U.S. Criticizes China's Zero Covid Strategy, Says Beijing Needs to Boost Vaccination Among Elderly

Tyrone Siu | Reuters

  • Top U.S. health officials said China’s zero Covid strategy is not an effective way to control the virus, and Beijing should focus on vaccinating the elderly.
  • The White House, in a statement, said the Chinese people have the right to protest peacefully.
  • Rare protests broke out against Covid lockdowns in Beijing, Shanghai, Urumqi and other cities over the weekend.

The White House on Monday criticized Beijing’s zero Covid strategy as ineffective and said the Chinese people have a right to peacefully protest.

“We’ve long said everyone has the right to peacefully protest, here in the United States and around the world. This includes in the PRC,” a spokesperson for President Joe Biden’s National Security Council said in a statement.

Rare protests broke out against Covid lockdowns in Beijing, Shanghai, Urumqi and other cities over the weekend. Nearly three years after the virus first emerged in Wuhan, China is still imposing strict social controls to quash Covid outbreaks, while countries such as the U.S. have largely returned to normal life.

“We’ve said that zero COVID is not a policy we pursuing here in the United States,” the NSC spokesperson said. “And as we’ve said, we think it’s going to be very difficult for the People’s Republic of China to be able to contain this virus through their zero COVID strategy.”

The U.S. Covid response is focused on increasing vaccination rates and making testing and treatment more accessible, the spokesperson said.

China’s stringent Covid controls have kept deaths very low compared to the U.S., but the measures have also deeply disrupted economic and social life. In China, more than 30,000 people have died from Covid since the pandemic began, according to the World Health Organization. In the U.S., more than 1 million people have died.

Dr. Anthony Fauci, the top infectious disease expert in the U.S., said China’s approach to Covid “doesn’t make public health sense.” Vaccination rates among the elderly, one of the groups most vulnerable to Covid, are low in China compared to other countries. The vaccination campaign in China focused on people in critical positions first, those ages 18 to 59 next, and only then people ages 60 and over.

“If you look at the prevalence of vaccinations among the elderly, that it was almost counterproductive, the people you really needed to protect were not getting protected,” Fauci told NBC’s Meet the Press on Sunday.  A temporary lockdown might make sense if the goal was to buy time to boost vaccination rates but China doesn’t seem to be doing that, he said.

“It seems that in China, it was just a very, very strict extraordinary lockdown where you lock people in the house but without any seemingly endgame to it,” Fauci said.

As of August, about 86% of people ages 60 and older in China were fully vaccinated and 68% had received a booster, according to a September report from China’s Center for Disease Control and Prevention. By comparison, 92% of older Americans were fully vaccinated and 70% had received a booster during that same period.

Fauci said China’s domestically developed vaccines are also not very effective.

The authors of China CDC report said older people are more skeptical of the vaccine. The clinical trials didn’t enroll enough older people and as a consequence there wasn’t sufficient data on the vaccine’s safety and efficacy for this age group when the immunization campaign started, they wrote.

Dr. Ashish Jha, head of the White House Covid task force, said China should focus on making sure the elderly get vaccinated.

“That I think is the path out of this virus. Lockdowns and zero COVID is going to be very difficult to sustain,” Jha told ABC’s “This Week” on Sunday.

Read CNBC’s latest global health coverage:

    Beijing beatdown begins: Chinese cops use violence and intimidation to curb anti-Covid lockdown protests after crowds chanted for the end of Communist leader Xi's rule

    (Multimedia) Beijing pide a servicios de mensajería contratar más personal en medio de control de COVID-19

    Jimmy Lai’s national security trial: Hong Kong justice department to seek case adjournment on Tuesday amid wait for Beijing’s interpretation of law

    Xi Jinping's censors are overwhelmed as they try and fail to scrub Chinese rebels' blank sheets of paper from the Internet as anti-lockdown protests rumble across Beijing, Shanghai and Hong Kong

    MARK ALMOND: Why Beijing's autocratic leader could yet become a sacrificial lamb

    Chinese protests aren’t about COVID — they’re about a dictatorship

    'Covid is Beijing's fault but they can't admit it and won't': Chinese Communist Party 'is scared of the people' and Xi 'faces the greatest threat to his rule' as lockdown protests explode

    Hong Kong tycoon Jimmy Lai’s trial could be deferred by month or more while Beijing interprets national security law, analysts say

    Beijing residents push back against Covid-19 lockdown

    Tesla sets up autos chip JV in China, in line with localisation strategy and as Beijing promotes domestic industry development

    SEX BOTS are used to curb Chinese Covid protests: Porn accounts flood Twitter with racy escort ads and erotic videos 'in Beijing plot to drown out reports on riots'

    Beijing Laporkan Lebih dari 2.000 Kasus Covid-19 Baru di Tengah Protes

    (Multimedia) Ola de frío azotará Beijing

    Beijing regulators outline hydrogen car blueprint to boost industry

    UK warns China after BBC journalist ‘beaten’ by police during protests

    Beijing, Kovid-19 kontrolü için barikat kurulmasını yasakladı

    NEWS RELATED

    Travellers from China to require negative Covid-19 test to enter UK

    (Peter Powell/PA) (PA Wire) The UK is set to follow other countries by requiring travellers from China to be tested for Covid-19. The PA news agency understands the UK Government is expected to announce a requirement for a negative pre-departure test, amid concerns about surging case numbers in the ...

    View more: Travellers from China to require negative Covid-19 test to enter UK

    Renesas resumes Beijing chip plant production on Dec. 20

    Japan-based Renesas Electronics has resumed production at its chip plant in Beijing after a suspension caused by the rising COVID cases. However, whether or not the semiconductor manufacturer has restarted full production at the site remains to be discovered. According to Reuters and Nikkei, the Beijing plant had been ...

    View more: Renesas resumes Beijing chip plant production on Dec. 20

    Growing COVID cases forces Renesas to suspend Beijing plant

    Japan-based Renesas Electronics has halted production at its chip plant in Beijing due to the growing COVID case number at the site. According to media reports, the company has suspended production since the evening of December 16. Nikkei and Yomiuri reported that the increasing COVID cases at Renesas’ Beijing ...

    View more: Growing COVID cases forces Renesas to suspend Beijing plant

    Paypal as Big Brother, not out of woods on inflation and other commentary

    Federal Reserve Board Chairman Jerome Powell announced that interest rates will rise by 0.5% to 4.5 this month. Getty Images Tech desk: Paypal as Big Brother “Fifty-eight percent of Americans use PayPal, and in 2021, there were 19.3 billion PayPal transactions,” notes Rupa Subramanya at The Free Press. But ...

    View more: Paypal as Big Brother, not out of woods on inflation and other commentary

    China pulls out six diplomats wanted for questioning over Manchester assault

    James Cleverly (Victoria Jones/PA) (PA Wire) China is pulling out six officials wanted for police questioning over the assault of a protester outside the nation’s consulate in Manchester, the Foreign Secretary has been told. James Cleverly said he is “disappointed” the individuals including consul general Zheng Xiyuan will not ...

    View more: China pulls out six diplomats wanted for questioning over Manchester assault

    Mercedes has decided on drive production system

    On the way to a purely electric vehicle range by the end of the decade, Mercedes-Benz has now made important decisions for drive production. This means that it has been decided in which plants the drive units and battery systems will be assembled. After Mercedes had determined the production ...

    View more: Mercedes has decided on drive production system

    Security minister raises concerns over TikTok as news source

    Tom Tugendhat (James Manning/PA) (PA Wire) The security minister has raised concerns about a growing number of young people reading the news on social media sites such as the Chinese-owned TikTok. Tom Tugendhat warned on Tuesday that “challenges” could be created if Beijing declares the platform’s algorithms a national ...

    View more: Security minister raises concerns over TikTok as news source

    China’s COVID surge causes chaos at hospitals as country eases restrictions

    People enter a railway station, after the government eased curbs on COVID, in Wuhan, China, Sunday. REUTERS China’s surge in COVID-19 cases after the government’s abrupt rollback of its heavy-handed restrictions had led to chaos at ill-prepared and understaffed hospitals, as long lines of fearful residents inundate its clinics. ...

    View more: China’s COVID surge causes chaos at hospitals as country eases restrictions

    Blind Chinese dissident Chen Guangcheng says Biden must help protesters

    Renault & Dongfeng launch luxury EV brand in China

    Channel 4 boss: Jordan Gray’s sketch was ‘beautiful moment of trans expression’

    No 10 condemns ‘shocking and unacceptable’ arrest of journalist in China

    MPs to visit Taiwan amid heightened tensions

    Rishi Sunak warns against ‘cold war’ with China despite growing ‘authoritarianism’

    UK's Rishi Sunak says 'golden era' with China over

    Beijing protesters spooked by phone calls from police

    China police out in force in Beijing and Shanghai as Covid protests quieten

    Video: Beijing beatdown begins: Chinese cops use violence and intimidation to curb anti-Covid lockdown protests after crowds chanted for the end of Communist leader Xi's rule

    Protes Ketatnya Kebijakan Zero Covid, Warga Beijing: Saya Ingin Menonton Film!

    Iain Duncan Smith accuses Rishi Sunak of 'appeasing' China despite PM toughening his language in a key speech declaring the 'golden era' of ties to Beijing as 'over'

    OTHER NEWS