Opinion: CNN Wants to Mute Trump at Its Debate. Good Luck With That

opinion: cnn wants to mute trump at its debate. good luck with that

Animated GIF by Thomas Levinson/The Daily Beast/Getty

There are a few events in every presidential campaign that matter. The upcoming presidential debate between Joe Biden and Donald Trump—just over a week from now—will likely be one such moment. But who is likely to benefit from the clash?

To a certain degree, victory is contingent on the rules of the debate (CNN has announced their rules, which have been agreed on by both campaigns).

Based on what I’m seeing, the deck is stacked in Biden’s favor.

Let’s start with what might be the most important change: “Microphones will be muted throughout the debate except for the candidate whose turn it is to speak.”

It’s easy to imagine that constant interruptions could cause Biden to lose his train of thought amid the chaos, thereby creating a “senior moment” that would reinforce the narrative that says he’s too old for a second term.

On the other hand, during the first presidential debate in 2020, Trump’s attempt to exasperate Biden backfired, resulting in Biden’s best line of the night: “Will you shut up, man?” A muted mic would have deprived Biden of that zinger.

Still, the first rule of this debate probably has to be “do no harm.” And the muted mic decree seems very likely to reduce the risk for Biden.

Couple that with Trump and his minions unwisely downplaying Biden’s cognitive ability, and Biden could win the expectations game merely by showing up and not drooling on himself.

The other important CNN debate rule is that there will be no studio audience.

Even if Trump were not permitted to stack the audience with supporters (as he did during last year’s controversial CNN town hall), Trump disproportionately benefits from a live audience.

“Trump feeds off the crowd, they give him life,” one Biden adviser told Politico. “We wanted to take that away.”

They did.

Again, this rule seems almost guaranteed to aid Biden.

This is not to say that the rule change is unfair or that studio audiences should be allowed. One could argue that modern political debates have become “TV shows” that are too focused on entertaining us as consumers, rather than feeding us as citizens.

Regardless, genuinely restoring the intellectual grandeur of presidential debates would require much broader reforms than those instituted by CNN. Instead, CNN’s rules simply seem narrowly tailored to squash a repeat of Donald Trump’s behavior during the first 2020 debate.

Which is why it’s so curious that Trump has allowed Biden and CNN to set these particular parameters.

(Note: Fox News’ Sean Hannity might be ahead of the curve on recognizing this; Hannity recently floated the idea that Trump should “pass on the debate” until he’s the official nominee.)

Having been disadvantaged by the rules, the two most pertinent remaining questions may be: Will CNN enforce the rules—and what happens if Trump tries to break them?

If CNN fails to enforce the rules, it will be a major blow to Team Biden. After all, Biden decided to forgo having the Commission on Presidential Debates sponsor the debate precisely because it “was unable or unwilling to enforce the rules in the 2020 debates,” resulting in “noisy spectacles of approval or jeering.”

The good news is that CNN’s rules seem both simple and easy to implement.

Microphones can easily be muted when it’s the other candidate’s turn, and there won’t be an audience to break any “no applause” rules that CNN might otherwise have requested of a live audience.

Now, it’s possible that Trump will still attempt to interrupt Biden, even after his microphone has been cut. But the risk-reward ratio for Trump doing so is not great.

To be sure, Trump is Harry Houdini, but it’s hard to imagine how he will escape these debate rules.

At this point, you might wonder why Trump’s team agreed to these rules.

To be honest, I’m not sure.

We may look back and say that Trump lost the debate (and thus, the election) back in May, when the contours of the rules were established. That was the moment that Joe Biden used Donald Trump’s debate taunts (“anywhere, any time, any place”) as an opportunity to set some key parameters and box Trump into an unfavorable position.

Biden seized the initiative and picked the timing (much earlier than most General Election debates). Biden picked the number of debates (just two, plus a vice presidential debate). And Biden was first to accept CNN’s invitation to host the debate, and CNN set the rules.

Debates are complex and dynamic, and it is impossible to predict which side will actually benefit most from the rules (you can’t stop Trump, you can only hope to contain him). But if most battles are won before they are fought, Team Biden got everything they could have wanted.

Forgive me for re-setting the expectations, but this is now Joe Biden’s debate to lose.

Read more at The Daily Beast.

OTHER NEWS

16 minutes ago

SNP MP asks Starmer 'what changed' in relation to Labour's stance on child poverty

16 minutes ago

Jomo Sono proud as UJ honours 'son' Pitso Mosimane

16 minutes ago

Michael Owen names Man Utd star who wanted Erik ten Hag to be sacked

16 minutes ago

The Perils of the Democratic Alliance’s Public Works Policies: A Concern for South Africa’s Future

16 minutes ago

Shocking workplace conditions at Baltimore city facility where staff are forced to ask for toilet paper

16 minutes ago

Baby of the House Sam Carling delivers first speech in Parliament aged 22

16 minutes ago

Italian government rejects EU Commission warning about interference in public media

16 minutes ago

Kamala Harris’s absence from Netanyahu’s Congressional address: A bad start

16 minutes ago

Why the recent interest rate announcement is good news for South Africa property investors

16 minutes ago

BBC Studios Fires Starting Gun On Race To Replace Ralph Lee At Helm Of $2B Content Unit

22 minutes ago

Abbie Chatfield shares a photo of her current boyfriend and ex, sending followers wild

23 minutes ago

Mother of backseat passenger, longtime friend of Bexar County deputy killed in wrong-way crash speaks out

23 minutes ago

Jennifer Aniston calls out JD Vance's ‘childless cat ladies' comment with message on her IVF journey

23 minutes ago

TCU celebrating history at the 2024 Paris Olympics

25 minutes ago

Abortion, Israel-Hamas War, criminal justice: Where Harris' agenda could break from Biden's on key issues for voters

25 minutes ago

Banks want your voice data for extra security protection. Don't do it!

25 minutes ago

10 to watch: Why Olympian Jahmal Harvey gives USA Boxing hope to end gold-medal drought

25 minutes ago

‘These old legs are coming to an end’: Munster set for double hip surgery

25 minutes ago

New road connection to Sydney Airport to open in September, as government urges drivers to familarise themselves

25 minutes ago

FC Rottach-Egern 1-14 Bayern Munich: Initial reactions and observations

25 minutes ago

Australia imposes sanctions on Israeli settlers, youth group over West Bank violence

25 minutes ago

Michael Owen claims Man Utd star wanted Erik ten Hag to be sacked

25 minutes ago

Online GP consultations have led to harm and death, investigation finds

25 minutes ago

More Heathrow flights cancelled as traffic snarls on M25

25 minutes ago

Lloyds earnings dip as boost from borrowing costs slows

25 minutes ago

Hamas slams Netanyahu's remarks on efforts to release Gaza hostages as 'pure lies'

25 minutes ago

'Children will pay price of two-child benefit cap for the rest of their lives'

25 minutes ago

British Gas owner sees profits slump as energy markets stabilise

25 minutes ago

I cut the hedge outside my home into the shape of a naked lady - but drunk people keep pretending to have sex with it

25 minutes ago

Why Obama has not yet endorsed Kamala Harris' presidential bid according to Biden family insider who claims to know what he really thinks

25 minutes ago

Video: Revealed: Why Russian athletes are able to compete at the 2024 Paris Olympics - but why they WON'T feature on the medal table or bear their country's colours or flag

25 minutes ago

Video: Manchester airport: Armed police officer SUSPENDED after being filmed kicking and stamping on men - as 'victims' break silence and hundreds gather outside station accusing force of racism with MORE demos planned for tonight

25 minutes ago

4 takeaways from President Biden’s Oval Office address

25 minutes ago

‘Sherlock’ Star Amanda Abbington Says BBC Failed To Take Her ‘Strictly Come Dancing’ Abuse Concerns Seriously & “Blocked” 50 Hours Of Evidence

25 minutes ago

Rumpus Signs Entertainment Boss; Paramount+’s ‘Dating Naked’ Teased; Newcastle Enters Streaming Game; Fred Media Shake-Up; Movistar Joins ‘Turbulence’ – Global Briefs

25 minutes ago

10 to watch: USWNT star Naomi Girma represents best of America, on and off field

25 minutes ago

Queen Mary knocked to the ground by elderly man on scooter during Greenland visit

25 minutes ago

Max Verstappen banned by Red Bull from sim racing before F1 races

25 minutes ago

Oregon fire is the largest burning in the US. A storm with lightning and high winds exacerbates it

25 minutes ago

FBI director suggests Donald Trump may not have been struck by bullet during assassination attempt at rally