'Limited' chance of Lehrmann paying mammoth legal bill, judge says

'limited' chance of lehrmann paying mammoth legal bill, judge says

Former Liberal staffer Bruce Lehrmann has been ordered to pay most of Network Ten's legal costs from his failed defamation case against the broadcaster.

Ten could have very limited prospects of recouping millions in legal costs spent successfully defending a defamation case brought by Bruce Lehrmann, a judge says.

The former Liberal staffer had his lawsuit tossed in April when Justice Michael Lee found reports he had raped Brittany Higgins in a parliament house office five years earlier were true, based on the balance of probabilities.

In May, the Federal Court judge ordered the 28-year-old pay the legal bill of Network Ten and journalist Lisa Wilkinson on an indemnity basis.

That is higher than ordinary costs, which usually allow from 50 to 60 per cent of a party's bill to be recovered.

Justice Lee found Lehrmann had defended the criminal charge of rape "on a false basis, lied to police and then allowed that lie to go uncorrected before the jury".

During a short hearing this morning, the judge noted Wilkinson had spent just over $1.8 million defending the case.

Ten's barrister Zoe Graus did not say how much the network was owed, adding those details were still being ironed out.

The hearing discussed whether Wilkinson's costs should be sent to a referee for assessment, to see whether her expenses were reasonable and how much should eventually be covered by Ten as her employer.

The reference would also include how much Lehrmann would have to pay Ten for both its and Wilkinson's costs.

But Justice Lee questioned whether the network would be wasting money arguing over the details of specific charges as Lehrmann might not be able to foot the multimillion-dollar legal bill regardless of its cost.

"Is the cost associated with a reference... really worth the candle given... what appears to be... the limited prospect of recovery?" he asked.

"I don't want people throwing good money after bad and having referees going down the path of preparing detailed reports when it's a completely futile exercise."

The ex-staffer had no financial backers and his lawyers had agreed they did not need to be paid if he lost the case, the court heard previously.

Wilkinson's barrister Michael Elliott SC said his client and Ten continued to disagree on how much was payable.

"On any view, there would be a sensible sum of money that would be recognised as payable and there's just an ongoing reluctance to pay us anything," he told the court.

Graus said Ten did not dispute that it had to pay some of Wilkinson's legal expenses but it was having difficulty identifying which of her individually billed items it should pay.

Lehrmann sued Ten and Wilkinson over a February 2021 report on The Project in which Higgins was interviewed about the alleged rape, in March 2019.

He has until May 31 to appeal the defamation case finding.

The case will return to court on June 27 when Ten could tell the court how much money it thinks Lehrmann should pay.

National Domestic Violence Service: 1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732). National Sexual Abuse and Redress Support Service 1800 211 028.

OTHER NEWS

17 minutes ago

2024 MLB draft: Who will Guardians take with No. 1 pick? Two-way SEC player, power hitters, more on the board

17 minutes ago

Ole Miss makes massive change to 2025 college football schedule by cancelling high-profile non-conference matchup

17 minutes ago

Heat and humidity fuels thunderstorm threat in Ontario Tuesday

17 minutes ago

Uber, Khosla, Nvidia invest in $200 million funding round for autonomous trucking startup Waabi

19 minutes ago

Montana canal siphon splits open, flooding area and threatening local farming industry

22 minutes ago

Russia ramps up deportations of Ukrainian children with ‘summer camps’: researchers

22 minutes ago

Fisker files for bankruptcy protection in wave of EV startups, moment of déjà vu for its founder

22 minutes ago

Steve Cohen is set to make a big push into investing in AI

22 minutes ago

Apple has ‘very serious’ non-compliance issues with key EU digital law, Margrethe Vestager says

22 minutes ago

What a Labour-run NHS looks like: One in 20 Welsh patients waiting A YEAR for treatment, new data shows, compared to just 0.5 per cent of those in England

22 minutes ago

Jose Mourinho names the three Euro 2024 stars he will watch with 'sadness'... including two former Premier League favourites

22 minutes ago

Hungary striker Martin Adam - who went viral for being an 'absolute unit' - breaks silence as he responds to social media comments

22 minutes ago

Video: Lala Kent reveals the man she lost virginity to looked like 'the offspring of The Rock' as she dishes details on the first time she had sex

22 minutes ago

Video: Charlotte Crosby flaunts her impressive figure in a barely there yellow bandeau bikini and heels

22 minutes ago

Video: Lady In The Lake trailer: Natalie Portman is an obsessed 1960s housewife on the run from a 'secret life' in the Apple TV+ series

22 minutes ago

Prevention task force recommends intensive counseling for kids with obesity

26 minutes ago

"We need loyalists": Far-right Freedom Caucus chairman in MAGA civil war over tepid Trump support

26 minutes ago

"Virtually no public information": Trump campaign pays over $3 million to mystery company

26 minutes ago

Kevin O'Leary Pours Cold Water on Trump Tax Plan as 'Game Changer'

26 minutes ago

SpaceX's Starlink Mini Dish Features a Built-In Wi-Fi Router

26 minutes ago

What is the 'Man Utd tax'? Bonkers Branthwaite price and more overpriced transfer fees

26 minutes ago

BLACKPINK's LISA Announces New Solo Single ‘Rockstar': Here's When It Arrives

26 minutes ago

Kobbie Mainoo speaks out on Man Utd decision to keep Erik ten Hag

26 minutes ago

'Brentford feel they can qualify for Europe'

26 minutes ago

49ers offseason was neither great nor terrible, and that's fine

26 minutes ago

Falcons failed experiment among NFL players with most to prove in 2024

30 minutes ago

Tesla rival Fisker files for bankruptcy after glitches doomed Ocean SUVs

30 minutes ago

Southerners slam neighbors with ‘lefty politics’ who move in and drive up cost of living: ‘Don’t California my Tennessee!’

31 minutes ago

Cheltenham sign former Wrexham captain Young

31 minutes ago

Everything announced at the June 2024 Nintendo Direct

31 minutes ago

Hispanic shoppers can buoy Constellation Brands in tough consumer environment, Jefferies says

31 minutes ago

Wolves expect Hammers bid for skipper Kilman

32 minutes ago

JetBlue Makes a Big Update to Basic Economy Baggage Policy — and It's Making Flying Cheaper

32 minutes ago

‘House Of The Dragon’ Season 2 Premiere Viewership Down Versus Series Launch

32 minutes ago

Sofia Carson And Corey Mylchreest To Star In Feature Adaptation Of ‘My Oxford Year’ For Netflix And Temple Hill

32 minutes ago

Comedian Danny Jolles Prepping Third Special

32 minutes ago

Lionsgate Promotes Chase Brisbin To EVP International SVOD Sales & Head Of Global Channels

32 minutes ago

Couple spent ‘all of our money' to open a New York cafe—their business brought in nearly $50 million last year

32 minutes ago

Boyfriend of 12-year-old girl found dead in north Houston creek said she was talking with 2 adults before she was killed

32 minutes ago

Boyfriend of 12-year-old girl found dead in north Houston creek said she was talking with 2 adults before she was killed, mayor says