Supernova Forensics: Eight Years Later, a Mysterious Stellar Explosion Is Still Revealing Secrets

The supernova known as 2014C took place eight years ago—but scientists are still watching and learning from its aftermath. The very faintly visible explosion is shown circled in red. Credit: Sloan Digital Sky Survey

Study including University of Chicago researchers analyzes aftermath of 2014 supernova.

An international group of astronomers has uncovered new clues about a mysterious stellar explosion that was discovered eight years ago, but is continuing to evolve even as scientists watch.

The results help astronomers better understand the process of how massive stars—giants far larger than our own sun—live and die.

The study was published in The Astrophysical Journal by a group led by the University of Texas at Austin (UT Austin) and including scientists from the University of Chicago.

The lives of 2014C

In 2014, astronomers spotted a sudden bright spot in the sky—a sure sign that a star had exploded out in space.

When an exploding star is first detected, astronomers all around the world race to follow it with telescopes as the light it gives off changes rapidly over time. By watching how it evolves, using telescopes that can see visible light and also X-rays, radio waves, and infrared light, scientists can deduce the physical characteristics of the system.

Supernova Forensics: Eight Years Later, a Mysterious Stellar Explosion Is Still Revealing Secrets

This schematic shows the various ejecta and winds (red and purple) given off by the exploding star (left, yellow). The common-envelope disk (blue) surrounds both stars, the one exploding as a supernova and its binary partner (not shown). The boundary layer around the common-envelope disk is the source of the hydrogen the team detected. Credit: B. Thomas et al./UT Austin

By doing this many times, astronomers have identified signatures and grouped these exploding stars into categories. 2014C, as this particular event was named, looked like what’s called a Type Ib supernova. They are what happens when the largest known stars in the universe die.In fact, scientists think 2014C was probably originally not one but two stars orbiting each other, one bigger than the other. The more massive star evolved more quickly, expanded, and its outer layer of hydrogen got sucked away. When it eventually ran out of fuel, its core collapsed, triggering a gigantic explosion.

Supernova Forensics: Eight Years Later, a Mysterious Stellar Explosion Is Still Revealing Secrets

Research Prof. Vikram Dwarkadas

However, observations in the first 500 days after the explosion had shown that it was emitting more X-rays over time, which was unusual and seen only in a small number of supernovae. “It suggested that the shockwave was interacting with dense material,” said Vikram Dwarkadas, University of Chicago research professor of astronomy and astrophysics.

The group set out to collect all of the data on 2014C, including new data they obtained as well as from studies over the past eight years, and to fit it into a cohesive picture of what happened to the star.

The X-ray emissions, infrared light, and radio waves all showed the distinctive pattern of increasing and then decreasing. Meanwhile, the optical light—measured by UT Austin’s Hobby-Eberly Telescope—appeared to stay steady. The radio signal showed that the shockwave was expanding at a very high speed, whereas the optical light indicated a much slower speed.

The researchers suggested that the odd behavior had to do with a dense cloud of hydrogen around the two stars that was left over from earlier in their lifetimes.

When the star exploded, it produced a shockwave traveling at something like 67 million miles per hour in all directions. As the shockwave reached this cloud, its behavior would be affected by how the cloud was shaped.

These supernovae are what happen when the largest known stars in the universe die.

In the simplest model, this cloud would be assumed to be spherical and symmetrical. However, if the cloud had formed a “donut” around the two stars—that is, thicker around the middle—the thicker part of the ring would slow down the shockwave, showing up in the optical light as slower-moving material. Meanwhile, in the thinner areas, the shockwave would rush forward, as seen in the radio waves. “Think of the water hitting a rock in the center of the river,” Dwarkadas said.

Questions remain, the scientists said, but this unevenness could account for the different speeds of the shockwave indicated by the different wavelengths.

The study provided valuable clues as to the evolution of these stars and mass lost from these systems, and in a larger sense to the lives and deaths of these relatively mysterious stars, the scientists said.

“In a broad sense, the question of how massive stars lose their mass is the big scientific question we were pursuing,” said UT Austin professor and team member J. Craig Wheeler. “How much mass? Where is it? When was it ejected? By what physical process? Those were the macro questions we were going after.

“And 2014C just turned out to be a really important single event that’s illustrating the process.”

For more on this research, see Extraordinary Supernova Reveals Secrets to Astronomers.

Reference: “Seven Years of SN 2014C: a Multi-Wavelength Synthesis of an Extraordinary Supernova” by Benjamin P. Thomas, J. Craig Wheeler, Vikram V. Dwarkadas, Christopher Stockdale, Jozsef Vinko, David Pooley, Yerong Xu, Greg Zeimann and Phillip MacQueen, 4 May 2022, The Astrophysical Journal.
DOI: 10.3847/1538-4357/ac5fa6
arXiv: 2203.12747

The study was led by Benjamin Thomas of the University of Texas at Austin. The other researcher from the University of Chicago on the paper was Yerong Xu, SM’20, now with the University of Palermo in Italy. For the full list of collaborators and telescopes, see the paper.

Funding: U.S. National Science Foundation, U.S. Department of Energy, NASA, Chandra Observatory, Hungary National Research, Development and Innovation Office.


The Carrington Event: History's greatest solar storm

During solar storms like the Carrington Event, the sun ejects material into space, and it can play havoc with technology.

View more: The Carrington Event: History's greatest solar storm

Lisa Feldman Barrett

Dr. Lisa Feldman Barrett is University Distinguished Professor of psychology at Northeastern University with appointments at the Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) and Harvard Medical School. Dr. Barrett is among the top 1% most-cited scientists, having published over 250 peer-reviewed scientific papers. She is the recipient of a NIH Director’s ...

View more: Lisa Feldman Barrett

Tesla driver involved in tragic California crash to stand trial

A Tesla Model S driver who was involved in a tragic crash in a Los Angeles suburb will be standing trial. The driver was believed to have been operating his Tesla with Autopilot when the crash occurred. According to a Los Angeles County Judge, there is enough evidence to ...

View more: Tesla driver involved in tragic California crash to stand trial

Dust Storms on Mars Happen When the Planet Can’t Release its Heat Fast Enough

Mars is well-known for its seasonal dust storms, which can sometimes grow to encompass the entire planet. In June 2018, the dust storms became so severe that they obscured most of the planet’s surface, causing NASA to lose contact with Opportunity, which eventually proved fatal to the record-breaking rover. ...

View more: Dust Storms on Mars Happen When the Planet Can’t Release its Heat Fast Enough

Webb Space Telescope Nearly Set to Explore the Solar System

The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) is the next of NASA’s Great Observatories; following in the line of the Hubble Space Telescope, the Compton Gamma-ray Observatory, the Chandra X-ray Observatory, and the Spitzer Space Telescope. JWST combines the qualities of two of its predecessors, observing in infrared light, like Spitzer, ...

View more: Webb Space Telescope Nearly Set to Explore the Solar System

Elon Musk denies sexual misconduct allegation

Musk says it's part of a politically motivated campaign against him.

View more: Elon Musk denies sexual misconduct allegation

Light pollution can disorient monarch butterflies

University of Cincinnati researchers found that light pollution can interfere with the internal compass of monarch butterflies. Credit: Michael Miller Besides planting milkweed in the garden, people interested in helping monarch butterflies might want to turn off the porch light. Biologists at the University of Cincinnati say nighttime light ...

View more: Light pollution can disorient monarch butterflies

Key Iraq irrigation reservoir close to drying out

An Iraqi rides a donkey across the dried out lake bed that is all that is left of Lake Hamrin, in normal years a key irrigation reservoir. Iraq’s Lake Hamrin, a once-vast reservoir northeast of Baghdad that is the sole source of water for irrigation across Diyala province, has ...

View more: Key Iraq irrigation reservoir close to drying out

Are Republicans and Democrats driven by hatred of one another? Less than you think

Wave Mixing Laser- and X-Ray-Beams

Mixing laser beams and X-ray beams

Scientists explain why meridional heat transport is underestimated

Topography and soil pH found to steer the activity-density and spatial distribution of termites in a fine-scale study

The snake trade in Indonesia is not sustainable enough—but it could be

Researchers find imperfections provide protection for system symmetry

Research reveals surprising inactivation mechanism for a voltage-gated ion channel

IAP releases datasets of frequent marine heatwaves in most ocean regions over two decades

Boeing's Starliner approaching ISS in high-stakes test mission

Space agencies provide global view of our changing environment

Hubble focuses on large lenticular galaxy 1023