Biden’s unworkable nursing rule will harm seniors

biden’s unworkable nursing rule will harm seniors

Biden’s unworkable nursing rule will harm seniors

What could be wrong with wanting to have a registered nurse (RN) in every nursing home in the United States at all times? Nothing — it’s just not possible.

As most facilities are already staffed by a combination of certified nursing assistants (CNAs), licensed practical nurses (LPNs) and RNs, mandating such a requirement would devastate both nursing homes and the seniors for whom they care. But, this is exactly what the Biden administration is attempting to do.

A new rule proposed by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) seeks to radically increase federally mandated staffing levels in nursing homes in two ways. First, the rule, if finalized, would require every nursing home in the nation to have an RN on-site at all times, which is much more than the current requirement of eight hours daily, five days weekly. It would separately impose new minimum staffing ratios, requiring a certain number of RNs and CNAs per resident per day.

This is a well-intentioned goal and I, as much as anyone, want seniors to have the best care possible. But, good intentions are not enough. Policy needs to be informed by reality and what is possible. And unfortunately, the current reality is pretty bleak for America’s nursing homes.

At the moment, there are nearly 15,000 nursing homes throughout the country. Of these, 29 percent are in rural areas that are more difficult to staff. In my home state of Kansas, this number is even higher — 53.7 percent of nursing homes are in rural areas. Not even half of the nation’s nursing homes are currently staffed at the level required by the proposed rule, as facilities across the nation are contending with a workforce shortage.

The nursing home workforce has declined by 12 percent since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, part of an overall contraction of the aging services workforce. Some of this can be explained by the burnout employees felt due to the intensity of the pandemic, but that is not the whole picture.

Since President Biden took office in 2021, inflation is up more than 17 percent. That puts an incredible strain on anyone running a business and the seniors and their families trying to afford care. Labor costs for nursing homes are now 22 percent higher than they were at the start of 2020.

Somehow, under these strained conditions, CMS expects nursing homes to find an additional 3,267 RNs to satisfy the 24/7 RN part of the rule. This would cost nursing homes $349 million per year and would increase annual costs for residents by almost $2,180. In the Sunflower State, that would rise to an additional $2,600 in resident costs each year. To meet the rule’s minimum staffing ratio requirement, an additional 12,639 RNs and 76,376 CNAs would be needed nationwide, costing nursing homes $4.2 billion per year at an average cost of $13.24 per resident per day. So, implementing the two parts of this rule would require upwards of 15,000 new RNs, plus more than 76,000 CNAs.

These numbers put nursing homes in a catch-22. Implementing the rule will cost money that most nursing homes don’t have. But even if money were not a problem, it wouldn’t solve the workforce issues. Remarkably, the CMS rule does nothing to address either of these concerns and help facilities find a way forward.

CMS has actually made it more difficult for long-term care facilities to comply by narrowly defining the type of staff that qualifies toward the requirement. Inexplicably, the CMS rule excludes licensed practical nurses (LPNs) from counting toward the minimum. By leaving out a fully credentialed and licensed type of nurse that has long been present in nursing homes, CMS further shrinks the already limited workforce facilities have to lean on.

Instead of their heavy-handed approach, the president and his administration should take a step back. They should let Congress, representing America’s senior citizens, drive the conversation. There are innovative solutions coming from within the People’s House that address the workforce, Medicare and other issues associated with giving seniors the best possible care.

In fact, I proposed one such solution in May. The bipartisan Ensuring Seniors’ Access to Quality Care Act addresses a critical shortage of CNAs who, unlike LPNs, count toward the minimum staffing requirement. The bill allows nursing homes that have been forced to suspend in-house CNA education programs, due to restrictions from violations, to resume those programs once quality standards are again met.

This is a commonsense bill. It accounts for the current workforce challenges nursing homes face without compromising on a commitment to quality care for residents.

In-house CNA programs, often free, offer a pathway to certification for qualified candidates who may not be able to afford an outside program or who do not live near such a program or school. Through these programs, nursing homes can attract, retain and build a pipeline of skilled staff.

At a time when employees, much less highly skilled employees, are hard to come by and the cost of school is prohibitive for many, every effort should be made to keep in-house CNA programs running. If a facility has corrected the deficiency for which it received a penalty, it would be allowed to resume its training of CNAs with additional oversight if deemed necessary.

Legislative solutions like this are needed before CMS proceeds with any federal minimum staffing rule. It is imperative that the Biden administration holds off on implementing this rule until sufficient plans are put in place to build up the necessary workforce to satisfy staffing ratios like this.

The Biden administration should join Congress in doing the hard work to address these issues and support seniors instead of trying to bend reality to fit their whims.

Ron Estes, one of only a handful of engineers in Congress, worked in the aerospace, energy and manufacturing sectors before representing Kansas’ 4th District since 2017. He is a fifth-generation Kansan, former state treasurer, and serves on the House Committee on Ways and Means, Budget Committee, and Education and the Workforce Committee.

For the latest news, weather, sports, and streaming video, head to The Hill.

OTHER NEWS

13 minutes ago

Former TikTok CEO Kevin Mayer says AI hype is at an all-time fever pitch right now

13 minutes ago

Families of Marines who died in an Osprey crash sue Bell Textron, Boeing and Rolls-Royce, makers of the aircraft

13 minutes ago

Thai town maddened by marauding monkeys launches plan to lock them up and send them away

16 minutes ago

Bayern Munich star 'has a desire to play for another club' as the German giants close in on appointing Vincent Kompany as their new manager

16 minutes ago

Stefano Pioli will LEAVE AC Milan at the end of the season after five years in charge as Serie A giants prepare to finish nearly 20 points behind rivals Inter

16 minutes ago

Hiker cheats death while being mauled by grizzly bear after the enraged beast bites through his pepper spray canister during frenzied attack on Wyoming mountain trail

16 minutes ago

Why West Ham should be worried about Lucas Paqueta's charges - Kynan Isaac was banned for 10 YEARS for spot fixing and Bradley Wood couldn't play for six years after FA Cup offences

16 minutes ago

The staggering amount Luke Littler has earned in darts ALREADY after 17-year-old sensation bagged £275,000 from his Premier League final triumph over Luke Humphries

17 minutes ago

'Cherished' BBC sitcom making epic return in 'dream come true' for Lee Mack

17 minutes ago

Club now plotting third Everton exit blow alongside Branthwaite and Onana

17 minutes ago

4-2-3-1 manager who shocked Ten Hag now a "serious" target for Man Utd job

17 minutes ago

Liverpool to share £997m FORTUNE as Taylor Swift Eras Tour arrives at Anfield

18 minutes ago

Three La Liga talking points ahead of final weekend

18 minutes ago

Inter Miami’s Lionel Messi, Luis Suárez, Sergio Busquets won't play vs. Vancouver Saturday

18 minutes ago

Aviva’s share price is tipped to rise 17%! Time to buy?

18 minutes ago

2024 Detroit Lions Week 1 OTA observations: Positional breakdown

18 minutes ago

AI in the Enterprise

19 minutes ago

Ferrari's New Electric Supercar 'Unique': CEO

20 minutes ago

Channel 4 To Air Episodes Of Hit Podcast ‘The Rest Is Politics’ In General Election Run-Up

21 minutes ago

A mega-gift for an HBCU college fell through. Here's what happened — and what's next

23 minutes ago

Meet Dickie's new squeeze! Richard Wilkins holds hands with celebrity  makeup artist Mia Hawkswell after his split with long-time love Nicola Dale

23 minutes ago

Cher, 78, turns back time as she wows in cut-out leotard and permed wig at the amFar Gala - more than 30 years after debuting the look

24 minutes ago

Astronomers Discover Stars from the Universe's Beginning at the Edge of the Milky Way

24 minutes ago

China launches LLM based on Xi Jingping Thought

24 minutes ago

Luke Littler gains revenge to secure Premier League title

25 minutes ago

Nvidia earnings closed out earnings season, says Virtus' Joe Terranova

25 minutes ago

Post Market Wrap: May 23, 2024

25 minutes ago

2024 NBA Finals: Dates, schedule and how to watch NBA championship series

25 minutes ago

Manchester Arena bombing victim’s mother ‘feels misled’ after Sunak meeting

25 minutes ago

Is Barcelona vs Lyon on TV? Channel, kick-off time and how to watch Women’s Champions League final

25 minutes ago

Washout for UK retailers in pre-election blow for Rishi Sunak

25 minutes ago

Taiwan protesters gather as Bill aimed at curbing President’s powers moves ahead

25 minutes ago

New inter-ministerial committee to review S’pore business rules and help firms cut red tape, costs

25 minutes ago

Paul Weller enjoyed 'singing some else's lyrics' on latest LP 66

25 minutes ago

Israeli Minister for Strategic Affairs praised for 'brilliantly' handling ABC interview

26 minutes ago

A British neonatal nurse convicted of killing 7 babies loses her bid to appeal

26 minutes ago

Harris announces plans to help give 80% of Africa access to the internet by 2030, up from 40% now

30 minutes ago

Alisha Lehmann shows off her impressive skills as she enjoys down time in Rio de Janeiro with Aston Villa boyfriend Douglas Luiz... with the couple posing for loved-up snaps ahead of international duty

30 minutes ago

Sarah Ferguson orders Cannes Film Festival audience to be 'quiet' and tells them off for 'looking for the next party' when they should be worrying about the climate

30 minutes ago

Laura Linney, Justin Kurzel, Ben Semanoff to Direct Jason Bateman & Jude Law's Netflix Series ‘Black Rabbit'