Promotion doesn't add up to gender equity at leading accounting firms
Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain

Often instead of making partner, women in public accounting firms appear to be sidelined into less prestigious, less powerful director positions, a study has found.

Examining public audits from the seven largest firms, including Deloitte and KPMG, researchers found that directors signing audit reports for nonprofit entities were twice as likely to be women than men, despite the fact that there are fewer female directors.

The analysis of this data, which is accessible because the audit clients are public institutions like nonprofits or universities, provides a window into promotion practices, said Kathleen Harris, an accounting assistant professor with Washington State University’s Carson College of Business.

“Women and men are hired into these public accounting firms at a very equal ratio, but at the partner level, it’s disproportionate,” said Harris, the corresponding author on the study published in the Journal of Accounting and Public Policy. “If we want equity in accounting, then both men and women need to be at the table making decisions.”

Partners and directors can both lead audits of nonprofit entities, but there are considerable differences between the two groups. Partners are the top leaders of their firms. They buy into the firm, hold voting power and help strategically plan how the firm goes forward. It is a high risk, high reward position, Harris said. Directors, while highly skilled and compensated, are salaried employees without voting power.

Both leadership levels lack gender equity with women making up 32% of directors but just 18% of partners, according to self-reports by large firms in 2016. This “vertical segregation,” where men are clustered at higher levels than women, was also noted in earlier research in 2011 with the director-level dubbed a “pink-collar ghetto.”

The current study shows that division is persisting. Harris and her co-authors, Elizabeth Almer of Portland State University as well as Julia Higgs and Joe Rakestraw of Florida Atlantic University, analyzed more than 1500 audit engagements from 2017 Federal Audit Clearinghouse data for the seven largest public accounting firms. They found that among audit signers, directors were more often women, and partners more often men.

In addition, audit clients paid more for female partners who signed audits versus female directors or even male partners and directors. This study could not determine exactly why that was the case, but Harris said it is possible that some audit clients with goals for increasing diversity may be specifically asking for women partners to lead their audits, driving up demand for a limited supply.

It is also hard to pinpoint the reasons for the continued gender equity problems in accounting leadership. Harris said it could involve unconscious bias, lack of opportunity for women to develop the necessary skills, or women themselves choosing not to take on leadership roles that require long hours away from family.

“The first point of change is awareness,” Harris said. “Once you identify a problem, the next step is to discuss what opportunities there are to develop equity in the firm.”

For instance, Harris suggested firms address work-life balance for both men and women versus assuming it is just an issue for one gender, which might help level the playing field. Advocacy and sponsorship are also key to helping women and other underrepresented employees advance into top leadership roles, and once more of them are there, it can help improve diversity overall.

“You can’t really hire diversity. You have to create an environment that attracts diversity,” Harris said. “For anybody going into accounting, if they can see themselves as a success story because they can see a partner that looks like them, then, it’s more attractive for them to enter that field.” More information: Elizabeth D. Almer et al, Gender equity in public accounting: Evidence from single audit partner and director engagement leaders, Journal of Accounting and Public Policy (2022). DOI: 10.1016/j.jaccpubpol.2022.106941 Provided by Washington State University Citation: Promotion doesn’t add up to gender equity at leading accounting firms (2022, August 17) retrieved 17 August 2022 from https://phys.org/news/2022-08-doesnt-gender-equity-accounting-firms.html This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

NEWS RELATED

Acne is a “disease of Western civilization.” Is overwashing to blame?

In the Western world, it’s rare to find someone who hasn’t faced a bout of acne at least once. Regardless of race, everyone seems to succumb to this unsightly skin condition, which occurs when hair follicles become plugged with oil and dead skin cells. At 80% to 90% prevalence ...

View more: Acne is a “disease of Western civilization.” Is overwashing to blame?

Weird Alibaba Products: This Mini Electric Ice Cream Trike Comes With a Pop-up Tent

If you are always searching for the oddest buys on the Internet for whatever reason, Alibaba has all the strangest stuff to fulfill your interests. The largest online retailer in China has a massive catalog of the most bizarre items, particularly electric vehicles. Alibaba is one of the largest retailers ...

View more: Weird Alibaba Products: This Mini Electric Ice Cream Trike Comes With a Pop-up Tent

Spotify Is Installing Itself on Some Windows PCs

Spotify, Microsoft Remember when Apple dumped a U2 album on everyone’s iPhone? Well, it seems that Microsoft is automatically installing Spotify on Windows 10 and Windows 11 PCs. Several users report that Spotify magically appeared on their desktop after a recent update. Reports of this problem bubbled up Reddit and Microsoft’s ...

View more: Spotify Is Installing Itself on Some Windows PCs

1,000,000 Times Thinner Than a Single Strand of Hair – Scientists Develop Leak-Free Nano-Pipes

Tubes, visible in light green, are roughly seven nanometers in diameter — about two million times smaller than an ant — and several microns long, or about the length of a dust particle. Credit: Johns Hopkins University The world’s tiniest plumbing could potentially funnel drugs to individual human cells. ...

View more: 1,000,000 Times Thinner Than a Single Strand of Hair – Scientists Develop Leak-Free Nano-Pipes

Power Armor 16 Pro unveiled on AliExpress for$159.99 and free Ulefone Buds

Power Armor 16 Pro preheat giveaway event is still going on and it has finally been disclosed on Ulefone official website. What’s more, from October 10th to October 13th this rugged machine will launch on AliExpress, priced at only $159.99. More importantly it is bundled with a set of free ...

View more: Power Armor 16 Pro unveiled on AliExpress for$159.99 and free Ulefone Buds

Study Reveals Main Target of COVID-19 in Brain and Describes Effects of Virus on Nervous System

Summary: SARS_CoV_2, the virus responsible for COVID-19 infects and replicates in astrocytes, reducing neural viability. Source: FAPESP A Brazilian study published in the journal PNAS describes some of the effects infection by SARS-CoV-2 can have on the central nervous system. A preliminary version (not yet peer-reviewed) posted in 2020 was one of ...

View more: Study Reveals Main Target of COVID-19 in Brain and Describes Effects of Virus on Nervous System

Long-Term Study Supports Link Between Inflammation and Cognitive Problems in Older Breast Cancer Survivors

Summary: Higher levels of the inflammatory C-reactive protein were discovered in older breast cancer survivors who experienced cognitive issues. The study is one of the first long-term assessments linking chronic inflammation to cognitive decline in breast cancer survivors. Source: UCLA Scientists are still trying to understand why many breast cancer ...

View more: Long-Term Study Supports Link Between Inflammation and Cognitive Problems in Older Breast Cancer Survivors

Work on to launch 5G in 200 cities within six months: Telecom minister Ashwini Vaishnaw

ETTelecomTelecom minister Ashwini Vaishnaw on Saturday said that the government is working to launch 5G in 200 cities over the next six months. Speaking to reporters on the sidelines of a roundtable conference meeting with the information technology (IT) ministers of different states, Vaishnaw said though the target was to ...

View more: Work on to launch 5G in 200 cities within six months: Telecom minister Ashwini Vaishnaw

Ashwini Vaishnaw bats for stronger laws for social media intermediaries

She-Hulk episode 7 features the most puzzling twist of the series

Podcast #695 – Ryzen 7000 Reviews, RTX 40 Series minus EVGA, Intel Arc A770 Soon, ARM everything! + MORE

Using Smartphones Can Help Improve Your Memory Skills

Google Stadia Will Shut Down in 2023, All Purchases to Be Refunded

Anker Teases Its Biggest And Most Capable Power Station Yet

7 new Netflix releases everyone will be streaming next week

Folic Acid Treatment Is Associated With Decreased Risk of Suicide Attempts

New Marker of ALS Outcome Identified

Hubble Space Telescope Detects Protective Shield Defending a Pair of Dwarf Galaxies

Annoyed When Netflix Trailers Play Automatically? Turn Them Off

The Best Way to Clean Battery Acid Off Your Gadgets

OTHER NEWS

Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network