The barrister acting for Ben Roberts-Smith in his high-stakes defamation appeal has cautioned a court against “amateur sleuthing” as he urged a trio of judges to overturn a devastating decision dismissing the war veteran’s lawsuit.
Sydney silk Bret Walker, SC, who has acted in a string of high-profile appeals, delivered submissions in reply on Friday after The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald argued the Full Court of the Federal Court should not overturn Justice Anthony Besanko’s decision from last year. It marked the final day of the 10-day appeal and the court reserved its decision.
Ben Roberts-Smith leaving the Federal Court in Sydney in 2021.
Besanko last June found the newspapers had proven to the civil standard – on the balance of probabilities – that Roberts-Smith was complicit in the murder of four unarmed prisoners while on deployment in Afghanistan between 2009 and 2012. This is lower than the criminal standard of beyond reasonable doubt. Roberts-Smith maintains his innocence.
Walker said “the heart of our case” was that “weight is to be given to the presumption of innocence” and “exactness of proof is expected”. In this case, “you certainly don’t have that”, Walker told the three-judge bench of the evidence marshalled by the newspapers.
“Of course it is possible in a case such as the present for the court to think there is something in the allegations brought against the person in question,” Walker said.
But he said it was also possible that, notwithstanding any misgivings, “there cannot be a finding with the sufficient degree of cogency required” in light of the gravity of the allegations.
Addressing one alleged murder, Walker said: “There is absolutely no evidence on the basis of which there can or should be amateur sleuthing in this court, I say that with great respect, concerning the scatter or otherwise of blood on things thought to be, or posited to be, held by a person who’s been shot.”
He said there was “simply no evidentiary basis for any of that”.
During Friday’s hearing, Walker was asked a series of questions by the court concerning findings made by Besanko that were not the subject of a challenge by Roberts-Smith’s team in the appeal.
He agreed the Roberts-Smith camp did not challenge the judge’s findings that a serving Special Air Service soldier dubbed Person 18, one of the newspapers’ witnesses, was honest and reliable.
However, Walker said later that “the fact that we don’t challenge something doesn’t mean … that my client accepts anything”, and the court could take it that “my client doesn’t accept that he lied”.
“Lest there be any doubt, can I spell that out,” he said.
The appeal court will deliver its decision at a later date.
Start the day with a summary of the day’s most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up for our Morning Edition newsletter.
News Related
-
-
-
FILE PHOTO: A man walks in the Central Business District on a rainy day, in Beijing, China, July 12, 2023. REUTERS/Thomas Peter/File Photo By Joe Cash, Ellen Zhang and Kane Wu BEIJING/HONG KONG (Reuters) – U.S. furniture company head Jordan England thinks his firm’s Chinese suppliers are among the best ...
See Details:
Analysis-West's de-risking starts to bite China's prospects
-
Independent senators are trying a parliamentary tactic last successful 90 years ago to give first responders PTSD protections and end domestic violence discrimination in the workplace. Senators Jacqui Lambie and David Pocock took four elements of Labor’s larger workplace law reform bill and it passed the Senate against the government’s ...
See Details:
'Beyond a joke' Labor won't ensure PTSD protections: MP
-
-
-
-
Photograph: Rod McGuirk/AP The stateless Rohingyan refugee who successfully overturned the legality of indefinite immigration detention was accidentally named in documents published by the high court. The man was identified by his surname in a home affairs department email providing an internal update about the case, which was among documents ...
See Details:
Rohingyan refugee NZYQ accidentally named in documents published by high court
-
Photograph: Rod McGuirk/AP The stateless Rohingyan refugee who successfully overturned the legality of indefinite immigration detention was accidentally named in documents published by the high court. The man was identified by his surname in a home affairs department email providing an internal update about the case, which was among documents ...
See Details:
Colorado loses commitments of 2 more high school recruits
-
Photograph: Rod McGuirk/AP The stateless Rohingyan refugee who successfully overturned the legality of indefinite immigration detention was accidentally named in documents published by the high court. The man was identified by his surname in a home affairs department email providing an internal update about the case, which was among documents ...
See Details:
Queensland Health issues urgent patient safety alert over national bacteria outbreak
-
Photograph: Rod McGuirk/AP The stateless Rohingyan refugee who successfully overturned the legality of indefinite immigration detention was accidentally named in documents published by the high court. The man was identified by his surname in a home affairs department email providing an internal update about the case, which was among documents ...
See Details:
Townsville Community Pantry 'distressed' by fruit, vegetable waste at Aldi supermarket
-
Photograph: Rod McGuirk/AP The stateless Rohingyan refugee who successfully overturned the legality of indefinite immigration detention was accidentally named in documents published by the high court. The man was identified by his surname in a home affairs department email providing an internal update about the case, which was among documents ...
See Details:
What Is The Beaver Moon And What Does It Mean For You?
-
Photograph: Rod McGuirk/AP The stateless Rohingyan refugee who successfully overturned the legality of indefinite immigration detention was accidentally named in documents published by the high court. The man was identified by his surname in a home affairs department email providing an internal update about the case, which was among documents ...
See Details:
Labor senator Pat Dodson to resign from politics due to health issues
-
Photograph: Rod McGuirk/AP The stateless Rohingyan refugee who successfully overturned the legality of indefinite immigration detention was accidentally named in documents published by the high court. The man was identified by his surname in a home affairs department email providing an internal update about the case, which was among documents ...
See Details:
Hamas releases 11 more hostages, as Israel agrees to extend ceasefire
OTHER NEWS
Disrupt Burrup Hub group say police have issued move-on notices prohibiting access to the WA site. A group of climate activists and filmmakers say their phones have been seized during ...
Read more »
As individuals, we have unique experiences that affect our mental health and wellbeing, but what about the collective experiences that influence each generation? The mental health of Australians has been ...
Read more »
Syed Ghazaly wants to see the Geraldton abattoir reopen early next year to process 1,000 sheep a day. (ABC Mid West Wheatbelt: Chris Lewis) The new owners of a mothballed ...
Read more »
Carlton coach Michael Voss says he and his players understand there are heightened expectations on them, but insists the Blues are ready to develop individually and in their game plan. ...
Read more »
The Bulldogs’ off-season signing frenzy is set to continue with the club reportedly set to land Cronnor Tracey in a swap deal. The Sydney Morning Herald reports Tracey is expected ...
Read more »
Consumers and impacted businesses are being urged to have their say on the Optus outage, with the federal government laying out the terms of reference for its review into the ...
Read more »
It has been revealed a released immigration detainee is unable to be contacted by authorities. Border Force has referred the matter to the Federal Police as authorities are attempting to ...
Read more »