Competition Bureau probes alleged anticompetitive conduct by Loblaws, Sobeys owners

competition bureau probes alleged anticompetitive conduct by loblaws, sobeys owners

Canada's Competition Bureau has launched probes of the parents of grocery chains Loblaws and Sobeys for alleged anticompetitive conduct. A man leaves a Loblaws store in Toronto on Thursday, May 3, 2018. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Nathan Denette

VANCOUVER AND TORONTO — Canada's Competition Bureau has launched investigations into the parent companies of grocery chains Loblaws and Sobeys for alleged anticompetitive conduct, court documents reveal, with Sobeys' owner calling the inquiry "unlawful."

The Federal Court documents show the Commissioner of Competition launched the probes on March 1, saying there's reason to believe the firms' use of so-called property controls limits retail grocery competition.

The commissioner claims the controls that the grocery giants have baked into lease agreements are designed to restrict other potential tenants and their activities and are hampering competition in the grocery market.

The Competition Bureau revealed its investigation into the use of property controls in the grocery sector in February.

At the time, deputy commissioner Anthony Durocher told a House of Commons committee that property controls can be a barrier both for independent grocery stores and chains looking to expand, as well as for foreign players looking to enter Canada.

That’s why in a report last June, the bureau recommended the government limit their use in the grocery sector in order to help boost competition and make it easier for new supermarkets to open.

Industry minister François-Philippe Champagne has said he’s seeking a foreign grocer to strengthen competition in the Canadian market.

Loblaw Cos. Ltd. and Sobeys parent Empire Co. Ltd. are two of the three major Canadian grocery companies and each owns a number of grocery chains across the country.

Details of the investigations are contained in a pair of court applications lodged by the commissioner on May 6.

Sobeys owner Empire has pushed back against the investigation, saying in a separate court application that the probe gave the commissioner "the appearance of a lack of independence" amid public criticism from federal politicians over grocery pricing and retailers' conduct.

Loblaws' parent company is co-operating with the bureau's review, said spokeswoman Catherine Thomas on behalf of George Weston Ltd.

"Restrictive covenants are very common in many industries, including retail. They help support property development investments, encouraging opening of new stores and capital risk-taking," she said.

The commissioner applied in the Federal Court to order Empire and George Weston to hand over records about real estate holdings, lease agreements, customer data and other records.

In the court documents, the commissioner describes Empire and George Weston’s holdings in real estate investment trusts, or REITs. In both cases, the companies’ own grocery banners are significant tenants for the real estate companies.

Through a subsidiary, Empire holds a 41.5 per cent interest in Crombie Real Estate Investment Trust, and Empire is an anchor tenant in the majority of Crombie’s properties, the documents say, adding that Empire’s ownership interest in Crombie puts it in a position to exercise influence over the REIT.

George Weston has a controlling ownership interest of 61.7 per cent in Choice Properties Real Estate Investment Trust, and Loblaw accounted for more than half of Choice Properties’ rental revenue in 2023, the documents say — and Choice Properties and Loblaw have a strategic alliance under which the REIT has agreed to “significant restrictions” limiting “its ability to enter into leases with supermarket tenants other than Loblaw.”

The commissioner's probe is focused on the companies' operations in Halifax, but also more broadly across the country.

The documents show the inquiries are zeroing in on two types of property controls in contracts and commercial leases used by the grocery retailers "in many markets in Canada."

Restrictive covenants in private contracts, the commissioner says, "limit or restrict" how a piece of land can be used and can apply even after changing ownership.

The covenants can "leave restrictions or exclusions on competitors that extend beyond ownership of the land, sometimes for decades," the applications say.

The probes are also looking into "exclusivity clauses" in commercial lease agreements that "limit or restrict" who a landowner can lease to and which products can be sold by other parties close to another leaseholders' business.

"According to market participants, property controls are widespread in the retail grocery sector, impacting where and how businesses can compete in the retail sale of food products," the commissioner claims.

The property controls, the commissioner says, may give the companies "the ability to exclude actual or potential competitors from selling food products within certain geographic areas or to dictate the terms upon which they carry on business."

“This is a novel case,” said Michael Osborne, chair of the Canadian competition practice at law firm Cozen O’Connor.

Previous cases alleging abuse of dominance involved companies with significantly more market power than George Weston or Empire have individually, said Osborne.

Therefore, the Bureau will have to argue that the companies are jointly dominant because they're using the same tools and together represent a large portion of the market, he said.

“The Bureau has never brought a joint dominance case before.”

Sobeys parent Empire claims the commissioner was wrong to start the inquiry because it doesn't have a "dominant" market position.

In a separate application in Federal Court that has yet to be decided by a judge, the company denies that property controls are anti-competitive and says they "are not unique to the grocery sector, but have been widely used for decades in a range of retail and other sectors across the country."

Empire also claims the inquiry was launched for an "improper purpose," claiming the grocery sector has been the subject of an "inordinate" amount of attention from politicians.

The company says the Competition Commissioner must make decisions independently and "free from political interference and direction."

Empire says the decision to launch an inquiry, amid a wave of criticism over rising grocery prices, raises "at least the appearance of a lack of independence of the Commissioner."

The company's lawyer declined to comment since the matter is still before the courts.

Competition Bureau spokeswoman Sarah Brown confirmed the formal investigations launched March 1 and said the Bureau had filed a motion to strike Empire’s application for judicial review.

She declined to comment further, citing ongoing court proceedings.

The bureau is using new tools it gained from recent amendments to the Competition Act that broaden the scope of the kinds of agreements it can look into.

Canada’s major grocers have recently been under public and political pressure as food prices have risen by double digits over just a handful of years.

The grocers have denied allegations of so-called greedflation, but the government has called on them to take action to stabilize food prices. All three major Canadian grocers have also agreed to participate in an industry-led code of conduct meant to help level the playing field for suppliers and smaller grocery retailers.

This report by The Canadian Press was first published May 24, 2024.

Darryl Greer and Rosa Saba, The Canadian Press

OTHER NEWS

20 minutes ago

Nigel Farage to launch 'contract with the people' in Wales following poll boosts

20 minutes ago

Tony Awards 2024: How to Watch, Nominations, Host, Performers

20 minutes ago

Arne Slot handed early Liverpool headache after unlikely star makes Euro 2024 statement

20 minutes ago

London jumps into top 10 in global ‘most expensive cities’ list

21 minutes ago

CDC Warns About Chocolate Brand; Raw Garlic and Acne; Odd Appeal of Cow Pedicures

21 minutes ago

Queensland Maroons State of Origin team list for Game II announced, Reece Walsh picked, Selwyn Cobbo misses out

21 minutes ago

Dodgers put Yoshinobu Yamamoto on IL with triceps tightness

21 minutes ago

Dodgers put Yoshinobu Yamamoto on IL with strained rotator cuff

21 minutes ago

Chinese premier and Australian prime minister meet at Australia's Parliament House

22 minutes ago

Kate Middleton captures Prince William and kids at beach for touching Father's Day tribute

24 minutes ago

Less than 10 per cent of homeless shelters N.S. promised last year currently in place

26 minutes ago

Pa. widow wins $1 million scratch-off as dying husband feared she’d have money troubles

28 minutes ago

Cabrera wins first event since release from prison

28 minutes ago

'Nazi hunter' would support Le Pen's party in France

28 minutes ago

Childish Ford Ranger Raptor owner tries to stick it to EVs

28 minutes ago

Sen. Tim Scott says he stands by his decision to certify President Biden's 2020 election

28 minutes ago

Lilia Vu comes back from injury to beat Lexi Thompson, Grace Kim in playoff

28 minutes ago

Hajj pilgrims perform Tawaf Al-Ifadah

31 minutes ago

Asia-Pacific markets all slide ahead of key China data

33 minutes ago

Aussie basketball superstar Josh Giddey spotted with glamorous blonde model months after he was cleared of allegations about a teenage girl

33 minutes ago

England fans say Jude Bellingham's shoulder barge on Serbia's Filip Kostic 'needs to go in the Louvre' as they praise star midfielder for 'letting opponents know they were in a game'

33 minutes ago

World Cup's 'sexiest fan' Ivana Knoll takes bizarre swipe at German TV host Laura Wontorra: 'If I looked like that I'd wear winter clothes forever'

33 minutes ago

Lottie Moss puts on a VERY racy display in a sheer polka dot dress for swanky bash - after going public with new boyfriend Evan Campbell

34 minutes ago

Three missing tourists found dead in just one week on Greek islands

34 minutes ago

Democratic lawmaker doubts polls showing increased support for Trump among Black people: 'Something is amiss'

34 minutes ago

McDavid registers four points, Oilers thump Panthers to avoid Stanley Cup final sweep

34 minutes ago

Vu wins playoff in return from back injury, spoiling Thompson's bid for 1st victory in 5 years

34 minutes ago

Sunday Bird Droppings: The Orioles try to send Phillies fans home unhappy

34 minutes ago

Ohtani has second 2-homer game of season as Dodgers blank Royals 3-0. Betts' hand broken in the 7th

35 minutes ago

Nearly half of all London shootings go unsolved due to 'witnesses being afraid to share evidence' with Met Police, figures show

35 minutes ago

Opinion polls predicting 'Starmergeddon' should make voters think twice of handing Labour huge majority by voting Reform, Transport Secretary Mark Harper warns

35 minutes ago

Alan Cumming Calls Marvel’s ‘X2: X-Men United’ His “Gayest Film”

37 minutes ago

Nicole Scherzinger shows off her hourglass figure in a skintight fishtail dress ahead of her performance at the Tony Awards

38 minutes ago

Reasons behind Skomota’s reality show cancellation

38 minutes ago

Nuclear Powers Set to Continue Boosting Operational Warheads

38 minutes ago

Rory McIlroy’s horrific collapse hands US Open title to Bryson DeChambeau

38 minutes ago

New Aussie Olympic pairing for Paris

38 minutes ago

Prince Louis’ best Trooping the Colour moments resurface ahead of 2024 parade

38 minutes ago

Rory McIlroy Storms Out of Clubhouse After Losing U.S. Open to Bryson DeChambeau [VIDEO]

38 minutes ago

Pentagon shoots down concerns over Chinese solar panels