Ofcom decisions on GB News rule breaches ‘killed’ presenter’s career, court told

ofcom decisions on gb news rule breaches ‘killed’ presenter’s career, court told

Ofcom found GB News twice breached its broadcasting rules (Yui Mok/PA)

A former GB News presenter’s career was “killed” by Ofcom twice ruling his show breached its broadcasting code, the High Court has heard.

Mark Steyn is taking legal action against the regulator over its decisions in 2023 that two of his shows in 2022, which both related to the Covid vaccine rollout, amounted to breaches of its rules.

The Canadian broadcaster is asking a High Court judge to quash the decisions, with his lawyers claiming they lacked “clarity and coherence” and risked an “obvious potential chilling effect”.

However, barristers for Ofcom claim the regulator was free to make its decisions to protect the public from potential harm.

Speaking in a packed courtroom in London on Tuesday, Jonathan Price, for Mr Steyn, said: “The rulings against his show have killed his career, killed his career in the UK, and given rise to what he describes as crude defamation … recycled through the London papers as if they had the force of criminal convictions.”

The decisions related to two separate broadcasts of Mr Steyn’s primetime show on GB News, which began with the presenter delivering a monologue known as “The Steyn Line”.

Mr Price said that the show “did not adopt an anti-vax approach” but instead “strongly criticised the purely binary position” on Covid vaccines and featured guests who “questioned and challenged the official narrative”.

Ofcom’s first decision concerned a show broadcast on April 21 2022, which related to Mr Steyn’s monologue on the rollout of Covid vaccines, based on UK Health Security Agency (UKHSA) data.

The watchdog received four complaints about the broadcast and on March 6 2023 said it breached its rules as it “presented a materially misleading interpretation” of the figures “without sufficient challenge or counterweight”, which it said risked “harm to viewers”.

It also said that the programme “failed to reflect” that the UKHSA had warned that raw data on Covid vaccines “should not be used to draw conclusions about the effectiveness of the vaccine”.

The second decision concerned Mr Steyn’s show on October 4 2022, where he interviewed author Naomi Wolf.

Ofcom said in May last year that during the interview, Dr Wolf likened the vaccine rollout to a “mass murder” which was comparable to the actions of “doctors in pre-Nazi Germany”.

The regulator received 422 complaints following the interview, ruling on May 9 last year that GB News failed to take “adequate steps to protect viewers” from “potentially harmful content”, labelling Dr Wolf’s comments as promoting “a serious conspiracy theory”.

No statutory sanction was imposed for either breach, but GB News was requested to attend a meeting to discuss its approach to compliance with the code.

Mr Steyn, who no longer works for the channel, attended the hearing on Tuesday having travelled from the United States, with Dr Wolf also in attendance.

In written submissions, Jessica Boyd KC, representing Ofcom, said there was “no realistic basis” for the court to rule that the regulator had “obviously gone wrong” in its decisions, adding that the rights of broadcasters to freedom of expression “are not unqualified”.

She said: “Both decisions were correct in concluding that the programmes could cause potential harm to the rights of viewers by distorting their understanding of issues which were likely to have a significant bearing on their health decisions in the context of a continuing pandemic.”

Ms Boyd continued: “Neither decision sought to prevent the claimant, or his guests, from ventilating controversial views about important public health issues or from challenging the reliability of official medical advice, including in inflammatory or provocative terms.

“He and they remain free to do so, provided they comply with the (Ofcom) code.”

The hearing before Mrs Justice Farbey is due to conclude on Tuesday, with a judgment expected in writing at a later date.

OTHER NEWS

21 minutes ago

Dwight Yorke names the young star Manchester United should sign to create 'buzz'

21 minutes ago

South Korea Considers Supplying Weapons to Ukraine

21 minutes ago

Tom Marquand living the dream as he revels in royal reunion at Ascot after winning the Coronation Stakes with Porta Fortuna - and he could meet the King again this weekend!

21 minutes ago

Netherlands coach feels VAR got it wrong over disallowed goal at Euro 2024

21 minutes ago

Why Putin's visit is worrying the West

21 minutes ago

Billionaire businessman James K. Irving dead at 96

21 minutes ago

Emma Stone shows off legs in tweed miniskirt with matching jacket as she promotes her new film Kinds Of Kindness in NYC

24 minutes ago

Dressel wins 50 metres free splash and dash to set up Paris title defence

26 minutes ago

Canada giving political space to 'Khalistani' extremists: India

26 minutes ago

Matthew Lewis doesn't 'want to do' “Harry Potter” reboot but is intrigued by idea of adult Neville

26 minutes ago

Here’s how people with $1 million or more changed their asset allocation last year

26 minutes ago

Taylor Swift forced to stop sell-out London Eras Tour show and call on security

26 minutes ago

Key dates for 2025 NFL season that could have big impact on 49ers

26 minutes ago

WATCH: Proteas’ confidence rising after performing under pressure - Heinrich Klaasen

26 minutes ago

Ronwen Williams’ mentor, who converted him from being a striker to a goalkeeper

29 minutes ago

Shocking claim in alleged western Sydney road rage attack

31 minutes ago

Probe needed to prevent repeat of B.C. sewage plant debacle, former auditor says

31 minutes ago

Controversial worker ‘floatel’ drops anchor for LNG project near Squamish

32 minutes ago

McLaren Artura Spider road test: Spacious supercar makes light work of dizzying speeds

32 minutes ago

Swimmer Apollo Hess 1st member of Blood Tribe to go to Olympics

32 minutes ago

I wouldn’t use private healthcare even if my children were ill, Starmer says

32 minutes ago

Labour plots £10billion tax increases in first budget this autumn

35 minutes ago

Caitlin Clark Makes WNBA History Against Atlanta Dream

35 minutes ago

Sha'Carri Richardson on track for Paris Olympics with top 100 time in trials' opening round

36 minutes ago

Reality TV's Julie Chrisley must be resentenced in bank fraud, tax evasion case, appeals judges rule

37 minutes ago

The strong women of the Bach family

37 minutes ago

Queen Camilla enjoys a friendly chat with former Strictly judge Darcey Bussell as they attend Royal Ascot

37 minutes ago

JK Rowling accuses Sir Keir Starmer of 'abandoning' women after Labour leader changes views on gender

37 minutes ago

Women voters in France give a boost to Marine Le Pen's hard-Right party - as country prepares for snap general election

37 minutes ago

Labour-affiliated rail union TSSA in merger talks with the militant RMT about creating a 'mega union' capable of shutting down almost the entire UK railway network

37 minutes ago

England have been stumbling their way through Euro 2024, writes GRAEME SOUNESS. They are supposed to have leadership groups - well b****y lead then! And why I'm so happy to be ribbed by Alan Hansen

37 minutes ago

Aer Lingus travel chaos: Airline cancels flights from UK to Ireland as pilots announce strike

37 minutes ago

Hugh Jackman shows off his lean and muscular Wolverine physique while carrying a guitar bag at JFK airport in New York

37 minutes ago

Stephen Lawrence killer David Norris to apply for early release after serving just 12 years of his sentence

37 minutes ago

Jailed for three years, callous carer who stole £75,000 from Scots film writer to fuel his gambling addiction

37 minutes ago

Campaign to fund a statue honouring Dame Vera Lynn will receive £1 million boost if Conservatives win power after general election

37 minutes ago

Police search for a power drill with a tracker leads to £1m haul of 3,500 'stolen' tools

37 minutes ago

Lucy Letby denies dislodging breathing tube of a very premature baby in a bid to murder her, court hears

37 minutes ago

Gareth Southgate's flawed England tactics have resulted in frazzled minds, chaos and a team shredded of self-respect, writes IAN LADYMAN

37 minutes ago

Former Royal British Legion secretary accused of 'forgery' over neighbour's £5m will withdraws his claim on the cash