Supreme Court: Panel recommended by law ministry did not have one person who could complete full 6 yrs as EC

Supreme Court of India

The list of bureaucrats the Union law ministry recommended to the prime minister for picking an election commissioner did not have the name of even one person who could complete the stipulated six-year tenure at the poll panel, the Supreme Court said on Thursday. A five-judge Constitution bench headed by Justice KM Joseph wondered was the government not closing the doors on meritorious younger candidates by appointing retired bureaucrats.

“There is a law. We expect you that you would act in such a way that you would comply with the statutory requirements. Why is that you will have a pool of retired bureaucrats, why not others? Why only four names, why not have a larger pool of candidates? “Are you not shutting out the meritorious younger candidates? You seems to be hell bent that no chief election commissioner or for that matter EC gets a complete six years tenure and it is against the statute,” Justice Joseph said.

Know all about the new Election Commissioner Arun Goel and the controversy around his appointment

Judge: Why were the names sent to prime minister and not the council of ministers

Under the Election Commission (Conditions of Service of Election Commissioners and Transaction of Business) Act, 1991 an EC can have a tenure of six years or up to the age of 65, whichever is earlier.

Justice Joseph said the point is that from the pool of a large number of officers the government has selected only those people who are never going to complete the six-year tenure.

“Why were the names sent to prime minister and not the council of ministers?” Justice Joseph asked.

Attorney General R Venkataramani responded, “Batch is one criteria, date of birth is other, seniority from the batch is other. Similarly, there are several other aspects which are being considered. Several discussions are done. Everything is not in black and white. There are several ways of appointment. Some files go to the Appointments Committee of Cabinet (ACC) through cabinet secretariat and some go directly to the prime minister”.

The bench, also comprising Justices Ajay Rastogi, Aniruddha Bose, Hrishikesh Roy and C T Ravikumar, clarified there should not be any misunderstanding that the court is against the government and it is only debating and discussing the issue.

The AG replied, “Yes, My Lord. It is a debate and I am bound to answer the court’s questions. If we start doubting every appointment, look at the implications for institution’s reputation”.

Justice Joseph said, “So, ultimately your point is that only those people need to be appointed who are on the verge of retirement, so that they don’t get a full six year period. Is that the law? You are violating the law and we are saying that clearly”.

Not questioning or scrutinising the names but the process

The bench said it is not questioning or scrutinising the names but the process, and from the database the government has given, it appears there are several other officers who are younger.

Venkataramani said the existing system has been working for quite a long time and this is the convention which is being followed.

“We cannot conclude that there is quid pro quo because something has happened in a certain way,” he said.

Justice Roy said the court is struggling to find the reasons and logic as how these four names were selected by the law minister.

“You may be right in saying age category. We are testing the process. Now if age category is important, then there are 40 more names. How 36 names were left (out)?” Justice Roy said, adding the court wants to lighten the mood by saying the Attorney General’s note forgot to mention that Goel is gold medalist in mathematics and that election is all about numbers.

Venkataramani said he had left the point as he did not want to step into the shoes of decision makers.

Advocate Prashant Bhushan, appearing for petitioner Anoop Baranwal said, as a matter of fact, there are 160 officers from the same batch and many are younger than those who were considered. Had they been considered, they would have got a longer tenure as EC, he said.

Advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan, appearing for advocate Ashwini Upadhyay, said it was good that Goel’s file was called for by the court as they came to know that the law minister also played in a role in the appointment of the EC.

“The Election Commission has now become a promotional cadre for bureaucrats. There is seniority basis through which they are appointed as per the convention but law is something different. Parliament, to ensure security of tenure, said the EC should have a six-year tenure but here a person is put for six months,” he said.

On Wednesday, Goel’s appointment as an EC came under scrutiny by the top court which sought from the Centre the original records pertaining to his appointment for perusal, saying it wanted to know whether there was any “hanky panky”.

On November 19, Goel, a Punjab cadre IAS officer, was appointed as election commissioner.

Goel would be in line to be the next CEC after incumbent Rajiv Kumar demits office in February 2025. His total tenure in the Election Commission would be of over five years.

SC questions ‘lightning fast’ appointment process of EC Arun Goel, AG for Centre asks court to ‘hold its mouth’

(To receive our E-paper on whatsapp daily, please click here. To receive it on Telegram, please click here. We permit sharing of the paper’s PDF on WhatsApp and other social media platforms.)

Hungary expects EU to approve its recovery plan next month: minister

Is David Miliband about to make a Commons comeback? Ex-Cabinet minister refuses to rule out standing for Labour at 2024 election (and surprise surprise, he wants to 'align' with the EU)

Hanako Greensmith Admits She Sometimes Forgets A Step Of Administering An IV On Chicago Fire

Uomini e Donne, Davide Donadei ritorno di fiamma con l'ex? "Ci siamo parlati e..."

Aussie banned from TikTok after being relentlessly mocked for asking if it's okay to be 'straight, white and jacked' in a rant about 'feminist men'

Technology no longer agnostic, has strong political connotation: External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar

Nissan'dan yeni bir model daha, ancak bu sefer bir minibüs!

Affordable fashion finds: Amazon shoppers love these £20 fur-lined boots that are £135 cheaper than UGG's trending Classic Mini Boots

Iranian female supporters claim they are 'being spied on by government officials' at the Qatar World Cup after staging controversial stadium protests in support of Mahsa Amini

Irán confirma más de 300 muertos desde el inicio de las protestas por el fallecimiento de Mahsa Amini

Sněhule nejen na hory: V kombinaci s minisukní je můžete obléknout i na párty

Primary school teachers in Sarawak have no problem teaching Science, Math in English, says local minister

El MINI Cooper S representa las características típicas del MINI como ningún otro

Tish Cyrus dating Dominic Purcell

Former Russian finance minister Kudrin announces departure from Audit Chamber

Ciclismo, rivoluzione in vista per la Vuelta femminile

NEWS RELATED

Innenminister setzen Abschiebungen in den Iran vorerst aus

Westliche Nationen appellieren im UN-Menschenrechtsrat an die iranische Regierung , das brutale Vorgehen gegen die Protestbewegung zu beenden. Aber kann das wirklich etwas gegen das Mullah-Regime bewirken? Der Politologe Fathollah-Nejad sieht Spielraum vor allem bei Sanktionen. Quelle: WELT | Marcus Tychsen Die Innenminister der Länder wollen vor dem Hintergrund ...

View more: Innenminister setzen Abschiebungen in den Iran vorerst aus

Wiceministerska para "na dorobku". Prześwietlili ich majątek

Piotr Patkowski i Olga Semeniuk-Patkowska na ślubie W weekend wiceminister rozwoju Olga Semeniuk wzięła ślub z wiceministrem finansów Piotrem Patkowskim. Jeden z tabloidów zbadał, jak prezentuje się majątek młodej rządowej pary. 34-letnia Semeniuk i 31-letni Patkowski wzięli ślub w sobotę 26 listopada w kościele na warszawskiej Woli. Na ceremonii byli obecni znani ...

View more: Wiceministerska para "na dorobku". Prześwietlili ich majątek

Presidente Petro tras aprobarse en primer debate la creación del Ministerio de la Igualdad: “La dignidad debe ser un derecho, no un privilegio”

Esa cartera será liderada por la vicepresidenta Francia Márquez. El presidente de la República Gustavo Petro no ocultó su alegría por el avance que se registró este lunes, en las comisiones primeras conjuntas del Senado y la Cámara con la aprobación del proyecto de ley que crea el Ministerio de ...

View more: Presidente Petro tras aprobarse en primer debate la creación del Ministerio de la Igualdad: “La dignidad debe ser un derecho, no un privilegio”

Ministro de Agricultura sin filtro: “Que los camioneros descolgados se descuelguen de la imbecilidad”

Publimetro Chile Esta mañana el ministro de Agricultura, Esteban Valenzuela, criticó el paro de camioneros que inició hace una semana la Confederación Fuerza del Norte. Según informó Radio Bíobío, en conversación con los medios, Valenzuela apuntó contra la actitud de los descolgados y los invitó a “descolgarse de la imbecilidad”. ...

View more: Ministro de Agricultura sin filtro: “Que los camioneros descolgados se descuelguen de la imbecilidad”

Energy Minister Bill Johnston plays down fears over gas leak at Santos-operated Varanus Island hub

Output at the Varanus Island gas terminal has taken a hit following a leak.  () Energy Minister Bill Johnston says a gas leak at a pipeline off the coast of Western Australia’s Pilbara region, which has forced  Santos to cut output at its Varanus Island gas hub, will not impact ...

View more: Energy Minister Bill Johnston plays down fears over gas leak at Santos-operated Varanus Island hub

UNITA diz que nova divisão político-administrativa não deve condicionar autarquias

MPLA diz não ter medo de autárquicas e UNITA pede respeito de opiniões diferentes Luanda, 28 nov 2022 (Lusa) – O líder do grupo parlamentar da UNITA, maior partido da oposição angolana, disse hoje que o ‘timing’ para discussão de uma proposta de lei sobre a nova divisão político-administrativa ...

View more: UNITA diz que nova divisão político-administrativa não deve condicionar autarquias

Iran confirms more than 300 dead since start of protests over Mahsa Amini’s death

File – Photograph of Mahsa Amini, killed in Iran after being arrested for improperly wearing the veil, during a protest in Germany. – Christoph Reichwein/dpa Iran’s Revolutionary Guard has confirmed that more than 300 people have died since protests began in September over the death of Mahsa Amini, a ...

View more: Iran confirms more than 300 dead since start of protests over Mahsa Amini’s death

Der ehemalige Staatsanwalt Martínez prangert ein angebliches Komplott des kolumbianischen Außenministers gegen ihn an

Néstor Humberto Martínez. – EL TIEMPO / ZUMA PRESS / CONTACTOPHOTO Der ehemalige kolumbianische Generalstaatsanwalt Néstor Humberto Martínez hat sich bei den US-Behörden beschwert, er sei Opfer eines Komplotts, in das der ehemalige Präsident Juan Manuel Santos verwickelt sei und das von Außenminister Álvaro Leyva in Zusammenarbeit mit Journalisten ...

View more: Der ehemalige Staatsanwalt Martínez prangert ein angebliches Komplott des kolumbianischen Außenministers gegen ihn an

Kaczorowska nie mogła tego dłużej tolerować i pocisnęła ostro po feminizmie. Wywoła kolejną aferę?

Bitcoin’s Mining Difficulty Expected to Drop Significantly, Retarget Could Be 2022’s Largest Reduction

Labor finalises censure motion against Scott Morrison over secret ministries saga

Merugi Rp 3 Juta Gegara Main Judi Slot Online, Seorang Pria Nekat Bobol ATM dan Minimarket

Iraq Prime Minister to discuss shelling of Kurdish groups during Iran visit

Μαρέβα Μητσοτάκη | Η minimal chic εμφάνισή της στη συνάντηση με τον βασιλιά Κάρολο στο κάστρο του W

Top Gun filminin yıldızı ünlü oyuncu hayatını kaybetti

Nye budsjettmøter på Statsministerens kontor

Thai economy may miss forecast next year as global growth slows -Finance Minister

Wypadek na polu w gminie Radziejów. 58-latek przygnieciony upadającym pniem [zdjęcia]

Hydrogen-powered buses get Vehicle Type Approval from federal govt after trial run, says Sarawak transport minister

Conservatives are 'fearmongering' over assault-style gun ban: public safety minister

OTHER NEWS

Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network