Vennells concedes ‘no one to blame’ but herself for Horizon scandal

Ex-Post Office boss Paula Vennells has admitted she has “no one to blame” but herself for what happened during the Horizon scandal.

The 65-year-old, ordained priest was giving evidence for a third day at the Horizon IT inquiry on Friday, and she told the hearing there are “no words” that will make the “sorrow and what people have gone through any better”.

Under questioning from Edward Henry KC, a lawyer representing a number of subpostmasters, she said she “didn’t always take the right path”.

She told the hearing she lost all employment since the Court of Appeal passed a judgment which ultimately led to a number of subpostmaster convictions being overturned.

Beginning his questioning, Mr Henry said; “There were so many forks in the road but you always took the wrong path, didn’t you?”

Ms Vennells said: “It was an extraordinarily complex undertaking and the Post Office and I didn’t always take the right path, I’m very clear about that.”

Mr Henry went on: “You exercised power with no thought of the consequences of your actions despite those consequences staring you in the face?”

The former chief executive replied: “The scheme was set up and for the time that I worked on that I believed … that we were doing the right things and clearly that was not always the case. We did look at the consequences.”

vennells concedes ‘no one to blame’ but herself for horizon scandal

Former Post Office boss Paula Vennells said she did work entirely in isolation (PA Media)

She added: “I understand your point that there are no words that I can find today that will make the sorrow and what people have gone through any better.”

Questioned on whether she had anyone to blame but herself during the scandal, Ms Vennells said: “Absolutely. Where I made mistakes and where I made the wrong calls … where I had information and I made the wrong calls, yes, of course.”

Mr Henry continued: “Well, you are responsible for your own downfall, aren’t you?”

She replied: “From when the Court of Appeal passed its judgment, I lost all the employment that I had, and since that time, I have only worked on this inquiry.

“It has been really important to me to do what I didn’t, or was unable to do at the time I was chief executive – and I have worked for three years and prioritised this above anything else – for the past year it has probably been a full-time job.

“I have avoided talking to the press, perhaps to my own detriment, because all the way through, I have put this first and I was not working alone on this.

“I cannot think that any of the major decisions I took by myself in isolation of anybody.”

She added: “I did my best through this. And it wasn’t good enough, and that is a regret I carry with me.”

Mr Henry continued: “I suggest to you that you still continue to live in a cloud of denial and it persists even to today because you have given in 750-odd pages (of a witness statement) a craven, self-serving account, haven’t you? ‘I didn’t know, nobody told me, I can’t remember, I was not shown this, I relied on the lawyers’.”

Ms Vennells replied: “I have tried to do this to the very best of my ability. I have taken … all of the questions I was asked. I have answered them honestly, no matter how difficult or how embarrassing or how wrong I was at the time. I don’t believe I could have worked harder for this.”

Mr Henry went on: “What I’m going to suggest to you is that whatever you did was deliberate, considered and calculated. No one deceived you, no one misled you. You set the agenda and the tone for the business.”

Ms Vennells responded: “I was the chief executive, I did not set the agenda for the work of the scheme and the way the legal and the IT parts of it worked.

“I had to rely on those colleagues who were experts and I had no reason not to take the advice that I was given. I accept I was chief executive and, as I have said, as a chief executive you have ultimate accountability and that is simply fact.

“You are not responsible for everything that happens underneath you. You have to rely on the advice of internal and external experts and that is what I did and I was not working alone on this.”

She added: “I did my very best through this, and it wasn’t good enough, and that is a regret I carry with me.”

More than 700 subpostmasters were prosecuted by the Post Office and handed criminal convictions between 1999 and 2015 as Fujitsu’s faulty Horizon IT system made it appear as though money was missing at their branches.

Hundreds of subpostmasters are still awaiting compensation despite the Government announcing that those who have had convictions quashed are eligible for £600,000 payouts.

OTHER NEWS

12 minutes ago

Shadow health secretary Wes Streeting says manifesto is 'just the start' of spending - and won't rule out council tax hikes

12 minutes ago

Leslie's Clover Chips Barbecue Corn Snacks recalled: Do not eat

12 minutes ago

Father's fury after he is fined for taking his 14-year-old daughter out of school to mark the D-Day commemorations in France

12 minutes ago

Couldn't you afford an England shirt, Sir Keir? Labour leader is ridiculed after Angela Rayner posts a picture of him celebrating Three Lions' Euros win wearing a plain white top

12 minutes ago

Abbie Chatfield reveals surprise details about her first date with new boyfriend Adam Hyde and her 'special performance' at 4am

13 minutes ago

Gabrielle Rose proves age is just a number as she competes in US swim trials at 46

13 minutes ago

Penny Wong insists the Coalition is abandoning Australia's Pacific neighbours

13 minutes ago

This ASX 200 stock's 'compelling valuation' makes it a strong buy

13 minutes ago

Unity bears first fruit in KZN

13 minutes ago

Ed Davey praises Princess of Wales and Alan Bates

13 minutes ago

Modi's Indian government and its allies accused of spying, silencing Sikh critics and pushing its far-right ideology in Australia

13 minutes ago

Nigel Farage’s populist Reform Party overtakes Conservatives, polls show

13 minutes ago

Love Island fans call for 'disgrace' Ronnie to be removed after 'cruel' scenes

13 minutes ago

Cesc Fabregas names England star who has to 'step up' after 'underwhelming' Serbia display

15 minutes ago

Tampa 19-year-old kills parents before getting into shootout with law enforcement

16 minutes ago

Clare Grogan: 'Being in Altered Images earned me £75 a week'

17 minutes ago

The best faces England fans pulled during win over Serbia at fan park in Germany

17 minutes ago

Toby Bedford the tagger looms as a key for GWS

19 minutes ago

Kim Kardashian enjoys a good slice of New York pizza at North West's 11th birthday party

19 minutes ago

Mark Wright embarks on an epic road trip to the Euros in Germany with pal Olly Murs - who misses first father's day for the trip - as England triumph

19 minutes ago

Video: Real World star and Fox News host Sean Duffy divides viewers for telling wife and mother of his NINE children she 'looked better' when she worked out on national TV

19 minutes ago

Video: Heart-stopping video reveals how race marshal narrowly dodges death after car loses control on track and comes flying towards him - before smashing into a concrete barrier

19 minutes ago

Scottish Euros fan was 'sent to stay in an abandoned medical facility' which looked like 'something out of a murder film' after complaining to Booking.com for hours about previous room with 'bed made from cardboard' in shambolic £2,000 trip to Germany

19 minutes ago

Star Wars: What The Original Voice Of Emperor Palpatine Sounds Like

21 minutes ago

Age may be election’s defining issue as Trump and Biden count down to TV debate

21 minutes ago

Bryson DeChambeau outduels Rory McIlroy to win 2024 U.S. Open at Pinehurst No. 2

21 minutes ago

Donald Trump grips railing for dear life in embarrassing video as he walks down stairs

21 minutes ago

Toronto hosting week long Indigenous Music Summit

21 minutes ago

Caitlin Clark Puts League on Notice After Fever-Sky Showdown

21 minutes ago

Clark and Ledecky lead charge of women's sports in Indy

22 minutes ago

1 person killed, 1 injured in West Pullman shooting

23 minutes ago

Calgary explores using interim pipes to move water from Bearspaw plant

24 minutes ago

Australians ‘frustrated’ with Albanese government

24 minutes ago

Penny Wong claims Australians will pay more for power under Coalition

24 minutes ago

UK on high security after Russian nuke sub spotted off Scottish coast

24 minutes ago

Gareth Southgate handed huge boost as Manchester United star returns

24 minutes ago

Bellingham's brilliance cannot disguise England's many problems

24 minutes ago

Henry Cavill asks fans for some parenting 'tips' ahead of becoming a dad for the first time in sweet Father's Day post

24 minutes ago

Naomi Watts shares heartbreaking post about her late dad on Father's Day after he died of a heroin overdose when she was seven years old

24 minutes ago

Tony Awards 2024: Julianne Hough is effortlessly radiant in a form-fitting blush gown on the red carpet in New York City