Trump demands recusal of NY civil fraud judge over chat with outside lawyer

trump demands recusal of ny civil fraud judge over chat with outside lawyer

Trump demands recusal of NY civil fraud judge over chat with outside lawyer

Attorneys for former President Trump demanded Thursday that the judge who oversaw his civil fraud trial recuse himself from the case over allegations he improperly discussed it with an outside party.

“Allegations have surfaced revealing this Court may have engaged in actions fundamentally incompatible with the responsibilities attendant to donning the black robe and sitting in judgment,” Trump attorneys Alina Habba and Clifford Robert wrote in a 24-page recusal motion.

On Feb. 16, the day Judge Arthur Engoron handed down his multimillion-dollar judgment against Trump, a high-profile New York real estate lawyer said in an interview with NBC New York that he approached the judge about three weeks earlier to offer unsolicited advice about the case.

“I saw him in the corner [at the courthouse] and I told my client, ‘I need to go.’ And I walked over and we started talking. … I wanted him to know what I think and why … I really want him to get it right,” the lawyer, Adam Leitman Bailey, told NBC New York on Feb. 16.

Bailey later said that “the word ‘Donald Trump'” was never mentioned in the conversation, NBC New York reported, but when asked if it was clear they were discussing Trump’s case, the lawyer replied, “Well, obviously we weren’t talking about the Mets.”

At the time, court spokesperson Al Baker told the outlet that Engoron’s decision “was his alone, was deeply considered and was wholly uninfluenced” by Bailey, denying any ex parte conversation where the case was discussed without all parties present.

In an email to The Hill, Bailey contended that his remarks to NBC New York were “off the record” and said he “only discussed with the Judge the September Summary Judgment decision,” where Engoron found Trump and his co-defendants liable for fraud.

“I did not think that speaking to Judge Engoron about my own personal views of his already published decision was wrong in any way,” he said.

“I was tricked, I was duped and I’m devastated that any of this is happening, it’s just wrong,” he continued. “I am devastated and I am hurt that even though Judge Engoron is retiring very soon that he still has to deal with this, because of a statement I gave off the record.”

The conversation between Bailey and Engoron sparked a state judicial conduct investigation last month.

“The New York Code of Judicial Conduct exists to ensure that litigants are afforded a fair and impartial trial,” Habba said in a statement. “Justice Engoron’s communications with Attorney Adam Leitman Bailey regarding the merits of this case, however, directly violate that code and demonstrate that Judge Engoron cannot serve as a fair arbiter.

“It is clear that Judge Engoron should recuse himself immediately,” she said.

Engoron ruled in February that Trump, the Trump Organization and top executives conspired to alter the former president’s net worth for tax and insurance benefits. He ordered them to pay a combined $464 million, plus interest. Trump has appealed the ruling.

Updated at 7:48 pm EST.

Copyright 2024 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

For the latest news, weather, sports, and streaming video, head to NewsNation.

OTHER NEWS

27 minutes ago

Stats - Ghosh breaks batting speed limits in India's first 200 in women's T20Is

27 minutes ago

Rattled by rising rates, 165,000 home owners may be forced to sell

27 minutes ago

UAE Team Emirates' Tadej Pogacar relishing 'golden age of cycling'

27 minutes ago

AfriForum approaches ConCourt to challenge John Hlophe’s appointment to the JSC

27 minutes ago

South Africans question government signing Pension Funds Amendment Bill into law: "More control?"

27 minutes ago

‘If I leave, the players, their kids and wives will also cry’ – Ramovic takes a jibe at Rulani

27 minutes ago

Gautng metros | High chance of ActionSA - ANC marriage in GP

27 minutes ago

Analyst discusses the outlook for chip manufacturing

27 minutes ago

Tipperary locals plead for ‘common sense’ over ‘hybrid’ centre for refugees and asylum-seekers at Dundrum hotel

27 minutes ago

Kaizer Chiefs midfielder and 3 star players who can replace Bongani Zungu at Mamelodi Sundowns this summer

27 minutes ago

'Betterment of Indian cricket is important, Gautam Gambhir is not important'

27 minutes ago

Ryanair misses profit estimates as airline warns of weaker summer fares as customers ‘more frugal’

27 minutes ago

Celebrity Net Worth: Gordon Ramsay invests $100 million in US cookware maker

27 minutes ago

Matildas stars show how unimpressed they are with one of their Paris Olympics outfits in hilarious video

27 minutes ago

The little-known reason why beanies have pom-poms at the top revealed - and it's not just for looks

27 minutes ago

The terrifying consequences of sleepwalking: Sleep scientist recalls terrifying 1988 case of a man who drove his car and murdered his mother-in-law without waking

27 minutes ago

The next Anthony Joshua? Team GB’s six boxers face daunting task at Paris Olympics

27 minutes ago

Why is Singapore’s recycling rate falling?

27 minutes ago

A Stock Market Rotation of Historic Proportions Is Taking Shape

27 minutes ago

Rosehill development plan a 'hijack': Gai Waterhouse

27 minutes ago

Patients who ask for doctors seen by physician associates instead, charity warns

27 minutes ago

Victoria Pendleton: ‘I’m a fair weather cyclist now’

27 minutes ago

Pressure mounts on Secret Service; agency had denied requests for extra Trump security

27 minutes ago

Health experts reveal the red flag symptom you should NEVER ignore - because it could be a sign of cancer and diabetes

30 minutes ago

Family and colleagues mourn Paul Trumper after FIFO electrician’s death in Perth

30 minutes ago

ASX200 slips on US chaos, mining woes during July 22, 2024 trading day

30 minutes ago

Bookie Robbie Waterhouse to learn fate over claims he offered inducements

30 minutes ago

Paris Olympics opening ceremony to celebrate immigration by mocking cliched France

30 minutes ago

Thousands rally in Spain's Mallorca against mass tourism

30 minutes ago

Big Bash bowler’s bold AFL ambitions

30 minutes ago

Rulani Mokwena recruits second member of Wydad technical team

30 minutes ago

Hymn-writing couple Keith and Kristyn Getty on bringing their Irish Christmas show back to its roots

30 minutes ago

MBZUAI Hosts AI Summer School Promoting Sustainable AI

30 minutes ago

Global IT Crash That Blocked 911 Calls, Grounded Planes Eases

30 minutes ago

‘R228bn lost through private sector graft’

30 minutes ago

NASCAR Cup Series playoff bubble battle watch: The gap closes after Indianapolis

43 minutes ago

The brain makes a lot of waste. Here's how it cleans itself up

43 minutes ago

'Sunny' is a robot buddy comedy about loss

43 minutes ago

David Harbour makes surprise cameo on Lily Allen podcast during beauty discussion

43 minutes ago

Football boss Graham Annesley applauds officials for their handling of fiery Origin melee