The smartwatch landscape is largely divided into three camps: Apple Watch, the ever-evolving lineup of Google Wear OS smartwatches, and … everything else. Now, it’s probably unfair to group all the other wearables into an “everything else” bucket because, to behonest, many of the smartwatches and fitness bands in this miscellaneous category are actually great.

Contents

  • Which smartwatches have Alexa
  • Alexa for every day
  • Alexa with every device
  • The bottom line

No, what I’m talking about when I say “everything else” is that these watches employ a custom-built operating system — separate from Apple’s Watch OS and Google’s Wear OS. While there are a lot of ramifications to a smartwatch with a custom OS (most of which are out of the scope of this article), one of the big choices you’re making by going with a non-Apple, non-Google smartwatch is which smart assistant you willn use.

While the ease with which you can have Siri navigate your Apple Watch is unsurprising, and the somewhat lackluster performance of Google Assistant on a Wear OS device makes that category of watches unfortunate, there is a whole landscape of watches that have turned to Amazon’s Alexa voice assistant. And this is pretty unique, because Alexa has a specific place in the voice assistant world — mostly as it relates to DIY use cases and cross-device compatibility.

But what’s it actually like choosing a smartwatch exclusively for the Alexa functionality? Well, I got my hands on a few different classes of watches, including a Fitbit Versa 2 and Xiaomi’s new flagship S1 smartwatch (currently only officially available in some markets), and spent the better part of a week asking Alexa to control my life. Here’s how it went down.

Talk to the wrist: Alexa is the best smartwatch assistant

Courtesy of Xiaomi

Which smartwatches have Alexa

The first key consideration for this story was to determine which brands of smartwatch actually rely on Alexa. First, there’s Fitbit’s range of trackers and watches. I generally really like what Fitbit does with a custom OS, especially when it comes to battery life, but I’ve honestly never spent much time calling for Alexa to start a workout or read me my calendar. But Fitbit had to include Alexa to maintain the competitive edge of having voice-activated commands — though that may change now that Google owns Fitbit.

Then there are the “third party” watches — the most famous maker of which is likely Amazfit. These value-forward watches and bands aim to give you wrist notifications, basic workout functionality, and about 70% of a smartwatch experience at a bargain price. This is likely the sweet spot for Alexa use.

The final category is the “higher-end” custom OS watches. For this story, I’m giving the Xiaomi S1 watch a spin for its custom OS, but you can find a few options in the higher-priced watch space that use a custom OS — most notably the Samsung Galaxy Watch line (before the fourth installment switched to Wear OS, that is).

Talk to the wrist: Alexa is the best smartwatch assistant

Xiaomi S1 Watch

Alexa for every day

Before I get into my actual experience using Alexa in my everyday life, it’s important to underscore what “built-in” Alexa functionality actually means. While an Alexa-specific device like an Amazon Echo or Fire TV is ready to go out of the box, a “built-in” device is a third-party piece of tech that is designed to work hand in hand with Alexa after some setup — typically via an Alexa app on your phone. Devices like the FitBit Versa 2 and the Xiaomi S1 require you to update firmware, connect the device to an Alexa app on your phone, and be in a territory where this functionality is supported. So once it’s set up, you’ll have hands-free access, but it does take some doing to get it going.

In practice, Alexa felt like an interesting voice assistant to have at your beck and call, most likely due to the fact that I’m used to Alexa living more in my smart home than in my pocket. My typical voice assistant on the go is Siri, and even then I only really use it on my Apple Watch to start a workout quickly or clumsily respond to a text when I can’t fish my phone out of my pocket. Alexa, with her intricate, DIY-friendly patchwork of skills means that there’s a bit more with which to experiment when I’m walking around.

First, I found that Alexa actually worked a little better than Siri when asking her to search the internet for me. Siri will often send back the wrong info or tell me to head over to my phone more often. Alexa on the other hand seemed to be more comfortable taking a stab at answering my question, at least in most cases. Similarly, because the Alexa app has other app functionality built-in more readily, it was more seamless to trigger scheduling in my Google ecosystem (like meetings and to-do lists). Of course, Siri can tackle this with Apple’s ecosystem, but not very seamlessly with third-party options. This is all anecdotal, and your mileage may vary, but in general, I think Amazon has built a bolder voice assistant in large part because it doesn’t play it safe quite as much — especially when you factor in Alexa’s tens of thousands of skills, which still outflank what the Google Assistant brings to the table.

Talk to the wrist: Alexa is the best smartwatch assistant

Xiaomi S1 Watch

Alexa with every device

Perhaps the most important consideration when determining the Alexa difference is just how many third-party devices Amazon has chosen to interface with. Because both Google and Apple tend to keep a tight grasp on their ecosystems, when you ask for functionality, they’ll tend to default to first-party devices. Amazon on the other hand has painstakingly taken steps to build a massive rolodex of speakers and smart home devices. While the numbers fluctuate quite a bit, Amazon usually has a few-thousand device edge with its compatibility list. Google Assistant and Apple remain woefully behind in this regard.

To be fair, my smart home is a little bit of a mixed bag. My thermostat is a Google Nest Learning Thermostat, while my TV streaming device of choice is an Apple TV. But much of the rest of my smart home system is powered by the budget-friendly company Wyze. Between smart locks, Wi-Fi cameras, a monitored security system, and even a robotic vacuum, the Wyze app is a frequent smart home control interface for me. And while Google integration is purportedly supported, the best functionality I’ve found is with Alexa. Therefore, getting Alexa on my wrist to unlock a door or turn off a camera was handy. And this should likely hold true on a variety of other devices, including the obvious Amazon-friendly ring devices and the popular Ecobee smart thermostat line.

And this is where I really think the Alexa-on-your-wrist thing shines. Apple’s HomeKit functionality is really not there yet and requires a ton of fiddling with to get off the ground, and Google’s approach works best with first-party devices. Amazon is the ecosystem without an ecosystem, so you’ll have better luck on a wider variety of third-party devices.

Talk to the wrist: Alexa is the best smartwatch assistant

Xiaomi S1 Watch

The bottom line

As unsatisfying as it may seem, the answer to the “is Alexa the best wrist-worn voice assistant” question is really dependent on your priorities. For me, I think I’ll still take Siri as my favorite, strictly because so much of my mobile lifestyle is Apple-based. But if I preferred Android phones and a PC laptop, I might change my tune to Alexa.

For the Google Assistant versus Alexa battle, Google may have the first-party battle won, but for compatibility on a ton of devices, Alexa is a really clever little helper. If you’re in the market for a smartwatch and voice activation is a feature you’re after, I’d recommend taking a look at your list of “must-have” device integrations. If it’s anything beyond the main Google Nest/Google Home infrastructure, Alexa might just unlock a better, more futuristic life.

NEWS RELATED

Qualcomm Unveils Wireless AR Smart Viewer

Qualcomm wants to bring a wireless Smart Viewer for an augmented reality experience. The reference design of this wearable gadget has been reported previously when the company hinted that it would be commercialized as smart headsets. With that being said, the chipmaker will soon release a pair of high-end smart ...

View more: Qualcomm Unveils Wireless AR Smart Viewer

Garmin Vivosmart 5 v Fitbit Charge 5: Fitness tracker face-off

Do you Garmin or Fitbit fitness tracker? Here's our take

View more: Garmin Vivosmart 5 v Fitbit Charge 5: Fitness tracker face-off

Echelon Smart Rower review: high-quality foldable rowing machine with virtual workouts

© Provided by Fit&Well Echelon Smart Rower rowing machine Our Echelon Smart Rower review will take you through everything you need to know about this premium home rowing machine. We put the rower to the test and found it was an effective way to train, especially when coupled with ...

View more: Echelon Smart Rower review: high-quality foldable rowing machine with virtual workouts

Qualcomm unveils Snapdragon 7 Gen 1 processor for gaming smartphones

Alongside the Snapdragon 8+ Gen 1, Qualcomm also unveiled the Snapdragon 7 Gen 1 processor that’s targeted toward gaming smartphones. Qualcomm claims its new chipset “delivers epic mobile gaming with high-speed connectivity, plus heart-pumping audio and visuals.” The Snapdragon 7 Gen 1 (SM7450-AB) is the successor to the popular ...

View more: Qualcomm unveils Snapdragon 7 Gen 1 processor for gaming smartphones

Can your smart home save you money on homeowners insurance?

Smart home devices provide more than just convenient assistance — they also help us complete tasks more efficiently and protect our homes. And now, they may actually be able to save you money on your homeowner’s insurance. Contents Which smart home products can save you money? How much can you ...

View more: Can your smart home save you money on homeowners insurance?

Today’s deals: $4 smart plugs, $150 AirPods 3, AirTags, NutriBullet, LG OLED TVs, more

© Provided by BGR BGR Deals of the Day Friday We have just over one week to go until Memorial Day 2022 arrives. That means there are so many impressive daily deals out there right now. Today’s Top Deals First and foremost, you can get super-popular Esicoo smart plugs ...

View more: Today’s deals: $4 smart plugs, $150 AirPods 3, AirTags, NutriBullet, LG OLED TVs, more

Garmin Smartwatches are 23 percent off right now

Amazon has discounted Garmin smartwatches just in time to get your summer fitness routine on. These deals will be in place until Sunday and you can check them out below: Garmin Forerunner 945 for $639.99 (save $190) Garmin Forerunner 55 for $219 (save $40) Garmin Forerunner 245 for $329 ...

View more: Garmin Smartwatches are 23 percent off right now

Top 5 best-selling smartphones in the world in the first quarter of 2022

iPhone 13 is the best-selling smartphone in the world in the first quarter of this year. This statement was made by IDC analysts based on the analysis of the mobile device market. At the same time, they did not name the total number of iPhone 13 sold and its market ...

View more: Top 5 best-selling smartphones in the world in the first quarter of 2022

Apple's iPhone 14 Lineup Might Arrive this September Along With Three New Smartwatches

FBI and UK Warn of Hacking Risks of Modern Smart Farm Machinery

Promotional images of the Honor 70 and 70 Pro smartphones

Marcus Smart returns to help the Boston Celtics beat the Miami Heat in Game 2

Qualcomm’s new AR Smart Viewer is sleek and wireless

Apple dominates U.S. smartphone market with 51% Q1 share thanks to iPhone 13

Despite challenges, Samsung increases smartphone market share in North America

Here is why Xiaomi smartphones are getting more expensive

Apple extends the gap with Samsung in North American smartphone market in Q1 2022

Oppo, Vivo, and Xiaomi to cut smartphone orders by 20%

iPhone 13 series enslave the entire North American smartphone market

Encalife Atmosphere Smart Galaxy Star Projector review

OTHER NEWS