at China plant expected to result in loss of 6 million iPhone Pros

Apple and Foxconn raised their estimates of production shortcomings at the Zhengzhou plant over the past two weeks

View more: Apple production shortfalls at China plant expected to result in loss of 6 million iPhone Pros

Jean-Charles Castelletto Scores Cameroon's First 2022 World Cup Goal

Cameroon is finally on the board at the 2022 FIFA World Cup

View more: Jean-Charles Castelletto Scores Cameroon's First 2022 World Cup Goal

Jessie James Decker Defends Her Kids' Abs After Criticism

After some Instagram users called Jessie James Decker and Eric Decker's kids' muscles "strange" and "weird," the singer clapped back, calling the critics "unkind."

View more: Jessie James Decker Defends Her Kids' Abs After Criticism

FTC may block Activision Blizzard-Microsoft sale, faster Mercedes and more: Monday's 5 things to know

Federal Trade Commission is likely to file an antitrust lawsuit to block Microsoft's acquisition of Activision Blizzard

View more: FTC may block Activision Blizzard-Microsoft sale, faster Mercedes and more: Monday's 5 things to know

1.8 million chickens slaughtered in Nebraska over bird flu fears

OMAHA —  Nebraska agriculture officials say another 1.8 million chickens must be killed after bird flu was found on a farm, in the latest sign that an outbreak that has already prompted the slaughter of more than 50 million birds nationwide continues to spread. The Nebraska Department of Agriculture said Saturday ...

View more: 1.8 million chickens slaughtered in Nebraska over bird flu fears

Australia downgrades national terrorism threat from ‘probable’ to ‘possible’

Vivica A. Fox Responds to Kanye West's Campaign Video Featuring Herself and Others

Maryland plane crash: Pilot and passenger trapped for seven hours rescued after aircraft becomes tangled in power lines 100ft above ground

Supporting Our Schools: Nominate a Teacher Going Above and Beyond

Buffalo supermarket gunman plans to plead guilty in attack that killed 10, lawyers say

How to Watch South Korea vs. Ghana at the 2022 FIFA World Cup

Polio is back in Indonesia, sparking vaccination campaign

Treasury Yields Fall as Investors Look to Key Economic Data Releases for Hints About the State of the U.S. Economy

Passaic County to kick off next phase of $10M Lambert's historic estate overhaul

Police Take Down ‘Super Cartel' Cocaine Ring in Europe

Dem. Sen. Murphy questions whether law enforcement should be funded in states that refuse to enforce gun laws

Trump Alleges 'Seriously Troubled Man' Kanye West Brought White Supremacist To Mar-A-Lago Dinner

OTHER NEWS

Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network