What if the dinosaurs hadn't gone extinct? Why our world might look very different
Giant dinosaurs and mammals through time. Credit: Nick Longrich

Sixty-six million years ago, an asteroid hit the Earth with the force of 10 billion atomic bombs and changed the course of evolution. The skies darkened and plants stopped photosynthesising. The plants died, then the animals that fed on them. The food chain collapsed. Over 90% of all species vanished. When the dust settled, all dinosaurs except a handful of birds had gone extinct.

But this catastrophic event made human evolution possible. The surviving mammals flourished, including little proto-primates that would evolve into us.

Imagine the asteroid had missed, and dinosaurs survived. Picture highly evolved raptors planting their flag on the moon. Dinosaur scientists, discovering relativity, or discussing a hypothetical world in which, incredibly, mammals took over the Earth.

This might sound like bad science fiction, but it gets at some deep, philosophical questions about evolution. Is humanity just here by chance, or is the evolution of intelligent tool-users inevitable?

Brains, tools, language and big social groups make us the planet’s dominant species. There are 8 billion Homo sapiens on seven continents. By weight, there are more humans than all wild animals.

We’ve modified half of Earth’s land to feed ourselves. You could argue creatures like humans were bound to evolve.

In the 1980s, paleontologist Dale Russell proposed a thought experiment in which a carnivorous dinosaur evolved into an intelligent tool user. This “dinosauroid” was big-brained with opposable thumbs and walked upright.

It’s not impossible but it’s unlikely. The biology of an animal constrains the direction of its evolution. Your starting point limits your endpoints.

If you drop out of college, you probably won’t be a brain surgeon, lawyer or Nasa rocket scientist. But you might be an artist, actor or entrepreneur. The paths we take in life open some doors and close others. That’s also true in evolution.

What if the dinosaurs hadn't gone extinct? Why our world might look very different
Brain size versus body mass for dinosaurs, mammals, and birds. Credit: Nick Longrich

Consider the size of dinosaurs. Beginning in the Jurassic, sauropod dinosaurs, Brontosaurus and kin evolved into 30-50 ton giants up to 30 meters long—ten times the weight of an elephant and as long as a blue whale. This happened in multiple groups, including Diplodocidae, Brachiosauridae, Turiasauridae, Mamenchisauridae and Titanosauria.

This happened on different continents, at different times and in different climates, from deserts to rainforests. But other dinosaurs living in these environments didn’t become supergiants.

The common thread linking these animals was that they were sauropods. Something about sauropod anatomy—lungs, hollow bones with a high strength-to-weight ratio, metabolism or all these things—unlocked their evolutionary potential. It let them grow big in a way that no land animals had ever before, or have since.

Likewise, the carnivorous dinosaurs repeatedly evolved huge, ten-meter, multi-ton predators. Over 100 million years, megalosaurids, allosaurids, carcharodontosaurids, neovenatorids and finally tyrannosaurs evolved giant apex predators.

Dinosaurs did big bodies well. Big brains not so much. Dinosaurs did show a weak trend towards increased brain size over time. Jurassic dinosaurs like Allosaurus, Stegosaurus and Brachiosaurus had small brains.

By the late Cretaceous, 80 million years later, tyrannosaurs and duckbills had evolved larger brains. But despite its size, the T. rex brain still weighed just 400 grams. A Velociraptor brain weighed 15 grams. The average human brain weighs 1.3 kilograms.

Dinosaurs did enter new niches over time. Small herbivores became more common and birds diversified. Long-legged forms evolved later on, suggesting an arms race between fleet-footed predators and their prey.

Dinosaurs seem to have had increasingly complex social lives. They started living in herds and evolved elaborate horns for fighting and display. Yet dinosaurs mostly seem to repeat themselves, evolving giant herbivores and carnivores with small brains.

There’s little about 100 million years of dinosaur history to hint they’d have done anything radically different if the asteroid hadn’t intervened. We’d likely still have those supergiant, long-necked herbivores and huge tyrannosaur-like predators.

What if the dinosaurs hadn't gone extinct? Why our world might look very different
Lion Tamarin, a South American monkey. Credit: Wikipedia

They may have evolved slightly bigger brains, but there’s little evidence they’d have evolved into geniuses. Neither is it likely that mammals would have displaced them. Dinosaurs monopolized their environments to very end, when the asteroid hit.

Mammals, meanwhile, had different constraints. They never evolved supergiant herbivores and carnivores. But they repeatedly evolved big brains. Massive brains (as large or larger than ours) evolved in orcas, sperm whales, baleen whales, elephants, leopard seals and apes.

Today, a few dinosaur descendants—birds like crows and parrots—have complex brains. They can use tools, talk and count. But it’s mammals like apes, elephants and dolphins that evolved the biggest brains and most complex behaviors.

So did eliminating the dinosaurs guarantee mammals would evolve intelligence?

Well, maybe not.

Starting points may limit endpoints, but they don’t guarantee them either. Steve Jobs, Bill Gates and Mark Zuckerberg all dropped out of college. But if dropping out automatically made you a multibillionaire, every college dropout would be rich. Even starting in the right place, you need opportunities and luck.

The evolutionary history of primates suggests our evolution was anything but inevitable. In Africa, primates did evolve into big-brained apes and, over 7 million years, produced modern humans. But elsewhere primate evolution took very different paths.

When monkeys reached South America 35 million years ago they just evolved into more monkey species. And primates reached North America at least three separate times, 55 million years ago, 50 million years ago, and 20 million years ago. Yet they didn’t evolve into a species who make nuclear weapons and smartphones. Instead, for reasons we don’t understand, they went extinct.

In Africa, and Africa alone, primate evolution took a unique direction. Something about Africa’s fauna, flora or geography drove the evolution of apes: terrestrial, big-bodied, big-brained, tool-using primates. Even with the dinosaurs gone, our evolution needed the right combination of opportunity and luck.

Provided by The Conversation

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Citation: What if the dinosaurs hadn’t gone extinct? Why our world might look very different (2022, November 26) retrieved 26 November 2022 from https://phys.org/news/2022-11-dinosaurs-hadnt-extinct-world.html This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

NEWS RELATED

TikTok’s chief executive to testify before Congress in March

The chief executive of TikTok, Chew Shou Zi, has agreed to testify to Congress in March on the video app’s relationship with the Chinese Communist Party, it was announced Monday. Representative Cathy McMorris Rodgers, Republican of Washington, who chairs the House Energy and Commerce Committee said that Chew would ...

View more: TikTok’s chief executive to testify before Congress in March

Honda retains lead in motorcycle market

Thai Honda Co, a manufacturer and distributor of Honda motorcycles, has maintained its top rank in Thailand's motorcycle market for the 34th consecutive year, with sales standing at 1.38 million units in 2022. Honda motorcycles were ranked number one in all segments, covering the family, automatic (AT) and sports ...

View more: Honda retains lead in motorcycle market

Head of Australian Antarctic Division to step down

The head of the Australian Antarctic Division has announced his resignation ahead of the finalisation of a review into workplace culture. Kim Ellis, who took up the role in 2019, has announced his retirement, the division said on Tuesday. It is reported Mr Ellis will step down in coming ...

View more: Head of Australian Antarctic Division to step down

STYLE Edit: Meet Lilou Wadoux, Ferrari’s first female Competizioni GT driver with Richard Mille Racing Team, who will ride the Ferrari 488 GTE with the AF Corse team in March

Richard Mille Racing Team protégé Lilou Wadoux is set to become the first female Ferrari Competizioni GT driver at Le Mans. The 21-year-old French woman from Amiens will join the starting grid at the wheel of the Ferrari 488 GTE with the AF Corse team, hoping to make a ...

View more: STYLE Edit: Meet Lilou Wadoux, Ferrari’s first female Competizioni GT driver with Richard Mille Racing Team, who will ride the Ferrari 488 GTE with the AF Corse team in March

ChatGPT-connected companies like BuzzFeed see stock volume surges in enthusiasm over OpenAI

Companies tied to artificial intelligence services recorded some of their highest trading volumes on record this month, amid a frenzy of interest in the ChatGPT tool, which generates conversation-style interactions. BuzzFeed Inc, C3.ai Inc, SoundHound AI Inc, and BigBear.ai Holdings Inc are among the stocks that have all seen ...

View more: ChatGPT-connected companies like BuzzFeed see stock volume surges in enthusiasm over OpenAI

Can you teach a computer common sense?

Dr. Yejin Choi University of Washington Professor and MacArthur Fellow, works to improve AI’s understanding of common sense. John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation hide caption toggle caption John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation The first time Short Wave co-host Emily Kwong ever “spoke” to a computer ...

View more: Can you teach a computer common sense?

New cancer treatment found ‘promising’ for terminally ill dogs

A new therapy to treat late-stage cancer in dogs can not only extend the lives of canines but also preserve “good quality of life”, according to a new study that may also lead to improved treatments for some cancers that affect humans. The research, published recently in the journal ...

View more: New cancer treatment found ‘promising’ for terminally ill dogs

Cryptocurrency entrepreneur and Huobi adviser Justin Sun plans move to Hong Kong while talking up China market

Chinese cryptocurrency personality Justin Sun said he is planning to move to Hong Kong, where the government recently announced new policies to attract virtual asset businesses, and talked up the potential of China’s crypto industry, while the global industry remains in a slump after the collapse of FTX. “China’s ...

View more: Cryptocurrency entrepreneur and Huobi adviser Justin Sun plans move to Hong Kong while talking up China market

Obesity can trigger Alzheimer’s symptoms, new study suggests

Watch distant worlds dance around their sun: Stunning timelapse shows exoplanets orbiting their star 133 light-years away from Earth

A mysterious flying spiral above Hawaiian night sky likely caused by SpaceX launch

Bring back the dodo bird? Ambitious plan draws investors, critics

Glowing material may cut out internal stitches

Xiaomi looks to improve decision-making with new governance bodies in wake of management reshuffles, slumping sales

Mars shines bright in night sky as it vanishes behind moon

Dolphins and humans can team up to go fishing. Scientists now understand why.

EPA blocks mine project that threatened crucial Alaskan salmon runs

China’s Henan province, home to the world’s largest iPhone factory, pushes US$7 billion digital infrastructure expansion programme

Giant sea scorpion species discovered in New Mexico

Five healthy digital habits It's not too late to make resolutions that will make your digital life safer and more convenient, say Kaspersky experts

OTHER NEWS