Pokémon Fans Mixed On Experience Share Feature Making Diamond, Pearl Remakes Easier

pokémon fans mixed on experience share feature making diamond, pearl remakes easier
© Image: Nintendo An illustration of the Pokemon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl protagonists exploring the Underground.

Not every Pokémon player is happy about the new gameplay details that are emerging for Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl, the Switch remakes of Nintendo DS’ Pokémon Diamond and Pearl. In fact, a significant portion of the playerbase is currently upset because Exp. Share (a feature in which experience points are distributed among all members of a Pokémon party) is going to be permanently on.

The latest round of previews for the Pokémon Sinnoh-region remake games revealed that permanent Exp. Share will return and cannot be toggled off, which has prompted a lot of mixed reactions from the playerbase. Some welcomed the inclusion of a mechanic that would make it easier to raise Pokémon. Other players thought that spreading experience points across the entire party was a step backward for the remakes.

You might be wondering why this is causing a stir at all, since permanent Exp. Share was also a feature in Pokémon Sword and Shield. However, the difference is that those games were new titles in the series, while Pokémon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl are remakes of much-beloved Nintendo DS adventures. And if it’s always on, it also has gameplay implications.

In most prior games, battle experience was only distributed among the Pokemon who actually participate in a battle, which gave players more control over how their Pokémon were trained. And even when a game had Exp. Share, it was an item that would only grant non-participant experience points to the Pokémon who were holding one. So some players are worried that the developers are taking control away from them.

Another contributor to the outrage is the ongoing controversy over the main Pokémon games becoming “too easy.” Several commenters on the Serebii.net’s tweet about the news seemed aghast that the Sinnoh remakes would supposedly be capitulating to more casual Pokémon players (many of whom will be literal children). As ever, the community has no shortage of gatekeeping sentiments concerning whether or not players who haven’t experienced the older games can be “true” Pokémon fans.

Nintendo / IGN (YouTube)

Other players were more pragmatic about their complaints. Some were concerned that a permanent Exp. Share would interfere with “effort values” training. EV are hidden stat points that are distributed to Pokémon after each battle, and they vary by the Pokémon species. For example, defeating a Pikachu usually gives a Pokémon EV points for speed, while a Snorlax gives them points for health. Exp. Share in prior games distributed EV points across the entire team, and there’s a ceiling to how many points each Pokémon can obtain. Competitive players will closely micromanage EV gains to avoid ending up with awkward stat spreads, so some players are nervous that a permanent Exp. Share will make training competitive Pokémon even more annoying than before.

Some people have pointed out that Pokémon can simply be placed in a box, where they would not gain any experience or EV points. Others pointed out that the far more annoying change was bringing back single-use technical machines (TMs), items that can teach special attacks to Pokémon. Personally, I just think we should stop arguing about a feature that’s been un-togglable for a whole mainline Pokémon game.

Pokémon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl will come out on November 19 for the Nintendo Switch.

News Related


Xbox studios head says he's not looking for an Uncharted or Horizon Zero Dawn

© Provided by GamesRadar Uncharted 3 Xbox Game Studios head Matt Booty says he’s not looking for Microsoft’s take on Uncharted or Horizon Zero Dawn. Speaking on the Kinda Funny ... Read more »

New Xbox Series X expansion cards from Seagate revealed

© Provided by GamesRadar Seagate Xbox Series X Expansion Cards Xbox has unveiled two brand new hard drive expansion cards for the Xbox Series X and Xbox Series S.  Announced ... Read more »

Razer launches its own PC components with liquid coolers, case fans, and power supplies

© Image: Razer Razer’s new PC components. Razer is expanding into PC components today with the launch of all-in-one (AIO) liquid coolers, case fans, and even platinum-rated power supplies. As ... Read more »

Bayonetta 3 guide - Everything we know so far

© Provided by GamesRadar Bayonetta 3 Bayonetta 3 is still one of the most anticipated Switch releases, and we’re getting ever closer to seeing the game finally release. While it ... Read more »

Battlefield 2042 seeing several gameplay changes from the open beta period

© Provided by GamesRadar Battlefield 2042 Hazard Zone Battlefield 2042 devs have revealed how the final game will differ from the recent open beta. In a blog post published earlier ... Read more »

New Larger Xbox Storage Expansion Costs More Than An Xbox Series S

© Image: Microsoft Three Xbox storage expansion cards, 512GB, 1TB and 2TB, floating on a gray, gray background. Microsoft has just announced two new SSD storage expansion cards, made by ... Read more »

League of Legends Netflix Animation ‘Arcane’ Will Stream Simultaneously On Twitch Featuring Drops

© Provided by Geek Culture Following the success of DOTA: Dragon’s Blood, it’s League of Legend’s turn in the spotlight. The upcoming animated series, Arcane, will be co-streamed on Twitch ... Read more »

Minecraft's The Wild Update is coming next year

© Provided by GamesRadar A snapshot of a stunning sunset shows off the new Wild Update Minecraft’s next major update will be called The Wild Update, and it’s coming next ... Read more »

Xbox Series X mini fridge pre-orders start next week

© Provided by GamesRadar The XSX mini fridge is nearly here It’s finally here, Xbox fans – Microsoft is accepting pre-orders on the replica Xbox Series X mini fridge from ... Read more »

New Gotham Knights trailer reminds us the Court of Owls is always watching

© Provided by GamesRadar Gotham Knights A new Gotham Knights trailer dropped during DC FanDome, and it’s all about the mysterious Court of Owls.  Gotham Knights is an upcoming action ... Read more »

Minecraft is coming to Xbox Game Pass on PC next month

© Provided by GamesRadar Best Minecraft servers Minecraft is coming to Xbox Game Pass on PC next month.  The Minecraft PC bundle includes both the Java and Bedrock versions. Announced ... Read more »

Alleged Elden Ring Xbox One footage leaks

© Provided by GamesRadar Elden Ring Elden Ring footage has allegedly leaked showing the highly anticipated game running on an Xbox One, of all things. Alleged Elden Ring footage from ... Read more »

Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League hides a bit of comic history in those prison uniforms

© Provided by GamesRadar Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League DC Fandome 2021 trailer The Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League trailer is hiding an Easter egg that hints at ... Read more »

Play as Superman’s dog in DC League of Super-Pets the video game

© Provided by GamesRadar DC League of Super-Pets: The Adventures of Krypto and Ace The upcoming DC League of Super-Pets movie is getting its own video-game spinoff, appropriately titled DC ... Read more »

Epic Games Store Will 'Welcome' NFT Games After Steam Bans Them

© Image: Epic Games / Kotaku Decorative Epic Games and its CEO Tim Sweeney are open to letting games that use blockchain technology and NFTs onto its PC store, even ... Read more »

Remastered GTA Trilogy Will Seemingly Feature GTA V-Style Controls And High-Res Textures

© Image: Rockstar Games Decorative If Grand Theft Auto: The Trilogy – Definitive Edition was a boat, it would have sunk by now after all the recent leaks. First, there ... Read more »

AnalogueOS bring save states, screenshots and more to Pocket

© Analogue “I’ve seen things you people wouldn’t believe.” Analogue, the boutique retro console manufacturer, has made a tradition out of pinning announcements to today’s date, October 16. First there ... Read more »

How to watch DC’s FanDome 2021 livestream

© Illustration: Lucia Pham for Polygon The 2021 DC FanDome streaming event is almost here, and the entire thing is going to be free for fans to watch. The four-hour ... Read more »

Dbrand pulls its PS5 Darkplates from sale after Sony threatens legal action

Earlier this year, Dbrand started selling matte black PS5 side plates that it called Darkplates, and when it did, it baited Sony right on the product’s info page to “Go ... Read more »

Epic will give you a $10 coupon if you let them email you

© Provided by GamesRadar Epic Games For a limited time, Epic Games is giving away $10 coupons to anyone who signs up for the company’s email and alerts program.  From ... Read more »

Monument Valley 2 adds new chapter to promote forest conservation

© Provided by GamesRadar Monument Valley 2 Four years from launch, Monument Valley 2 is getting a brand new chapter dedicated to conserving the Earth’s forests and battling climate change. ... Read more »

How a Final Fantasy 14 player uses a Ring Fit to explore Eorzea

© Provided by GamesRadar Final Fantasy 14 Controller modder SuperLouis64 has used his talents to combine the Nintendo Switch Ring Fit attachment with Final Fantasy 14 to host a charity ... Read more »

Epic says it’s ‘open’ to blockchain games after Steam bans them

© Illustration by Alex Castro / The Verge Epic tells The Verge that it’s “open to games that support cryptocurrency or blockchain-based assets” on its game store, unlike its competitor ... Read more »

Multiple Resident Evil announcements coming this month according to new teaser site

© Provided by GamesRadar Resident Evil timeline – Resident Evil 8 Capcom’s set up a new Resident Evil teaser site to showcase a month apparently packed with announcements for the ... Read more »

Cyber Monday Pokemon deals 2021 - here's what to expect from this year's sale

© Provided by GamesRadar Cyber Monday Pokemon deals Because Cyber Monday Pokemon deals come just a few days after Black Friday has wrapped up, we’re expecting them to be your ... Read more »

5 reasons to play Crysis Remastered Trilogy

© Provided by GamesRadar Crysis 3 The stealth. The suit. The sexy voice telling you ‘cloak engaged.’ It’s all back and better than before in the Crysis Remastered trilogy, out ... Read more »

Metroid Dread bug which can stop you from finishing the game will be fixed this month

© Provided by GamesRadar Metroid Dread A Metroid Dread bug that can stop players from finishing the game under specific conditions will be fixed in an update coming this month. ... Read more »

Animal Crossing Series 5 amiibo cards drop November 5 - here are all the cards confirmed so far

© Provided by GamesRadar Animal Crossing Series 5 Amiibo cards The Animal Crossing Series 5 amiibo cards are coming very soon, and will be adding a whole new suite of ... Read more »

This Acer Swift X is actually one of the best cheap gaming laptop deals we've seen all week

© Provided by GamesRadar Acer Swift X: cheap gaming laptop deal Amazon is currently selling the RTX 3050 Ti enabled Acer Swift X at its lowest ever price, but you’ll ... Read more »

Two Animal Crossing: New Horizons DLC drops are amazing for fans, and interesting for its future

© Provided by GamesRadar Animal Crossing: New Horizons – Happy Home Paradise DLC, the first paid DLC drop for the game I don’t think anyone was expecting Nintendo to drop ... Read more »

Genshin Impact now tracks all your free Primogems down to the minute you earned them

© Provided by GamesRadar Genshin Impact update 2.2 How many free Primogems do you get in Genshin Impact? A newly released account tracker called the Traveler’s Diary answers that and ... Read more »

Valve says no blockchain games or NFTs on Steam

© Illustration by Alex Castro / The Verge Games that use blockchain technology or let users exchange NFTs or cryptocurrencies won’t be allowed on Steam, according to a rule added ... Read more »

Skyrim players explain the mystery of a failed Dark Brotherhood assassination

© Provided by GamesRadar Skyrim The Skyrim community has been outlining a mystery surrounding the murderous Dark Brotherhood. In a recent post on Reddit, user upzylon says they found a ... Read more »

Here's what happens to your Animal Crossing: New Horizons DLC if you stop paying for Nintendo Switch Online

© Provided by GamesRadar Animal Crossing: New Horizons – Happy Home Paradise DLC, the first paid DLC drop for the game Players will only be able to access some of ... Read more »

Animal Crossing community goes into meltdown over the return of Froggy Chair

© Provided by GamesRadar Froggy Chair The Animal Crossing Direct has confirmed that one of the community’s favourite items is coming back to the game. Froggy Chair – a green ... Read more »

Animal Crossing: New Horizons Update 2.0 - Everything coming to your island for free this November

© Provided by GamesRadar Animal Crossing: New Horizon update 2.0 features In the Animal Crossing Direct, we were treated to a veritable banquet of new features, items, and locations set ... Read more »

15 things that prove that DOOM will run on literally anything

© Provided by GamesRadar null 15 things that prove that Doom will run on literally anything is a really weird headline, isn’t it? But I promise, from here on, things ... Read more »

Nintendo Switch Online + Expansion Pack price and date revealed, includes Animal Crossing DLC

© Provided by GamesRadar NIntendo Switch Online + Expansion Pack details The Nintendo Switch Online + Expansion Pack price has been confirmed, along with the reveal that it will also ... Read more »

Animal Crossing: New Horizons - Happy Home Paradise is the first paid DLC drop

© Provided by GamesRadar Animal Crossing: New Horizons – Happy Home Paradise DLC, the first paid DLC drop for the game Happy Home Paradise has been announced as the very ... Read more »

Everything announced at the Animal Crossing Direct

© Provided by GamesRadar Animal Crossing: New Horizons – Happy Home Paradise DLC, the first paid DLC drop for the game The Animal Crossing Direct is now over, and if ... Read more »