Treasure review – Lena Dunham and Stephen Fry can’t save muddled father-daughter Holocaust drama

treasure review – lena dunham and stephen fry can’t save muddled father-daughter holocaust drama

Stephen Fry and Lena Dunham in Treasure. Photograph: Anne Wilk

Stephen Fry and Lena Dunham play a Jewish father and daughter who miscommunicate their way through 90s Poland, until a visit to Auschwitz allows them to dig up the past (literally). There’s no doubting the good intentions of Dunham, Fry and the esteemed German director/writer, Julia von Heinz. All three clearly want to use this adaptation of Lily Brett’s novel Too Many Men to explore survivor’s guilt and enduring antisemitism. Alas, most of the film’s big scenes are either tonally muddled or soul-crushingly predictable.

Fry, who learned Polish to play Edek Rothwax, is miscast as an honorary New Yorker whose avuncular persona masks fear and fury. We believe in the character’s charm and suppressed pain (Fry is pitch-perfect in the chilling segment of the movie in which Edek visits his requisitioned family home). What he can’t convey is Edek’s Big Apple attitude or rage. As for Dunham, her Ruth – sometimes abject, frequently abrasive – is a potentially fascinating figure who’s been overloaded with distracting problems. This music journalist has a chronic eating disorder, engages in a grungy tattoo ritual and secretly obsesses over an ex called Garth. Every time Garth’s name was mentioned, I groaned. The truth about Treasure: it’s too conventional to satisfy devotees of Lena Dunham and too much of a vehicle for Dunham to please anyone else.

• In UK and Irish cinemas now

OTHER NEWS

1 hour ago

Watertank Solutions Victoria fined $45k after worker left paralysed from falling headfirst into concrete tank

1 hour ago

Singapore Shelf: From musings on Dakota childhood to poetry about mum’s illness

1 hour ago

Book review: Tricia Tan’s Patient History a promising poetry debut on illness

1 hour ago

The Straits Times’ Weekly Bestsellers July 13

1 hour ago

Future of HDB flats: A delicate balancing act, says sociologist Chua Beng Huat

1 hour ago

Shelley Duvall and Me

1 hour ago

RB CEO reveals what went wrong with mid-season upgrades as correlation issue found

1 hour ago

The Boys Had A Third Ryan Butcher Actor That Fans Probably Missed

1 hour ago

Over 94 thousand quintals of grain harvested in Nabeul

1 hour ago

China's secret military build-up in Tajikistan exposed by satellites

1 hour ago

Halle Berry, Glenn Close to Star With Kim Kardashian in Hulu Legal Drama From Ryan Murphy

1 hour ago

'The Bachelorette' Jenn Tran Hopes to 'Open Hearts and Minds' as Franchise's First Asian American Lead

1 hour ago

‘Gladiator II' Trailer: Paul Mescal Battles Pedro Pascal to Avenge His Roman Royal Family Legacy in Ridley Scott's Sequel

1 hour ago

Kyle Juszczyk admits taking pay cut 'hurt,' but top priority was remaining a 49er: 'I absolutely love it here'

1 hour ago

Vans Unveils ‘Always Out There' Campaign Featuring Three Sneaker Styles

1 hour ago

Vermont floods raise concerns about future of state's hundreds of aging dams

1 hour ago

'Felt I could get Virat Kohli out every ball...': James Anderson drops 'inferior' remark during farewell speech

1 hour ago

The volunteers out to save Toganmain, one of Australia's most important woolsheds

1 hour ago

Texas needs money to keep the lights on during extreme weather. It’s funding more fossil fuel instead

1 hour ago

Extreme weather in South Africa is disrupting tourism – research tracks the impact on coastal areas

1 hour ago

A Giant Energy Dome Is Daringly Turning Carbon Dioxide Into Power

1 hour ago

Shilo Sanders Credits Unusual Offseason Activity For Improvement In Speed

1 hour ago

Declan Rice ready to ‘run through a brick wall’ as England seek Euro 2024 glory

1 hour ago

Harrison Butker snaps back at Serena Williams after tennis star's BRUTAL dig at him at ESPYs

1 hour ago

Ashley Judd Is Latest Celebrity With Joe Biden Ties To Call On Him To Step Aside

1 hour ago

Eminem calls out Sean ‘Diddy' Combs for Cassie incident in new song

1 hour ago

A Taiwan-based Buddhist charity attempts to take the founding nun's message of compassion global

1 hour ago

New Zealand v England LIVE rugby: Latest build-up and updates from second Test at Eden Park

1 hour ago

Australia's Jess Hull smashes world 2,000m record ahead of Paris Olympics campaign

1 hour ago

Triton Workcentre Unboxing

1 hour ago

Shelters scramble as heavy rain continues

1 hour ago

What AT&T Customers Need to Know About the Massive Hack, Data Breach

1 hour ago

Jason Whitlock makes Caitlin Clark-Michael Jordan comparison amid Rookie of the Year race

1 hour ago

Video: GWS delivers epic troll to crosstown rivals Sydney over dramatic Isaac Heeney video message to fans - but Swans boss is not amused

1 hour ago

After 4 lung washes and $40k spent, ex-vaper reclaims his health

1 hour ago

Kindness of strangers helps women find stable homes amid housing crisis

1 hour ago

Bronny James' Explosive Dunk Before Lakers Summer League Game Has NBA On Notice

1 hour ago

Recently Waived NBA Forward Doesn't Care He Was Cut From Team

1 hour ago

My Sweet Land portrays anxieties of life and war in Artsakh through coming-of-age story

1 hour ago

6 Of The Best Harbor Freight Finds Under $50